Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board
Published
On this page
The Constant-Murley score—commonly referred to as the Constant shoulder score or Constant score (CS)—is a 100-point composite clinical outcome instrument introduced by Christopher R. Constant and Alan H.G. Murley in 1987 (Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, based on Constant’s 1986 university thesis) to evaluate overall shoulder functionality after injury, disease, or surgical intervention. Endorsed by the European Society for Surgery of the Shoulder and the Elbow (SECEC / ESSSE) as its gold-standard functional assessment system, the Constant-Murley score is one of the most widely reported primary endpoints in global rotator cuff repair, proximal humeral fracture, subacromial decompression, and shoulder arthroplasty literature.
Unlike purely self-administered patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) such as the 13-item SPADI score or the 12-item Oxford Hip Score, the Constant-Murley score is a hybrid clinician- and patient-assessed instrument (conceptually analogous to the Harris Hip Score in hip orthopaedics): it combines 35 points of subjective patient-reported items with 65 points of objective clinician-measured physical examination.
What Is Constant-Murley Score?
The Constant shoulder score sums four distinct clinical subscales to a maximum total of 100 points, where 100 represents an asymptomatic shoulder with full painless active range of motion and normal isometric abduction strength, and 0 represents worst possible shoulder function:
- Subjective Component (35 Points Total — 35% of Score):
- Pain: Maximum 15 points
- Activities of Daily Living (ADL): Maximum 20 points
- Objective Component (65 Points Total — 65% of Score):
- Range of Motion (Active Painless Mobility): Maximum 40 points
- Power (Isometric Abduction Strength): Maximum 25 points
Detailed Point Breakdown and 2008 SECEC Standardized Protocol
To eliminate inter-observer variability in strength testing and pain scaling, Constant, Gerber, and colleagues published the official SECEC modification and standardization guidelines in 2008 (Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery; Constant et al., 2008;17(2):355-361). Every item is scored strictly according to the following rules:
1. Pain Subscale (15 Points Maximum — Subjective)
Evaluates the most severe pain experienced by the patient during ordinary activities of daily living over a 24-hour period:
- Original 1987 Categorical Scale: No pain = 15 points; Mild pain = 10 points; Moderate pain = 5 points; Severe pain = 0 points.
- 2008 Standardized VAS Scale: Measured on a 15-cm (or 0–15 numeric) visual analog scale where “No pain” receives 15 points and “Intolerable pain” receives 0 points:
Pain Points = 15 − VAS Rating (0 to 15).
2. Activities of Daily Living (ADL) Subscale (20 Points Maximum — Subjective)
Divided into 10 points for daily living/sleep impact and 10 points for painless functional hand positioning:
- Sleep (2 points max): Uninterrupted sleep = 2 points; Intermittent disturbance = 1 point; Disturbance every night = 0 points.
- Work / Daily Routine Limitation (4 points max): No limitation = 4 points down to total limitation = 0 points (graded continuously via VAS in the 2008 guidelines).
- Recreational / Sporting Limitation (4 points max): No limitation = 4 points down to total limitation = 0 points.
- Level of Painless Functional Hand Positioning (10 points max — select highest level achieved):
- Up to waist: 2 points
- Up to xiphoid (sternum): 4 points
- Up to neck: 6 points
- Up to top of head: 8 points
- Above head: 10 points
3. Range of Motion / Active Painless Mobility Subscale (40 Points Maximum — Objective)
The patient must be seated upright to prevent spinal compensation, and only active, painless movement is scored across four planes (10 points each):
| Degrees of Painless Active Elevation ( Measured by Goniometer ) | Forward Elevation (Flexion) Points | Lateral Elevation (Abduction) Points |
|---|---|---|
| 0° to 30° | 0 points | 0 points |
| 31° to 60° | 2 points | 2 points |
| 61° to 90° | 4 points | 4 points |
| 91° to 120° | 6 points | 6 points |
| 121° to 150° | 8 points | 8 points |
| 151° to 180° | 10 points | 10 points |
- Functional External Rotation (10 points max — cumulative, 2 points for each independently completed maneuver):
- Hand behind head with elbow held forward (+2 points)
- Hand behind head with elbow held back (+2 points)
- Hand to top of head with elbow held forward (+2 points)
- Hand to top of head with elbow held back (+2 points)
- Full elevation from top of head (+2 points)
- Functional Internal Rotation (10 points max — select highest anatomical landmark reached by dorsum of hand behind back):
- Lateral aspect of thigh: 0 points
- Buttock: 2 points
- Lumbosacral junction: 4 points
- Waist (L3 spinous process): 6 points
- Twelfth thoracic vertebra (T12): 8 points
- Interscapular region (T7 vertebra): 10 points
4. Power / Isometric Abduction Strength Subscale (25 Points Maximum — Objective)
Under the 2008 Constant-Gerber standardization protocol, strength is measured with an electronic isometric dynamometer (such as an Isobex) or calibrated spring balance:
- The arm is positioned at 90° of abduction in the plane of the scapula (30° anterior to the coronal plane) with the elbow fully extended and the wrist pronated (strap placed at the wrist/distal forearm).
- The patient performs three maximal 5-second isometric contractions, and the highest force in pounds (lbs) is recorded: 1 point per pound of force, up to a maximum of 25 lbs (11.34 kg) = 25 points.
- Critical 90° Abduction Rule: If a patient is unable to actively achieve 90° of abduction in the scapular plane, the patient automatically receives 0 points for the strength domain.
How Is Constant-Murley Score Used in Clinical Research and Healthcare?
Because objective shoulder strength naturally declines with advancing age and differs between men and women, clinical researchers report both the Absolute Constant Score (0–100) and the Age- and Sex-Adjusted (Relative / Normalized) Constant Score (calculated by dividing the patient’s absolute score by the normative population score for their age decade and sex, expressed as a percentage).
- Minimal Clinically Important Difference (MCID): In anchor-based validation studies of patients undergoing arthroscopic rotator cuff repair (Kukkonen et al., 2013, Bone & Joint Journal), the MCID of the Constant-Murley score is 10.4 points (typically rounded to 10 points in clinical trial protocols; distribution- and anchor-based estimates across broader shoulder pathologies range from 6.7 to 12 points).
- Telehealth Adaptation (Auto-Constant / Patient-Assessed Constant Score): Because the 65-point objective exam traditionally requires an in-clinic goniometer and dynamometer, orthopaedic researchers have validated photographic/video-assisted and patient-self-assessed adaptations (such as the Levy / Chelli Auto-Constant score using household weights) that correlate strongly with clinician-measured scores in remote follow-up cohorts.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Constant-Murley score?
The Constant-Murley score (Constant shoulder score) is a 100-point clinical shoulder assessment tool introduced by Constant and Murley in 1987 that combines 35 subjective patient-reported points (15 points for pain and 20 points for activities of daily living) with 65 objective clinician-measured points (40 points for painless active range of motion and 25 points for isometric abduction strength at 90° in the scapular plane). Higher scores indicate better shoulder function (100 = normal).
How is Constant-Murley score used in clinical research and healthcare?
Orthopaedic surgeons and physical therapists use the Constant-Murley score (often normalized for age and sex) to measure functional recovery after rotator cuff repair, proximal humerus fracture fixation, and total shoulder arthroplasty. In clinical trials, an improvement of approximately 10 points (10.4 points in Kukkonen et al.’s anchor analysis) represents the Minimal Clinically Important Difference (MCID).







