Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board
Published
On this page
The Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics Evidence Analysis Library (EAL, at andeal.org) is a collection of systematic reviews and evidence-based nutrition practice guidelines on food and nutrition questions, run by the Academy and published since 2004. Each review ends in conclusion statements that carry a Grade from I (good/strong) to V (not assignable), so a reader can see how much evidence stands behind a recommendation. It is a curated synthesis resource, not a general literature database.
New to the field itself? The definition lives in What is nutrition science?; this page covers the EAL as a research-practice tool: who maintains it, how its grading works, how it is accessed, and how it differs from the USDA’s similarly named review programme.
What the Evidence Analysis Library is
The EAL describes itself as answering food and nutrition questions with systematic reviews since 2004. Its content falls into three groups: evidence-based nutrition practice guidelines, systematic reviews on named topics (the home page lists diabetes, hypertension, celiac disease, oncology, malnutrition and vegetarian nutrition among them), and collaborative guidelines and position statements. According to its About page it was developed by Academy members, launched in 2004 with three topics, and by the time of that page’s text held nearly 40 projects in various stages, with guidelines updated every five years.
The unit of the library is the evidence analysis question. Each question is answered by a written conclusion statement and a Grade, backed by bibliographies, evidence summaries and worksheets that the workgroup produced while reviewing the studies.
Who runs it and how a review is built
The Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics operates the EAL. Workgroup members evaluate, synthesize and grade the evidence, guided by the Academy’s Evidence Analysis Manual, which describes a five-step process and includes the Academy’s risk-of-bias tool. The manual is written for expert workgroup members and evidence analysts, and a PDF of the 2016 edition (107 pages) is linked from the manual page, which was last updated on 9 November 2022. The 2012 edition names the fifth step as writing and grading the conclusion statement.
Researchers who want to appraise the reviews themselves can compare this process with the checklist in the AMSTAR 2 guide to critically appraising systematic reviews. Because many of the EAL’s questions rest on observational and intervention studies of diet, the design vocabulary in nutritional epidemiology is the useful background for reading the study-design terms the library uses.
What is an evidence analysis?
An evidence analysis, as the Academy uses the term, is a systematic review of the studies that bear on one nutrition question, finished by a graded conclusion statement. The EAL supplies a Glossary of Study Designs and an EAL Terminology page so that the terms in a conclusion statement have fixed meanings.
The grade scale
The EAL grades the strength of the evidence behind each conclusion statement. The data table below lists the five grades and what each means, as the library’s Conclusion Statements Grade Chart defines them. In brief, Grade I rests on studies of strong design with consistent, clinically important results; Grade II either has strong designs with some uncertainty (inconsistent results, bias, design flaws or small samples) or weaker designs confirmed by separate studies; Grade III rests on a limited number of weak-design studies; Grade IV is solely the clinical experience of informed commentators; and Grade V means no evidence is available that directly supports or refutes the conclusion.
The practical reading rule is that a Grade V is a statement about the literature, not about the nutrient or food: it says the question has not been answered, not that the answer is no. The library also publishes a Recommendations Rating Chart for the practice recommendations that follow from conclusions.
How to find and use the content
The library does not need a login to explore its structure. These are the routes the site itself provides:
- Open the home page at andeal.org and use the Projects menu to see the guideline and review projects.
- Use the EAL Topic List to browse by subject area.
- Use the A-Z Index to find a known topic by name.
- Open the review or guideline and read the conclusion statement together with its Grade, then the supporting evidence summary and worksheets.
- Read the Evidence Analysis Manual, EAL Terminology, Glossary of Study Designs and Conclusion Statements Grade Chart before citing a conclusion, so the Grade is interpreted as the library defines it.
- The Orientation Tutorial is the library’s own introduction for new users. The sign-in link is on the home page.
Reading a conclusion statement
Treat a conclusion statement as three parts: the claim, its Grade, and the supporting studies listed in the evidence summary. Two statements can sound equally firm and still differ in certainty. A Grade II statement signals that either the strongest designs showed some uncertainty or weaker designs agreed across separate studies, so the reader should look at which of those applies before relying on it. A Grade IV statement rests only on informed commentators’ clinical experience, so it should be reported as expert opinion and not as research evidence. When you cite the EAL in a paper or protocol, record the Grade, the topic and the date you read it, since guidelines are updated about every five years.
Access model
Academy members have free full access. Non-members and groups can subscribe, and some content is free to the public. For a team that needs reproducible citations, it is worth checking which of the two access routes covers the guideline you need before planning around it.
Strengths and limits
- Strength: every conclusion carries an explicit, published Grade and a documented method, so the certainty of a claim is visible.
- Strength: the topics are written to support practice, which links naturally to documentation workflows such as the ADIME note.
- Limit: coverage is topic-by-topic; the library holds nearly 40 projects, not the whole nutrition literature.
- Limit: reviews follow a guideline update cycle of about five years, so a conclusion reflects the evidence at its review date.
- Limit: full access depends on membership or subscription.
Alternatives and the “Nutrition Evidence Library” confusion
The Academy’s EAL is often mistaken for the USDA’s Nutrition Evidence Library. The USDA programme, now called the Nutrition Evidence Systematic Review (NESR), was formerly the Nutrition Evidence Library (NEL) and was renamed in 2019. Its team sits within the Center for Nutrition Policy and Promotion at USDA’s Food and Nutrition Service, and it conducts food and nutrition systematic reviews used to inform US federal guidelines, including the Dietary Guidelines for Americans. NESR’s methodology includes a step that grades the strength of the evidence behind conclusion statements. For a dietary-quality measure that sits downstream of the Dietary Guidelines, see the Healthy Eating Index guide.
| Feature | Academy EAL | USDA NESR |
|---|---|---|
| Operated by | Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics | NESR team, Center for Nutrition Policy and Promotion, USDA Food and Nutrition Service |
| Earlier name | Evidence Analysis Library, from 2004 | Nutrition Evidence Library, renamed NESR in 2019 |
| Main purpose | Practice guidelines and systematic reviews for nutrition practice | Systematic reviews informing US federal guidelines and programmes |
| Grading | Grade I to V on conclusion statements | Grades the strength of evidence behind conclusion statements |
| Methods document | Evidence Analysis Manual (five-step process) | NESR Methodology Manual (February 2023) |
Methods literature to read alongside
Two peer-reviewed papers from the USDA team document how a federal nutrition review programme grades and governs its work, which is a useful reference when comparing it with the Academy’s approach. The first is the 2022 Advances in Nutrition perspective on grading the strength of evidence in nutrition and public health systematic reviews, by Spill, English, Raghavan and colleagues, written by members of the NESR team in the Nutrition Guidance and Analysis Division of the Center for Nutrition Policy and Promotion. It states that the grading step is critical so that end users understand the level of certainty in conclusions when using them to make decisions. The second is the 2023 Frontiers in Nutrition article by Obbagy, Raghavan, Cole and colleagues, on NESR’s collaborative approach to conducting systematic reviews, promoting diversity of expertise while managing potential conflicts of interest.
The EAL’s own equivalents are the Evidence Analysis Manual and the Glossary of Study Designs. A researcher writing a methods section that relies on either programme should cite the specific manual edition used, since the Academy’s manual page shows an update date of 9 November 2022 and links a 2016 PDF edition.
Frequently asked questions
What is an evidence analysis?
It is the Academy’s term for a systematic review of the studies on one nutrition question, ending in a conclusion statement with a Grade from I to V.
What are the most reliable evidence-based sources?
Reliability is easier to judge when a source publishes its method and grades its conclusions. The EAL and NESR both do: each documents its review process in a manual and each grades the strength of evidence. Appraise any review, including these, with a checklist such as AMSTAR 2.
What are some reliable websites for nutrition information?
For graded, systematic-review evidence: andeal.org (Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics) and nesr.usda.gov (USDA). For methods to judge any other site, use the appraisal guide linked above.
What are the two main types of library databases?
This is an editorial framing, not a statement from the EAL: databases that index citations and abstracts of the literature, and databases that supply full-text documents. The EAL is neither; it supplies reviewed conclusions with their Grades, built from literature found elsewhere.
Is the Academy EAL the same as the USDA Nutrition Evidence Library?
No. They are separate programmes run by separate organisations; the USDA one is now called NESR.
Sources
- Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, Evidence Analysis Library home, About, Conclusion Statements Grade Chart and Evidence Analysis Manual, read 2026-11-21.
- Spill MK, English LK, Raghavan R, et al. USDA Nutrition Evidence Systematic Review methodology: grading the strength of evidence. Advances in Nutrition 2022;13(4):982-991, read 2026-11-21.
- Obbagy J, Raghavan R, Cole NC, et al. USDA Nutrition Evidence Systematic Review’s collaborative approach for conducting systematic reviews: promoting diversity of expertise while managing potential conflicts of interest. Frontiers in Nutrition 2023, PMC9996304, read 2026-11-21.
Data: Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics EAL conclusion statement grades I to V
The five grades the Evidence Analysis Library assigns to conclusion statements, with the evidence basis each requires, compiled from the library's Conclusion Statements Grade Chart.
Coverage: United States.
| Grade | Label | Evidence basis |
|---|---|---|
| I | Good/Strong | Studies of strong design with consistent, clinically important results |
| II | Fair | Strong design with some uncertainty (inconsistent results, bias, design flaws, sample size), or weaker designs confirmed by separate studies |
| III | Limited | A limited number of weak-design studies |
| IV | Expert Opinion Only | Solely the clinical experience of informed commentators |
| V | Not Assignable | No evidence available that directly supports or refutes the conclusion |
Sources
- Conclusion Statements Grade Chart, Evidence Analysis Library (accessed 2026-11-21)
Compiled by CASRAI from the sources above. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution.







