Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board
Published · Last updated
On this page
Page proofs are the typeset version of your accepted work, laid out as it will be printed or published online, sent to you for a final check before publication. The check is narrow by design: you are looking for errors introduced during typesetting and for factual slips, not reopening the text. This guide explains what page proofs are, what publishers say you should and should not change, and how to work through them in order of risk.
Ask CASRAI · free to tryQuestion about this guide? Ask CASRAI answers with linked sources. 2 free questions a day, no account.
Purpose of the section: what page proofs are for
In the production sequence, page proofs come after copyediting and typesetting. CASRAI’s comparison of copyediting and proofreading describes proofreading as the final check performed on the typeset proof (PDF galleys or HTML/XML output) before publication, whereas copyediting happens earlier, on the accepted manuscript.
Publishers describe the author’s job at this stage in very similar terms:
- Steiner Verlag, a book publisher, states that “The correction of the proofs is purely to eliminate the errors which were introduced during layout.”
- Taylor & Francis Author Services tells journal authors to check the proofs against the original text for accuracy and to check that all figures and tables are correct, and states that it is the author’s responsibility to check the proofs.
The practical consequence is the same in both: page proofs are a verification step, not a revision round.
Structure: how to work through page proofs
- Read the publisher’s instructions first. Deadlines, the way corrections must be entered and who receives them differ by publisher (compare the two examples below).
- Compare the proof with your accepted text. Taylor & Francis asks authors to check proofs against the original text for accuracy.
- Check names. Taylor & Francis tells authors to check their own name and their co-authors’ names. If you are the corresponding author, confirm the names with your co-authors before you reply.
- Check figures, tables and their labels. Steiner Verlag lists the placement, numbering and labelling of figures and images among the items to check.
- Check what typesetting commonly disturbs. Steiner Verlag lists footnote placement and text flow between pages, special characters, hyphenation, line breaks, quotation marks, dashes versus hyphens, spacing around slashes, and leftover placeholder marks such as cross-references that were not resolved.
- Check running heads and, for monographs, the table of contents. Steiner Verlag asks authors of monographs and volume editors to check the pagination and headings in the table of contents, and gives its own running-head convention for monographs (level 1 heading on even pages, level 2 heading on odd pages).
- Answer every query. Taylor & Francis states that authors should respond to all queries from the copy editor or typesetter when submitting corrections.
- Return one consolidated set of corrections by the route and deadline the publisher specifies.
A short annotated example
Illustrative composite, not a real proof or a real publisher’s markup. Suppose a proof contains the following three items. The right-hand column shows the kind of response the sources above support.
| What you see on the proof | Correct it? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A co-author’s surname is misspelled in the byline | Yes | A factual error; Taylor & Francis asks authors to check their own and co-authors’ names. |
| Figure 2 appears with the caption of Figure 3 | Yes | A layout or labelling error; Steiner Verlag lists figure placement, numbering and labels among the items to check. |
| You now prefer a different word in the second paragraph of the discussion | No | A rewrite. Taylor & Francis: correct errors but “do not rewrite the text”; Steiner Verlag: editorial reworking is no longer possible at this stage or can incur higher costs. |
Common mistakes
- Rewriting instead of correcting. Taylor & Francis asks authors to correct errors but not to rewrite the text. Steiner Verlag warns that editorial changes at this stage are not generally possible and can lead to higher costs that the publisher may pass on to the author.
- Undoing house style. Taylor & Francis notes that the copy editor may already have changed spelling and punctuation to match the journal’s style, so those changes may not need correcting.
- Leaving queries unanswered. Taylor & Francis states that all queries should be answered when corrections are submitted.
- Not responding at all. Steiner Verlag states that if a contributor does not respond about their proofs, the contribution will not be printed. Taylor & Francis states that it will publish the article after the author has sent corrections.
- Sending corrections to the wrong person. In Steiner Verlag’s process, corrections sent directly to the publisher are forwarded unseen to the responsible editor and are not carried out until the editor checks them.
- Assuming someone else will catch it. Taylor & Francis states that it is the author’s responsibility to check the proofs and that it cannot be held responsible for errors that remain in the published version.
Checklist
Ordered from highest to lowest consequence. Items attributed to a publisher come from that publisher’s own author guidance, checked 29 October 2026.
- Author and co-author names correct (Taylor & Francis).
- Figures and tables correct, correctly numbered and labelled, and in the right place (Taylor & Francis; Steiner Verlag).
- Text matches your accepted text; no factual or typographical errors remain (Taylor & Francis).
- Footnotes sit on the right page and text flows correctly between pages (Steiner Verlag).
- Special characters, hyphenation, line breaks, quotation marks and dashes are correct (Steiner Verlag).
- No leftover placeholder marks where cross-references should be (Steiner Verlag).
- Running heads correct; for monographs and volume editors, table of contents pagination and headings checked (Steiner Verlag).
- Every copy editor or typesetter query answered (Taylor & Francis).
- Corrections sent once, to the right recipient, before the deadline.
Discipline differences: journal articles versus books
The two publishers quoted in this guide describe different workflows, and the differences are practical. They illustrate two publishers’ processes and should not be treated as universal rules.
| Point | Taylor & Francis (journal articles) | Steiner Verlag (books: monographs and edited volumes) |
|---|---|---|
| Who checks | The author; it is the author’s responsibility | Each contributor, with corrections merged by the responsible editor |
| Where corrections go | Submitted with answers to all queries | To the volume’s responsible editor, who submits a single final version to the publisher |
| Stated deadline | No deadline stated | Within a fortnight, to the editor |
| What happens after | The article is published after the corrections are sent | A contributor who does not respond is not printed; revised proofs go only to the editor |
| Extra items | Names, figures and tables | Footnotes, running heads, table of contents |
Other publishers use their own online proofing systems and instructions, so follow the instructions in the message that delivers your proofs. If you later find an error in the published version, the route is a published correction rather than a proof change; see the dictionary entry on correction (corrigendum) and the related entry on an erratum.
FAQ
Can I rewrite parts of my paper on the proofs?
No. Both publishers quoted here say proofs are for corrections: Taylor & Francis asks authors not to rewrite the text, and Steiner Verlag says editorial reworking is no longer possible at this stage or can lead to higher costs.
Whose responsibility is it to find errors in the proofs?
The author’s. Taylor & Francis states that it is the author’s responsibility to check the proofs and that it cannot be held responsible for errors that remain in the published version.
What is the difference between copyediting and page proofs?
Copyediting happens on the manuscript before typesetting; page proofs are the typeset result that you check afterwards. See copyediting vs. proofreading for the full comparison.
What happens if I do not return my proofs?
It depends on the publisher. Steiner Verlag states that a contributor’s piece will not be printed if the contributor does not respond about their proofs. Taylor & Francis states that it publishes the article after the author has sent corrections.
Do I need to check the manuscript for the journal’s spelling and punctuation style?
Not necessarily. Taylor & Francis notes that the copy editor may already have changed spelling and punctuation to match journal style, so those changes may not need correcting.
For a wider view of how an author moves through submission and production, see the Open Journal Systems author guide, which describes the editing and production stages in one journal platform.
Sources
- Taylor & Francis Author Services, “Checking proofs of a journal article” (also titled “What to look for when checking proofs”): https://authorservices.taylorandfrancis.com/publishing-your-research/moving-through-production/checking-proofs/. Checked 29 October 2026.
- Steiner Verlag, “Page proofs” (For authors, Book production process): https://www.steiner-verlag.de/en/For-authors/Book-production-process/Page-proofs/. Checked 29 October 2026. Deadlines and discounts on that page are Steiner Verlag’s own and are not general norms.
- CASRAI, Copyediting vs. Proofreading for Manuscripts, for the sequence of copyediting and proofreading: /compare/copyediting-vs-proofreading. Checked 29 October 2026.







