Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board
Published
On this page
BMC Surgery is an open access, peer-reviewed journal published by BioMed Central, part of Springer Nature, covering surgical research, training and practice. Its electronic ISSN is 1471-2482. For authors and readers, the key checks are the journal’s identity, its NLM indexing record, and the publication policies that apply to a particular manuscript.
Ask CASRAI · free to tryQuestion about this guide? Ask CASRAI answers with linked sources. 2 free questions a day, no account.
What it is
The BMC Surgery journal homepage brings together published articles, collections, author guidance and journal information. The journal is the publication; Springer Nature Link is the website through which readers reach that material. This distinction matters when recording a reference or following a submission link: the journal title identifies the publication, while the hosting platform identifies where it is presented.
The National Library of Medicine Catalog record gives the title abbreviation BMC Surg, the electronic ISSN and a publication start year of 2001. Those identifiers provide a more precise identity check than a journal name alone. The data table below combines these bibliographic details with separately documented publishing policies, so a researcher or research office can distinguish what each source actually establishes.
Who runs it and what it covers
The publisher identifies the journal with BioMed Central Ltd., part of Springer Nature. Its aims and scope include observational and interventional studies involving adults and children, along with surgical outcomes, diagnostics, epidemiology, training, guidelines and the organization of surgical services. A submission therefore needs a clear connection to surgical research or practice; a broad medical topic alone does not establish that connection.
The named sections cover trauma and orthopedic surgery, vascular and thoracic surgery, visceral and general surgery, and cancer surgery. Collections bring together work on particular developing topics. These are useful ways to assess subject overlap, rather than evidence that every manuscript within a specialty will be accepted.
As a BMC Series journal, BMC Surgery describes its assessment in terms of scientific validity rather than a study’s perceived interest or potential impact. For research articles, it specifies a sound research question, suitable methods and analysis, and relevant community standards. Editorial fit and methodological adequacy remain separate checks: a manuscript can address surgery while still needing a stronger design or clearer reporting.
How to search or use it
The journal’s own pages provide the following route from finding an article to preparing a submission. These are navigation and preparation steps, using the labels published on the website.
- Start with the journal homepage. Match the title and electronic ISSN against the NLM record. Follow the publisher’s journal links when moving to author information or submission.
- Open Articles or use the search field. The website labels its search input for keywords or authors. Use the article results to locate the specific paper you need rather than treating a journal-level description as evidence for that paper’s findings.
- Use Volumes and issues or Collections for browsing. The first is the journal’s archive route; the second groups work by a particular topic. Keep an individual article’s bibliographic details separate from the collection in which it appears.
- Open For authors and Submission guidelines. Choose the guidance for the intended article type. The page lists research articles, study protocols, reviews, systematic reviews and case reports, among other categories.
- Work through Prepare your manuscript and Prepare supporting information. The submission guidelines cover manuscript preparation, author details and cover-letter information. The article-type instructions supply the specific requirements.
- Use Submit your manuscript from the journal page. The guidelines say an author of the manuscript must make the submission; a third party may not submit it. Resolve the applicable funding and licence arrangements during preparation.
Peer review and manuscript requirements
BMC Surgery operates transparent peer review: when an article is published, reviewer reports are published alongside it, but reviewer names are withheld. The journal describes evaluation by typically two or more experts and editorial decisions informed by their reports. Transparent review therefore gives readers access to reports without promising the named-reviewer model associated with open review.
The author guidance calls for editable manuscript files, line and page numbering, and information about all coauthors. The cover letter must address suitability for the journal, relevant policy issues and competing interests, and confirm author approval and the manuscript’s publication/submission position. These declarations should agree with the manuscript and submission information, rather than being treated as a separate administrative formality.
The BMC editorial policies also distinguish ethics approval, consent to participate and consent to publish identifiable information. For human research, the manuscript needs the appropriate ethics statement. Identifiable patient material raises a separate publication-consent requirement. Reporting guidance is linked to study design: the policies identify CONSORT for randomized trials and encourage STROBE, PRISMA and CARE for relevant observational studies, reviews and case reports.
The journal additionally asks manuscripts to explain data availability. A useful data availability statement identifies the data’s location or applicable access conditions; it should describe what readers can actually obtain. The journal guidance calls for machine-readable datasets and appropriate references to publicly available data.
Submission file and data checks
The general file guidance accepts DOC, DOCX, RTF and TeX/LaTeX manuscripts. It says non-editable files such as PDFs will need an editable replacement during revision or after acceptance. For a team preparing the package, retaining the editable source is therefore a concrete preparation task alongside checking the chosen article type’s instructions.
Data access also needs an accurate description. BMC’s policies ask authors to explain restrictions when data cannot be shared openly. Clinical datasets require protection of participant identity and confidentiality. A statement about access should reflect those conditions, rather than promising unrestricted release of sensitive records. Publicly available datasets need a reference containing an accession number or persistent identifier, such as a DOI.
If authors suggest reviewers, the publisher asks for information that helps establish their identity. Its wider policy excludes recent collaborators and colleagues at the same institution from author suggestions. Preparing that list is distinct from choosing the reviewers: the editor retains discretion over whom to invite.
Open access, publication fees and licences
The publisher’s publishing and funding page describes an article processing charge for accepted articles, determined at acceptance. Open access concerns access for readers; the article publication charge concerns how publication is funded. These are different questions when planning a submission.
BMC Surgery participates in a country-tiered APC pilot. The page says this supersedes the generic waiver and discount provisions for corresponding authors in low- and lower-middle-income economies where the pilot applies. Institutional agreements may cover publication subject to eligibility. Discretionary support requests must be made at submission; the publisher says requests during review or after acceptance cannot be considered.
The listed article licences are CC BY 4.0 and CC BY-NC-ND 4.0, with authors retaining copyright. CC BY permits adaptation and commercial reuse with attribution; CC BY-NC-ND permits attributed non-commercial sharing, with permission required for commercial reuse or sharing adaptations. The selected Creative Commons licence therefore matters alongside funding, especially when a funder requires a particular reuse permission.
Indexing, publication pattern and metrics
NLM’s own catalog identifies BMC Surgery as currently indexed for MEDLINE and records MEDLINE and PubMed coverage beginning with volume 1 in 2001, together with PMC coverage. It also states that articles are added consecutively to the current annual volume. That publication pattern should not be rewritten as a monthly issue schedule.
For a research record, keep journal identity and article discovery separate. The electronic ISSN identifies the serial; the article’s own title, authors and identifier locate the item being cited. The distinction between PubMed and PubMed Central is useful when documenting where a citation can be found and where full text is held.
The publisher displays a Journal Impact Factor of 2.4 for 2025 and a five-year Journal Impact Factor of 2.2 for 2025. It also displays a median of 16 days from submission to first decision. Keep the metric year attached to the values, and keep the decision statistic attached to its stated endpoint. Neither supplies an acceptance probability or an individual manuscript’s publication date.
Strengths and limits
For a reader comparing surgical research, the journal combines broad subject coverage, open access to articles and a transparent-review policy. Those features support different tasks: scope helps identify relevant work, access enables reading, and reviewer reports provide another part of the published record to examine.
For an author, broad scope still requires a specific account of how the study meets the journal’s criteria. Open access also leaves funding and licence decisions to resolve. A publisher’s journal-level metric describes a different aspect of the publication from the design and reporting of any single study.
A practical approach is to maintain separate notes for subject fit, manuscript readiness, funding and reuse permissions. This is an editorial way to organize the publisher’s requirements, rather than an additional journal rule. It makes gaps visible before a team treats a promising journal title as a completed submission decision.
Alternatives
The alternatives below are compared by their published subject coverage. They are starting points for checking fit, without a ranking or prediction of editorial decisions.
| Journal | Published subject focus | Scope comparison |
|---|---|---|
| BMC Surgery | Surgical research, training and practice across several specialties. | A broad surgical frame, including service organization and outcomes. |
| Journal of Cardiothoracic Surgery | Clinical and experimental cardiac, vascular and thoracic research; relevant respiratory medicine. | A more focused cardiothoracic and vascular readership. |
| World Journal of Emergency Surgery | Clinical and basic research on traumatic and non-traumatic emergency surgery and related subjects. | A more focused emergency, trauma and acute-care frame. |
Illustrative manuscript-selection example: a team studying emergency surgical outcomes could compare the broad remit of BMC Surgery with the emergency-specific remit of World Journal of Emergency Surgery. A team studying a cardiac surgical technique could compare the cardiothoracic journal’s narrower audience. These examples map a hypothetical topic to the stated scopes; they do not establish acceptance or comparative quality.
Common mistakes before citing or submitting
- Using a title without checking identifiers. Record the electronic ISSN and publisher when confirming the journal, then use the individual article’s details for the citation.
- Equating transparent review with named reviewers. The journal’s policy makes reports public while keeping reviewer names anonymous.
- Treating all open access licences as interchangeable. The two listed licences differ in commercial reuse and adaptation permissions.
- Assuming a generic support policy overrides the journal-specific pilot. Read the country-tiered qualification together with institutional eligibility and submission-stage support requirements.
- Confusing a first decision with acceptance. The publisher labels the displayed statistic as a median to first decision, not a deadline for publication.
Sources
- Springer Nature Link: BMC Surgery homepage. Checked 2026-11-15.
- BMC Surgery: Aims and scope. Checked 2026-11-15.
- BMC Surgery: Submission guidelines. Checked 2026-11-15.
- BMC Surgery: How to publish with us. Checked 2026-11-15.
- NLM Catalog: BMC surgery, record 100968567. Checked 2026-11-15.
- BMC: Editorial policies. Checked 2026-11-15.
- Journal of Cardiothoracic Surgery: Aims and scope. Checked 2026-11-15.
- World Journal of Emergency Surgery: Aims and scope. Checked 2026-11-15.
Data: BMC Surgery identity, indexing and publication policies
Original compilation joining the NLM Catalog journal record with BMC Surgery author and funding policies. Each row identifies the primary record supporting its statement; checked on 2026-11-15.
Period covered: 2026-11-15.
| Record or policy | Documented statement | Primary source URL |
|---|---|---|
| Journal identity | Electronic ISSN 1471-2482; NLM title abbreviation BMC Surg | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/nlmcatalog/100968567 |
| Publication pattern | Articles added consecutively to the current annual volume | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/nlmcatalog/100968567 |
| MEDLINE status | Currently indexed for MEDLINE; coverage begins with volume 1, 2001 | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/nlmcatalog/100968567 |
| Peer review | Transparent review: reports accompany published articles without reviewer names | https://link.springer.com/journal/12893/submission-guidelines |
| Publication funding | APC applies to accepted articles; journal participates in country-tiered APC pilot | https://link.springer.com/journal/12893/how-to-publish-with-us |
| Article licences | CC BY 4.0 or CC BY-NC-ND 4.0; authors retain copyright | https://link.springer.com/journal/12893/how-to-publish-with-us |
Sources
- NLM Catalog: BMC surgery, record 100968567 (accessed 2026-11-15)
- BMC Surgery: Submission guidelines (accessed 2026-11-15)
- BMC Surgery: How to publish with us (accessed 2026-11-15)
Compiled by CASRAI from the sources above. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution.







