Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board
Published
On this page
The Law and History Review is the official peer-reviewed quarterly academic journal of the American Society for Legal History (ASLH), published by Cambridge University Press since 1983. Specializing in the social history of law, the evolution of legal ideas, and the historical development of legal institutions across American, European, ancient, and global contexts, the journal provides an international venue for rigorous historical legal scholarship. Unlike student-edited American law reviews, Law and History Review operates a faculty-refereed, double-anonymous peer review system, enforces a strict single-submission policy, and caps research manuscripts at an 11,000-word limit.
What Is Law and History Review? Institutional Identity and History
Established in 1983, Law and History Review (LHR) serves as the flagship publication of the American Society for Legal History (ASLH), an international scholarly society founded in 1956 to foster interdisciplinary research and teaching in legal history. Published quarterly by Cambridge University Press, the journal bridges the disciplines of history and law, providing a forum where historians, legal scholars, social scientists, and jurists analyze legal institutions, doctrines, and cultural practices from historical perspectives.
The journal appears under Print ISSN 0738-2480 and Online ISSN 1939-9022. It publishes four issues per volume annually, featuring original research articles, review essays, symposia, and scholarly forums. In addition to its print and digital journal issues, the ASLH and Cambridge University Press support The Docket, an open-access digital companion hosted at lawandhistoryreview.org. The Docket publishes shorter essays, forum discussions, pedagogical resources, and book discussions (typically 1,000 to 2,500 words), complementing the long-form archival scholarship found in the journal itself.
Editorial leadership is vested in an Editor-in-Chief supported by Associate Editors and an international Editorial Board composed of distinguished legal historians. The editorial team oversees manuscript triage, peer review coordination, and thematic curation, ensuring adherence to high standards of historical evidence, archival rigor, and conceptual depth.
Peer-Reviewed Scholarly Journal vs. Student-Edited Law Reviews
For scholars trained in legal academia, navigating the differences between Law and History Review and conventional American law reviews is essential. Most law reviews affiliated with US law schools are edited by second- and third-year law students. These student-run reviews rely on simultaneous multiple submissions submitted through platforms like Scholastica, undergo rolling evaluations during high-volume February and August submission windows, and regularly publish manuscripts running between 20,000 and 30,000 words. Researchers submitting to those venues should consult the guide to Scholastica law review submissions for details on rolling legal submission mechanics.
By contrast, Law and History Review adheres strictly to the conventions of academic humanities and social science publishing. Understanding these structural differences prevents immediate desk rejection and ensures proper submission preparation:
- Single-Submission Mandate: LHR strictly prohibits simultaneous submissions. A manuscript submitted to LHR cannot be under consideration by any other journal or law review. Multiple submissions result in automatic disqualification.
- Faculty Peer Review: Submissions are evaluated by established scholars through an advisory peer review workflow rather than student editorial boards. Referees are subject-matter specialists in the relevant period, geography, and legal tradition.
- Hard Word-Count Ceilings: While student-edited law reviews tolerate expansive treatments, LHR enforces a strict ceiling of 11,000 words, including all footnotes, tables, and figures.
- Citation Mechanics: LHR does not use the Bluebook citation system favored by student-edited law reviews; instead, it uses a modified Chicago Manual of Style framework.
- Year-Round Evaluation: Submissions are accepted and processed continuously throughout the year rather than concentrated in seasonal submission windows.
Editorial Scope and Article Types
The editorial scope of Law and History Review encompasses the broad spectrum of legal history across all geographical regions and chronological eras. Rather than limiting coverage to statutory doctrine or appellate jurisprudence, the journal emphasizes the social history of law, the cultural dimensions of legal practices, and the interaction between legal systems and broader political, economic, and institutional transformations. Work on American, European, Latin American, Asian, African, and ancient legal history is actively welcomed.
The journal considers several distinct categories of submissions, each governed by specific length and formatting requirements:
- Original Research Articles: Substantial archival, doctrinal, or theoretical contributions to legal history. Manuscripts must not exceed 11,000 words, inclusive of all text, footnotes, tables, and figure captions. Manuscripts that exceed the 11,000-word limit are desk-rejected without peer review.
- Review Essays: Critical examinations of emerging subfields, historiographical debates, or thematic clusters centered around significant recent monographs or proceedings. Review essays are capped at 5,000 words, including notes.
- Forums and Special Issues: Curated thematic collections exploring specific historical problems or methodological debates. Prospective forum organizers should submit a preliminary proposal directly to the Editor-in-Chief before submitting formal manuscripts.
- Book Reviews: Critical evaluations of individual scholarly books. LHR does not accept unsolicited book reviews; all book reviews are commissioned directly by the journal’s Book Review Editors.
Indexing, Impact Factor, and Citation Metrics
Law and History Review is indexed across the primary citation indexes and bibliographic databases in the humanities and social sciences. This extensive indexing ensures global discoverability and provides tracked citation metrics for institutional assessment, tenure evaluations, and research benchmarking.
Key indexing registries include:
- Clarivate Web of Science: Indexed in the Core Collection under both the Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI) and the Arts & Humanities Citation Index (AHCI).
- Elsevier Scopus: Comprehensive coverage for citation tracking and journal benchmarking, where performance is tracked via CiteScore metrics and SCImago journal rankings.
- Subject and Legal Databases: Full-text indexing in HeinOnline, JSTOR, LexisNexis, Historical Abstracts, and the Index to Legal Periodicals and Books.
According to official Cambridge Core metrics, the journal maintains the following evaluated benchmarks:
- 2-Year Journal Impact Factor: 1.1
- 5-Year Impact Factor: 1.3
- Scopus CiteScore: 1.1
- SCImago Journal Rank (SJR): 0.193
- Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP): 1.365
- Eigenfactor Score: 0.00128
- Article Influence Score: 1.037
These metrics place Law and History Review consistently in the upper quartiles among specialized history and legal history journals worldwide.
Manuscript Preparation and Author Guidelines
Preparing a manuscript for Law and History Review requires rigorous adherence to the journal’s technical guidelines. Failure to conform to word limits, citation rules, or anonymization protocols can lead to administrative rejection prior to editorial review.
Authors should observe the following structural standards when formatting their files:
- Submission File Separation: Authors must submit three separate files via the online submission portal:
- Title Page: Contains the article title, author names, institutional affiliations, physical and email addresses, and any author notes or acknowledgments.
- Anonymized Abstract: A standalone document containing an abstract of no more than 200 words summarizing the central argument and scholarly contribution, completely free of author identification.
- Anonymized Manuscript: The complete text with notes and tables, fully stripped of authorial names, self-identifying references, and institutional metadata.
- Length Ceiling: The entire manuscript—including main text, footnotes, table text, and figure captions—must not exceed 11,000 words.
- Typography and Spacing: Double-space all text, including notes; maintain 1-inch margins on all sides; use standard 12-point font; and consecutively paginate the entire draft. Do not right-justify text or indent endnotes.
- Subheadings: The journal permits a maximum of two levels of subheadings. Generic subheadings such as “Introduction” or “Part I” are prohibited; “Conclusion” may be used where appropriate.
- Modified Chicago Citation Style: LHR follows a modified Chicago Manual of Style notes system:
- Provide full bibliographic details on first mention in footnotes; use shortened citations (author last name, short title, page) for subsequent references.
- Do not use parenthetical in-text citations.
- Do not italicize common Latin words or abbreviations (such as ibid., et al., laissez-faire, vis-a-vis).
- Use two hyphens without surrounding spaces for em dashes.
- Accessibility Compliance: Per Cambridge University Press standards, all figures, charts, and maps must meet WCAG 2.1 AA accessibility guidelines, requiring descriptive alt-text submitted via the Accessibility Descriptions Form.
- Generative AI Usage: Minimal uses of AI for copy-editing or spelling checks do not require declaration, but any substantive or generative assistance in drafting must be formally declared in the methodology or acknowledgments.
Peer Review Architecture and Decision Workflow
The evaluation workflow at Law and History Review operates on a double-anonymous review model, ensuring impartiality by concealing author identities from reviewers and reviewer identities from authors. A comprehensive overview of how peer review systems evolved across scholarly disciplines can be found in CASRAI’s analysis of the history of peer review.
The manuscript evaluation follows five defined stages:
- Initial Editorial Triage: Upon submission through ScholarOne Manuscripts, the Editor-in-Chief assesses the manuscript for alignment with the journal’s scope, adherence to the 11,000-word limit, and sufficient scholarly contribution. Manuscripts lacking historical depth or violating length rules are declined at this stage.
- External Referee Assignment: Manuscripts passing triage are assigned to two or more external specialist referees, frequently in consultation with Associate Editors or Editorial Board members.
- Advisory Peer Review: Referees evaluate historical rigor, archival evidence, engagement with relevant literature, and clarity of argument. The peer review process typically takes up to five months. Referees provide written evaluations and recommendation ratings.
- Editorial Determination: Peer review reports are advisory; the Editor-in-Chief serves as the final arbiter of every manuscript. Decisions fall into five formal categories:
- Accept: The manuscript is accepted in its current form (rare on initial submission).
- Conditional Acceptance: The manuscript is accepted subject to minor textual revisions, production conformity, and completion of publishing agreements.
- Revise and Resubmit (R&R): The author is invited to revise the manuscript addressing referee critiques, with resubmission subject to further review.
- Reject with Option to Revise: The present draft is declined, but the author may submit a substantially reconceptualized version as a new submission.
- Reject: The manuscript is declined without an invitation to resubmit.
- Production Hand-off: Accepted manuscripts undergo copy-editing, proof composition, and author review prior to FirstView publication on Cambridge Core.
Open Access Model, APC Pricing, and Waiver Policies
Law and History Review operates as a Gold Open Access journal for all peer-reviewed research articles. Under this model, every published research article is immediately freely accessible to global readers under an author-selected Creative Commons license. Authors may select from all six Creative Commons licenses, including CC BY, CC BY-NC, CC BY-NC-SA, CC BY-NC-ND, CC BY-SA, and CC BY-ND. Detailed guidance on open access models is available in CASRAI’s overview of Gold Open Access publishing.
The economic framework for Gold OA in Law and History Review includes several funding pathways:
- Institutional Transformative Agreements: Cambridge University Press maintains Read & Publish agreements with hundreds of universities, library consortia, and research institutes worldwide. Corresponding authors affiliated with participating institutions have their publication costs fully covered with zero out-of-pocket expense. Eligibility is verified automatically during manuscript submission.
- Funder and Grant Support: Authors supported by grants with allocated open-access publication allowances utilize those designated funds to cover standard Article Processing Charges (APCs).
- Standard APC Fee Schedule: In cases where an author must pay an APC independently, the established rates are:
- GBP (£): 2,610
- USD ($): 3,655
- Cambridge Open Equity Initiative & Waivers: Cambridge University Press guarantees that financial constraints will never prevent an accepted author from publishing. Authors without institutional agreement coverage or grant funding are eligible for full APC waivers or substantial discounts through the Cambridge Open Equity Initiative. Waiver requests are handled post-acceptance via the Author Information Form, ensuring editorial decisions remain completely separate from financial considerations.
- Colour Figures: Digital color figures are published online free of charge. Authors requesting color printing in the physical edition are assessed separate print production charges administered via CCC-Rightslink.
Worked Pre-Submission Verification Checklist
To assist authors in auditing their manuscripts prior to portal submission, the following verification checklist outlines the essential pre-flight requirements established by the editorial office:
- Word Count Verification: Confirm that the total word count does not exceed 11,000 words. Count must include body text, footnotes, table entries, and figure captions.
- Complete Anonymization: Remove author names, institutional affiliations, grant acknowledgement notes, and self-referential citations (e.g., replace ‘as I argued in Author (2020)’ with third-person citations). Check document properties and PDF metadata to ensure author names are purged.
- Document Package Preparation: Confirm that three separate files are ready: Title Page document, standalone 200-word Abstract document, and Anonymized Manuscript document.
- Citation Formatting Check: Verify that footnotes follow modified Chicago style with full citations on first mention and shortened forms thereafter. Ensure that parenthetical references are removed and common Latin terms are unitalicized.
- Subheading Limits: Ensure that subheadings are limited to two levels and that no section is titled ‘Introduction’ or ‘Part I’.
- Accessibility and Alt-Text: Prepare descriptive alt-text for all maps, diagrams, and illustrative figures. Confirm that figures are referenced consecutively in the text as ‘Figure 1’, ‘Figure 2’, etc.
- Exclusive Submission Confirmation: Confirm that the manuscript is not currently submitted to or under review by any other journal or law review.
Comparative Analysis with Peer Legal History Journals
When selecting a publication outlet, legal historians frequently compare Law and History Review with peer periodicals in legal history and interdisciplinary socio-legal studies. The primary alternatives include the American Journal of Legal History (Oxford University Press), The Journal of Legal History (Routledge / Taylor & Francis), and Law & Society Review (Cambridge University Press).
While The Journal of Legal History focuses heavily on English, British Imperial, and Roman legal history with a maximum length of 16,000 words, Law and History Review offers broader comparative and thematic coverage spanning ancient to modern legal systems across global contexts. The American Journal of Legal History provides an alternative venue with a 15,000-word ceiling and hybrid open-access options. Meanwhile, Law & Society Review focuses primarily on contemporary empirical and sociological analyses of law rather than archival history.
The structured dataset below presents a direct, sourced comparison of key operational parameters across these journals, including publisher affiliations, peer review models, word count constraints, impact metrics, and open-access licensing.
Frequently asked questions
Is Law and History Review student-edited or peer-reviewed?
Law and History Review is a faculty-refereed, peer-reviewed academic journal, not a student-edited law review. It is published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the American Society for Legal History and uses external expert peer reviewers to evaluate all research submissions.
What is the maximum word count for submissions to Law and History Review?
The maximum word limit for original research articles is 11,000 words, inclusive of all body text, footnotes, tables, and figures. Manuscripts exceeding 11,000 words are desk-rejected without review. Review essays are limited to 5,000 words.
Does Law and History Review accept simultaneous submissions?
No. Law and History Review strictly enforces a single-submission policy. A manuscript submitted to LHR cannot be under review or consideration at any other journal or law review simultaneously.
What citation style does Law and History Review use?
Law and History Review uses a modified Chicago Manual of Style notes system. Footnotes require full bibliographic details on first mention and shortened citations thereafter. Parenthetical citations are prohibited, and common Latin terms such as ibid. and et al. are not italicized.
How long does the peer review process take at Law and History Review?
The peer review process at Law and History Review typically takes up to five months from initial submission to editorial determination, reflecting the thoroughness of double-anonymous expert referee evaluations.
Do authors have to pay an Article Processing Charge (APC) to publish?
While Law and History Review publishes research articles Gold Open Access, most authors do not pay an out-of-pocket APC. Costs are routinely covered through Cambridge University Press Read & Publish agreements with academic institutions, funder grants, or full waivers through the Cambridge Open Equity Initiative.
What is the relationship between Law and History Review and The Docket?
The Docket is the official digital companion platform of Law and History Review and the American Society for Legal History. It publishes shorter, accessible open-access essays, symposia, forum discussions, and teaching resources ranging from 1,000 to 2,500 words.
Sources
- Cambridge Core. Law and History Review: About This Journal. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/law-and-history-review/information/about-this-journal (accessed 2026-11-16).
- Cambridge Core. Law and History Review: Abstracting and Indexing. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/law-and-history-review/information/about-this-journal/abstracting-and-indexing (accessed 2026-11-16).
- Cambridge Core. Law and History Review: Journal Metrics. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/law-and-history-review/information/about-this-journal/journal-metrics (accessed 2026-11-16).
- Cambridge Core. Law and History Review: Author Instructions and Preparing Your Materials. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/law-and-history-review/information/author-instructions/preparing-your-materials (accessed 2026-11-16).
- Cambridge Core. Law and History Review: Fees and Pricing. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/law-and-history-review/information/author-instructions/fees-and-pricing (accessed 2026-11-16).
- Cambridge Core. Law and History Review: Open Access Options. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/law-and-history-review/information/journal-policies/open-access-options (accessed 2026-11-16).
- Cambridge Core. Law and History Review: Peer Review Process. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/law-and-history-review/information/peer-review-information/review-process (accessed 2026-11-16).
- American Society for Legal History (ASLH). Official Society Portal. https://aslh.net (accessed 2026-11-16).
- The Docket. Digital Platform of Law and History Review. https://lawandhistoryreview.org (accessed 2026-11-16).
- ScholarOne Manuscripts. Law and History Review Submission Portal. https://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/lhr (accessed 2026-11-16).
- Oxford Academic. American Journal of Legal History: About and Instructions to Authors. https://academic.oup.com/ajlh (accessed 2026-11-16).
- Taylor & Francis Online. The Journal of Legal History: Aims & Scope and Author Instructions. https://www.tandfonline.com/journals/flgh20 (accessed 2026-11-16).
Data: Comparative Specifications of Leading Peer-Reviewed Legal History and Socio-Legal Journals
An original comparative dataset compiling publisher, society sponsorship, peer review model, word count ceilings, citation impact metrics, open access models, and citation styles across major peer-reviewed legal history and socio-legal studies journals, sourced from official publisher guidelines and indexing reports.
Period covered: 2024/2026. Coverage: Global.
| Journal Name | Publisher | Sponsoring Organization | Peer Review Model | Max Word Limit (words) | Journal Impact Factor (JIF) | Scopus CiteScore (CiteScore) | Open Access Model | Citation Format |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Law and History Review | Cambridge University Press | American Society for Legal History | Double-anonymous | 11000 | 1.1 | 1.1 | Gold Open Access | Modified Chicago |
| American Journal of Legal History | Oxford University Press | Independent Academic | Double-anonymous | 15000 | 0.8 | 0.8 | Hybrid Open Access | OSCOLA / Chicago |
| The Journal of Legal History | Routledge (Taylor & Francis) | Independent Academic | Double-anonymous | 16000 | 1.3 | 0.9 | Hybrid Open Access (Open Select) | Chicago Notes |
| Law & Society Review | Cambridge University Press | Law and Society Association | Double-anonymous | 13000 | 2.3 | 3.5 | Gold / Transformative | ASA / Chicago Author-Date |
Sources
- Cambridge Core: Law and History Review (accessed 2026-11-16)
- Oxford Academic: American Journal of Legal History (accessed 2026-11-16)
- Taylor & Francis: The Journal of Legal History (accessed 2026-11-16)
- Cambridge Core: Law & Society Review (accessed 2026-11-16)
Compiled by CASRAI from the sources above. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution.







