Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board
Published
On this page
OMB Circular A-4, “Regulatory Analysis,” is the guidance the US Office of Management and Budget (OMB) gives executive agencies on how to analyse the benefits and costs of a proposed regulation. The version dated September 17, 2003 is the one the White House circulars page lists today, after a 2023 revision was issued and then rescinded in February 2025. Its best-known requirement is to report net benefits at both 3 percent and 7 percent real discount rates.
What is OMB Circular A-4?
The circular is a 48-page document addressed to the heads of executive agencies. It is issued under section 6(a)(3)(C) of Executive Order 12866 and the Regulatory Right-to-Know Act, and it also covers the regulatory accounting statements that act requires. It replaced OMB’s 1996 “best practices” document and the 2000 guidance that followed it. Executive Order 12866 requires a regulatory analysis for economically significant actions, and the circular applies to rules that rescind or modify existing rules as well as to new ones.
For anyone who studies public policy, evaluation or economics, A-4 is the reference that explains why federal regulatory analyses look the way they do: a stated need for action, a set of alternatives, benefits and costs expressed in comparable units, and an explicit treatment of uncertainty and of who gains and who pays.
What does Circular A-4 require?
The circular is organised in seven sections: A Introduction; B Need for Federal Regulatory Action; C Alternative Regulatory Approaches; D Analytical Approaches; E Identifying and Measuring Benefits and Costs; F Specialized Analytical Requirements; and G Accounting Statement. The points below are the ones most often needed by researchers who cite or replicate regulatory analyses.
- Benefit-cost analysis is the primary tool. The circular describes it as the way to compare alternatives and select the one with the largest net benefits, ignoring distributional effects.
- Cost-effectiveness analysis for health and safety. For major rules where an effectiveness measure exists, the circular calls for cost-effectiveness analysis, and for benefit-cost analysis as well where monetary values are available. For other major rules it calls for benefit-cost analysis, with cost-effectiveness or a qualitative discussion where benefits cannot be monetised.
- Threshold analysis for what cannot be quantified. The question the circular asks is how small the value of the non-quantified benefits could be before the rule would yield zero net benefits.
- Transparency. The analysis should state its time horizon and discount rates, include sensitivity analysis, and open with an executive summary containing a standardised accounting statement.
- Distributional effects are reported separately from efficiency. Groups can be defined by income, race, sex, sector or geography, and effects over time or across generations are shown as streams.
Discount rates: why 3 percent and 7 percent?
Circular A-4 tells agencies to provide estimates of net benefits using both 3 percent and 7 percent real discount rates. It explains that 7 percent approximates the opportunity cost of capital, which is the base-case rate in OMB Circular A-94, and that 3 percent approximates the consumption rate of interest, estimated from the real 10-year Treasury rate (about 3.1 percent over 1973-2003). The circular cites an EPA analysis of its 1998 pulp and paper rule, which used real discount rates of 3 and 7 percent, as an example. It also allows other rates when effects fall on capital in a way the 7 percent rate does not represent.
Discounting follows the standard present-value factor 1/(1 + r)t, where r is the real annual discount rate and t is the number of years from the base year in which the benefit or cost occurs. This is the same mechanics covered in the site’s guide to discounting costs and health benefits.
Worked example: a $10 million annual net benefit over 30 years
Suppose a hypothetical rule produces a constant net benefit of $10 million at the end of each year for 30 years (this is a teaching example, not a real rule). The present value at rate r is the sum of 10/(1 + r)t for t = 1 to 30, which equals 10 × [1 − (1 + r)−30] / r.
- At r = 0.03: the annuity factor is (1 − 1.03−30)/0.03 = (1 − 0.41199)/0.03 = 19.600, so the present value is 10 × 19.600 = $196.0 million.
- At r = 0.07: the annuity factor is (1 − 1.07−30)/0.07 = (1 − 0.13137)/0.07 = 12.409, so the present value is 10 × 12.409 = $124.1 million.
Individual years show the effect: the year-30 payment of $10 million is worth $4.12 million at 3 percent (10/1.0330) and $1.31 million at 7 percent (10/1.0730). The same stream is worth about 58 percent more at 3 percent than at 7 percent, which is why A-4 requires both figures: a rule’s apparent net benefit can depend heavily on the rate chosen, especially for long-lived benefits.
Interpretation: reading a 3 percent and 7 percent pair
| What you see | How to read it |
|---|---|
| Net benefits positive at both 3% and 7% | The conclusion does not depend on the discounting choice; sensitivity to other assumptions still needs checking. |
| Positive at 3%, negative at 7% | The result depends on the rate. The circular’s call for sensitivity analysis and for stating the time horizon applies directly. |
| Large gap between the two present values | Benefits or costs arrive late in the horizon, as in the example above where the 3% value is far larger. |
| Benefits not quantified | Use the circular’s break-even question: how small could the unquantified benefits be before net benefits reach zero? |
| Net benefits positive overall | Check the separate distributional discussion; A-4 reports who gains and bears costs apart from efficiency. |
Assumptions and common mistakes
- Mixing nominal and real values. The 3 and 7 percent rates are real rates, so cash flows must be in constant dollars, not nominal ones.
- Reporting only one discount rate. The circular asks for both; a single-rate table omits the comparison the guidance expects.
- Treating net benefits as the whole story. Efficiency and distributional effects are reported separately, so a positive total does not show how effects fall across groups.
- Citing the wrong version. There are two documents with the same number and title (2003 and 2023), and only the 2003 version is currently in force; see the status table below.
- Timing convention. The example above assumes year-end payments. Start-of-year payments change the present value, so state the convention.
Current status of Circular A-4 (as of November 2026)
Federal Register document 2023-24819 (November 13, 2023) announced a revised Circular A-4 that “supersedes and rescinds” the September 17, 2003 version. On February 12, 2025, OMB issued memorandum M-25-15, listed on its memoranda page as the “Recission and Reinstatement of Circular A-4.” The circulars page now lists “OMB Circular A-4, Regulatory Analysis (09/17/2003) (48 pages).” The related Circular A-94 followed a similar path: memorandum M-25-23 (April 8, 2025) revoked the November 9, 2023 version and reinstated the October 29, 1992 version with appendices A and B. The data table below summarises the status of each circular covered on this page.
Where can I find OMB circulars?
OMB posts current circulars on its Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs circulars page (whitehouse.gov/omb/information-regulatory-affairs/circulars). As of November 19, 2026 it lists A-4, A-11, A-94 with its Appendix C discount rates, A-123, A-129 and A-136. Superseded or relocated circulars, and notices of revisions, appear in the Federal Register.
What is an OMB Circular A-130?
OMB Circular A-130, “Managing Information as a Strategic Resource,” sets general federal policy for information governance, acquisitions, records management, open data, workforce, security and privacy. The Federal Register notice of July 28, 2016 (document 2016-17872) announced the revision, which took effect on publication. It is not a regulatory-analysis document; it is relevant to research administrators mainly through federal information-management expectations.
What is OMB Circular A-123 and what are its requirements?
OMB Circular A-123 is titled “Management’s Responsibility for Internal Control.” The circulars page lists a revision dated March 10, 2026 (35 pages). For the specific control requirements, use the circular text itself; for the grants-side view of internal control, see the site’s guide to internal controls in federal grant compliance.
What is an OMB Circular A-110?
Circular A-110 set administrative requirements for grants to universities, hospitals and other non-profit organisations. The December 26, 2013 Federal Register final guidance (document 2013-30465) states that it supersedes and streamlines requirements from Circulars A-21, A-87, A-110 and A-122, among others. Those requirements now sit in 2 CFR Part 200; see the guide to the Uniform Guidance (2 CFR 200) and the dictionary entry for the OMB Compliance Supplement.
How to cite OMB Circular A-4 (APA 7th edition)
Reference list: Office of Management and Budget. (2003). Circular A-4: Regulatory analysis. https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/CircularA-4.pdf. In text: (Office of Management and Budget [OMB], 2003). If your work discusses the 2023 revision, cite it separately as its own document and state which version your analysis follows. For federal rules and notices, see how to cite federal regulations.
How to calculate the present value in Excel, R or Python
Each snippet reproduces the worked example (30 years, $10 million per year, year-end payments).
Excel: =PV(0.03, 30, -10) returns 196.00 and =PV(0.07, 30, -10) returns 124.09 (millions of dollars).
R:
pv = function(r, n = 30, cf = 10) sum(cf / (1 + r)^(1:n)) c(pv(0.03), pv(0.07)) # 196.00 124.09
Python:
def pv(r, n=30, cf=10): return sum(cf / (1 + r) ** t for t in range(1, n + 1)) print(round(pv(0.03), 2), round(pv(0.07), 2)) # 196.0 124.09
Frequently asked questions
Is OMB Circular A-4 still in effect?
Yes. The September 17, 2003 version is the one on the OMB circulars page as of November 19, 2026, following the February 12, 2025 rescission and reinstatement memorandum M-25-15.
What discount rates does Circular A-4 require?
Real rates of 3 percent and 7 percent, with net benefits reported for both.
Does A-4 apply to research funding or grants?
No. It addresses regulatory analysis by executive agencies. Grant administration is governed by 2 CFR Part 200.
Where can I find OMB circulars?
On the OMB circulars page at whitehouse.gov and, for revision notices, in the Federal Register.
What is the difference between A-130, A-123 and A-110?
A-130 covers managing federal information as a strategic resource; A-123 covers management’s responsibility for internal control; A-110 was the administrative-requirements circular for non-profit award recipients, now superseded by 2 CFR 200.
Sources
- OMB, Circular A-4, “Regulatory Analysis,” September 17, 2003: https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/CircularA-4.pdf (accessed 2026-11-19).
- OMB, Circulars page: https://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/information-regulatory-affairs/circulars/ (accessed 2026-11-19).
- OMB, Memoranda page (M-25-15, M-25-23): https://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/information-regulatory-affairs/memoranda/ (accessed 2026-11-19).
- OMB, M-25-23, April 8, 2025: https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/M-25-23-Rescission-and-Reinstatement-of-Circular-No.-A-94.pdf (accessed 2026-11-19).
- Federal Register 2023-24819, “Issuance of Revised OMB Circular No. A-4,” Nov. 13, 2023: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2023-11-13/html/2023-24819.htm (accessed 2026-11-19).
- Federal Register 2016-17872, “Revision of OMB Circular No. A-130,” July 28, 2016: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2016-07-28/html/2016-17872.htm (accessed 2026-11-19).
- Federal Register 2013-30465, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Dec. 26, 2013: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2013-12-26/html/2013-30465.htm (accessed 2026-11-19).
Data: Status of selected OMB circulars as of November 2026
Compares selected OMB circulars by subject, the dated document or action that determines which version applies, and where it is found now, compiled from the OMB circulars and memoranda pages and Federal Register notices.
Period covered: 1992/2026. Coverage: United States.
| Circular | Subject | Key dated action | Where it is found |
|---|---|---|---|
| A-4 | Regulatory Analysis | 2003 version (Sept 17, 2003); 2023 revision issued Nov 13, 2023; M-25-15 rescission and reinstatement Feb 12, 2025 | Listed on OMB circulars page as 09/17/2003, 48 pages |
| A-94 | Discount rates (Appendix C: cost-effectiveness, lease-purchase) | M-25-23 (Apr 8, 2025) reinstated the Oct 29, 1992 version with appendices A and B | Listed on OMB circulars page with Appendix C discount rates |
| A-123 | Management's Responsibility for Internal Control | Revision dated Mar 10, 2026 (35 pages) | Listed on OMB circulars page |
| A-130 | Managing Information as a Strategic Resource | Revision announced in Federal Register July 28, 2016 | Federal Register notice 2016-17872; not on the current circulars list |
| A-110 | Administrative requirements for non-profit award recipients | Superseded by final guidance published Dec 26, 2013 | Replaced by 2 CFR Part 200 |
Sources
- OMB Circulars page (accessed 2026-11-19)
- OMB Memoranda page (accessed 2026-11-19)
- Federal Register 2023-24819 (accessed 2026-11-19)
- Federal Register 2016-17872 (accessed 2026-11-19)
- Federal Register 2013-30465 (accessed 2026-11-19)
- OMB M-25-23 (accessed 2026-11-19)
Compiled by CASRAI from the sources above. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution.







