Skip to main content
v2026.11,986 entries · CC-BY 4.0

Supplementary Materials: What to Include and How to Format Them for Journal Submission

What supplementary materials (supporting information) are, the scope rule that keeps the main article self-contained, why these files are peer reviewed, and common format and naming conventions across publishers.

Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board

Published · Last updated

On this page

Supplementary materials (called supporting information, supplemental material or supplementary information, depending on the publisher) are files submitted with a manuscript that sit outside the typeset article but are published with it: extended datasets, additional figures and tables, detailed methods, code, video and audio. Include what supports the conclusions but cannot fit the main text; keep anything the argument depends on in the article, and follow the target journal’s rules for format, size and labelling.

They are a routine part of journal submission across most disciplines, but authors consistently misjudge two things about them: how much editorial scrutiny they receive, and what actually belongs in them versus in the main article. Both misjudgments create real problems at review and after publication. Reviewers flag manuscripts that lean on supplementary content to reach their conclusions, and readers cannot evaluate a paper’s central claims if load-bearing evidence is buried in a file most people never open. The data table at the end of this page compares what three publishers (PLOS ONE, SAGE and Springer Nature) say about file size, zip files, labelling, copyediting and accessibility.

Ask CASRAI · free to tryQuestion about this guide? Ask CASRAI answers with linked sources. 2 free questions a day, no account.

Ask your first question freeSubscribe

What counts as supplementary material

Publishers use overlapping but not identical terms for this category: Elsevier calls it “supplementary material,” PLOS calls it “supporting information,” SAGE calls it “supplemental material,” and some journals distinguish “supplementary data” (datasets) from “supplementary methods” or “supplementary figures/tables.” The underlying concept is the same: content submitted with the manuscript, handled alongside it, and published as a companion to, not a substitute for, the main article.

Typical categories include:

  • Extended or raw data: datasets too large or granular for the main text, often as CSV, Excel, or plain-text files.
  • Additional figures and tables: supporting visualizations that are informative but not essential to following the main argument (for example a full set of dose-response curves when the main text shows only the representative case).
  • Extended methods: detailed protocols, reagent lists, instrument settings, or statistical code that would clutter the Methods section but are needed to replicate the work.
  • Multimedia: video, audio, or animation that cannot appear in a print-formatted article.
  • Questionnaires, survey instruments, or interview guides: the actual materials used to collect data, as distinct from the results derived from them.

Elsevier’s guidance describes this category as content offering “additional possibilities to publish supporting applications, movies, animation sequences, high-resolution images, background datasets, sound clips and more” (Elsevier Journal Article Publishing Support Center). It states that requirements differ by journal, so authors should always check the specific journal’s Guide for Authors rather than assume one house style applies across the platform, and it notes that supplementary images must comply with the publisher’s image-manipulation policy.

The practical consequence of that variation is that no single checklist applies to every journal. The sections below describe what the publishers that document their rules publicly say, and the data table at the end of the page puts three of them side by side.

The scope rule most publishers converge on

Wording varies, but publisher policies converge on a two-part scope rule:

  1. The main article must stand alone. A reader who never opens the supplementary files should still be able to follow the argument and understand the basis for the paper’s conclusions from the main text.
  2. Supplementary material must directly support, not duplicate, the main conclusions. It should be additional or complementary and directly relevant to the article content: material that could not fit in the printed or typeset article for reasons of length or format, not a parking lot for content an author did not want to cut during revision.

SAGE frames this as material “used to create the research (such as datasets) or additional pieces to the article that could not be included in the print version” (SAGE supplemental material guidelines). Springer Nature’s support pages similarly describe electronic supplementary material, such as animations, movies, audio and large original data, as content published in the online version of the article only (Springer Nature support).

In practice, editors and reviewers apply this scope test by asking whether a reader who skipped the supplement entirely would still trust the paper’s central claims, and whether anything in the supplement is quietly doing work the main text implies has already been done. If a result the abstract or Discussion relies on only appears in a supplementary table, that is usually a sign the material belongs in the main text. See CASRAI’s guide on manuscript word count limits for how to decide what to cut versus what to move when a submission is over length.

Standards context: NISO RP-15-2013

Publisher rules for supplementary material are not fully standardized, but there is a published recommended practice. NISO RP-15-2013, Recommended Practices for Online Supplemental Journal Article Materials, was published on 16 January 2013 as a joint NISO and NFAIS recommended practice (DOI 10.3789/niso-rp-15-2013). Its stated aims are a more standardized approach to supplemental materials, reducing the burden on authors, editors and publishers, ensuring that supplemental materials add substance, making them discoverable, and helping to preserve them (NISO RP-15-2013). It is guidance for the publishing community, not a rule an individual journal must follow, so the journal’s own instructions still govern what you submit.

Common misconception: supplementary material is not “unreviewed”

A persistent misconception is that supplementary files sit outside peer review: because they are not typeset or copyedited, they are assumed not to be scrutinized. At the publishers whose rules are documented below, that is not what the policies say:

  • SAGE states that supplemental material files are subjected to peer review alongside the main article, and that the editorial team decides whether to include them as part of the acceptance process.
  • PLOS ONE‘s Supporting Information guidelines require every supporting-information caption to correspond to a file, and ask that file names match their captions, a requirement that makes sense only if the files are expected to be opened (PLOS ONE Supporting Information guidelines).

What differs from the main text is production, not review. SAGE publishes supplemental material “as submitted,” print ready, with no accuracy check, copyedit, typesetting or proofreading, and PLOS publishes supporting information as submitted and not copyedited. That production difference is where the “unreviewed” misconception seems to originate, but it is a statement about formatting. Draft and check supplementary material with the same care as the main manuscript: errors, inconsistent labelling or unsupported claims in a supplementary table are a legitimate basis for a reviewer to raise concerns, exactly as they would be in the main text. How closely any individual reviewer reads every file still varies, so do not rely on a reviewer to catch an error you could catch yourself.

Before you upload: a pre-submission checklist

Because most publishers publish supplementary files exactly as submitted, the author carries the quality control that the production team applies to the article. SAGE states that authors are responsible for the accuracy and function of their supplemental material, and describes the published file as a permanent record that cannot be altered once published. Working from those statements, check the following before you upload:

  1. The file is final and print ready. Spelling, units, axis labels, column headings and layout will appear as you submit them; nobody will typeset or proofread them.
  2. Every number matches the main text. A supplementary table that disagrees with the article is a reviewer query waiting to happen, and after publication it cannot be quietly replaced.
  3. Every file opens on another computer. SAGE specifically advises testing video playback on a different machine, since a codec that plays on yours may not play on a reader’s.
  4. Third-party content is cleared. SAGE requires full copyright clearance, with the permission documents, for any third-party content in supplemental material. A figure borrowed from another paper is not cleared just because it sits in a supplement.
  5. Images comply with the image-manipulation policy. Elsevier states that supplementary material must comply with its image-manipulation policy, the same standard as the main figures.
  6. Each file has a descriptive title and caption. See the metadata section below.
  7. Nothing confidential is included. Reviewer-only material belongs in the separate confidential-upload category of the submission system, not in the published supplement.

Common format requirements

Exact specifications vary by journal. The recurring conventions documented by the publishers below are these.

File types

Most platforms accept a broad range of formats. SAGE lists archives, audio, datasets, documents, images, Jupyter notebooks, KML, molecule files, presentations, video, 3D viewer files, text and code files, and Gephi files as accepted types. PLOS ONE accepts any file type for supporting information. For tabular or numeric content that readers may want to reuse, an editable or machine-readable format such as CSV or Excel is more useful than a PDF, because data cannot easily be extracted from a PDF table. The journal’s Guide for Authors remains the authority on accepted formats.

File size

PLOS ONE asks for files preferably under 10 MB. SAGE likewise asks authors to keep files below 10 MB where possible. Elsevier’s support page does not state a single limit and refers authors to the journal’s Guide for Authors. Where a limit applies, reduce size before upload rather than splitting content into many fragments. PLOS suggests compressing TIFF images with LZW compression, converting large EPS or SVG files to PDF, and bundling multipage datasets as a ZIP file.

Zip files

Publishers disagree here, which is a good reason to read the target journal’s rules before you package anything. PLOS suggests ZIP files for bundling multipage datasets, while SAGE advises avoiding zip files. A single-file-per-item layout that satisfies both is usually possible for small supplements; for large ones, follow the journal you are actually submitting to.

Naming conventions

Two common conventions exist:

  • Sequential, type-labelled naming: files and items labelled by type and number, such as “Fig. S1” and “Table S1,” with the file name matching the content it contains.
  • “S-number” item naming (PLOS): every supporting information item combines “S” and a whole number, such as “S1 Appendix,” “S1 Table” and “S2 Fig,” and related sub-parts are combined into one file rather than split as S1A and S1B. PLOS requires the file name to match the caption, with an underscore replacing the space (for example S2_fig.pdf), and defines item types of Appendix, Checklist, Dataset, Figure, Movie, Protocol, Table, Text and Video.

In both systems the operative rule is the same: the file name and the in-text caption or citation must match exactly.

Citing supplementary items in text

Cite each item by its exact label at the point where it supports a statement, for example “the effect persisted after adjustment (S2 Table)” rather than a single sentence at the end of a section. PLOS says citation of supporting information in the text is recommended rather than required, and the items need not be cited in numerical order. To cite an element inside a supporting file, PLOS asks for forms such as “Table A in S1 Text” and warns against “S1 Table in S1 Text,” which can cause hyperlinking errors. PLOS also states that supporting figures and tables follow the supporting-information rules rather than the main-text figure and table rules.

Captions and metadata

Captions and titles are how a reader, a reviewer and a search engine learn what a file contains. The two publishers below handle them differently.

  • PLOS ONE uses a caption of the form “S1 Text. Title,” where the title is strongly recommended and a legend is optional. All captions are listed at the end of the manuscript file, and no separate caption file is submitted.
  • SAGE asks authors to supply a title and a description for each item. If none is supplied, a default is built from the file name, the article title, the authors and the journal. The title and description are shown on Sage Journals, which supports discoverability.

A useful caption states what the file contains, which main-text result it supports, and the software or version needed to open it if that is not obvious. One caption per item, with a label identical to the file name, avoids most production queries.

Video, audio and other multimedia

Multimedia is the category where format problems are most common, because readers need the right codec as well as the right file type.

  • PLOS ONE prefers video as MP4 at 480p using H.264 video with 128 kbit/s AAC audio, and also accepts MOV, AVI, MPG and MPEG. Larger video is accepted if shrinking it would reduce its usefulness.
  • SAGE requires commonly used video codecs and does not support non-standard ones. It asks authors to note the codec used in the legend, and also advises testing playback on another computer before submission.
  • Springer Nature asks for a descriptive summary, provided as an explanatory caption, for audio-only files and for video that has audio but no speech.

Accessibility of supplementary files

Springer Nature’s accessibility policy for figures, images and supplementary materials sets expectations that many authors do not anticipate (Springer Nature accessibility policy). Human-readable supplementary files are expected to be accessible, while files that are not human-readable, such as graphics formats, HTML and SBML, are exempt. PDFs must be tagged, and Office files should be made accessible using the built-in tools of the software. Images inside supplementary files need alternative text, in the same way as images in the manuscript, and authors should check any AI-generated alternative text before submitting it.

Even where a journal does not state an accessibility rule, building these habits into the file at the source is cheaper than repairing it later: use real headings and table header rows in Word files, tag PDFs when exporting, and describe every figure.

Supplementary information, extended content and appendices: what is the difference?

Whether you call it supplementary information, supplemental material or supporting information depends on the publisher; the terms describe the same idea. The distinctions that matter are between the sub-types a particular journal defines (for example separate handling of figures, tables and datasets) and between all of them and an appendix printed inside the paper.

Element Where it appears Typical content Handled by the publisher
Main article Print and online The argument and evidence needed to trust the conclusion Peer reviewed, copyedited and typeset
Supplementary or supporting file Online, as a companion to the article Extended data, methods, extra figures, multimedia, code Reviewed with the manuscript at the publishers documented above; published as submitted
Appendix Inside the article itself Material that belongs with the paper but would interrupt the text Part of the article

For appendices, which are part of the article rather than a separate file, see CASRAI’s guide to the appendix in a research paper.

Deciding what belongs in supplementary material versus the main text

There is no universal checklist, because journal length limits, disciplinary norms and article type all shift the line. These questions are a working test consistent with the scope rule above:

  • Is it necessary to trust the main conclusion? If removing it would leave a reader unable to evaluate whether the central claim is supported, it belongs in the main text. See also CASRAI’s guidance on writing a data availability statement, which covers the related question of where underlying research data should be deposited versus described.
  • Is it needed to replicate the method, but not to follow the argument? Detailed protocols, full statistical code and exhaustive parameter lists are strong supplementary candidates.
  • Is it a robustness check or secondary analysis? Sensitivity analyses, additional cohorts or alternative model specifications that corroborate but do not drive the main finding typically belong in the supplement.
  • Would it exceed a journal’s word, figure or table limit in the main text? This is often the practical trigger for moving content, but material that is load-bearing for the conclusions is supposed to stay in the main text regardless of length pressure.
  • Is it raw data rather than a dataset in its own right? Large raw datasets are frequently better placed in a dedicated data repository with a data availability statement pointing to it. PLOS itself encourages repository deposit of data, and repositories are built for discoverability, citation and long-term preservation. CASRAI’s guide on choosing an open data repository covers that decision.

Worked example: sorting the files for a clinical cohort paper

Suppose a manuscript reports a cohort study. The primary outcome table and the participant flow figure go in the main text, since the central claim cannot be judged without them. The full statistical analysis code, the complete questionnaire used to collect data, and the sensitivity analysis with an alternative model are supplementary candidates: they support replication and corroboration but do not carry the main finding. The de-identified participant-level dataset is better deposited in a repository and cited through a data availability statement. If the journal is PLOS ONE, the files would be named S1 Text (questionnaire), S2 Text (analysis code), S1 Table (sensitivity analysis), with captions listed at the end of the manuscript and file names such as S1_table.xlsx. This is an illustrative scenario, not a report of any real study.

Supplementary material is often confused with, but distinct from, adjacent submission requirements:

  • A graphical abstract is a single summary visual published with the abstract, not additional evidentiary content.
  • A Highlights bullet-point summary is a short indexing element, not supporting data.
  • A data availability statement tells readers where underlying data can be found; a supplementary file is one possible location, but not always the best one.
  • Materials submitted for reviewer or editor eyes only during review are a different category from published supplementary material and are typically marked accordingly during submission through systems such as ScholarOne or Editorial Manager.

Common mistakes

  • Moving a key result to the supplement to meet a word limit. The article must stand alone.
  • Mismatched labels. A caption reading “Table S3” attached to a file named differently invites a production query; at PLOS the file name must match the caption.
  • Submitting data only as PDF. Readers cannot easily reuse numbers locked in a PDF table.
  • Uncleared third-party figures. SAGE requires permission documents for third-party content.
  • Assuming a typo can be fixed later. SAGE treats published supplemental material as a permanent record that cannot be altered.
  • Untested video. A codec that plays only on your machine fails for readers; test on another computer.
  • Untagged PDFs and missing alt text. Springer Nature expects tagged PDFs and alternative text for images in human-readable files.

Frequently asked questions

Is supplementary material peer reviewed?

At SAGE it is reviewed alongside the main article, and the editorial team decides at acceptance whether it is included. At PLOS ONE, captions must correspond to files, which presupposes that the files are examined. What supplementary material typically does not receive is copyediting or typesetting: it is published as submitted. Check the specific journal’s policy.

Can I change supplementary files after publication?

At SAGE, no: published supplemental material is a permanent record that cannot be altered, and the author is responsible for its accuracy and function. Check the corrections policy of the journal you are submitting to before assuming a fix is possible.

What video format should I use for supporting information?

PLOS ONE prefers MP4 at 480p with H.264 video and 128 kbit/s AAC audio, and also accepts MOV, AVI, MPG and MPEG. SAGE requires commonly used codecs, does not support non-standard ones, and asks authors to note the codec used in the legend.

Should I zip my supplementary files?

It depends on the journal. PLOS suggests ZIP for bundling multipage datasets; SAGE advises avoiding zip files. Follow the target journal.

Do supplementary files need to be accessible?

Springer Nature expects human-readable supplementary files to be accessible, PDFs to be tagged and images to have alternative text, and it exempts non-human-readable formats such as graphics formats, HTML and SBML.

How do I cite “S1 Table” in the text?

Cite it by its exact label where it supports a statement. PLOS says citation is recommended rather than required and need not follow numerical order. For an element inside a file, write “Table A in S1 Text,” not “S1 Table in S1 Text.”

Do I need permission for third-party material in a supplement?

Yes. SAGE requires full copyright clearance for third-party content in supplemental material, with permission documents supplied.

Should raw data go in supplementary material or a repository?

For large or reusable datasets, a dedicated repository with a data availability statement in the main text is usually the better home, since repositories support persistent identifiers, structured metadata and long-term access.

Do supplementary files count toward a journal’s word or page limit?

Journals set their own rules on this, and some also cap the number or size of supplementary files. Check the Guide for Authors; do not treat “move it to the supplement” as a substitute for trimming an over-length manuscript.

Key takeaways

  • Supplementary material supports a manuscript’s conclusions without being part of the typeset article. It is not a place to relocate content because a manuscript runs long.
  • The main article must stand alone; supplementary content should support, not duplicate, the main conclusions.
  • Documented publisher policies treat supplementary files as reviewed with the manuscript but published as submitted, so you own their accuracy.
  • File type, size, zip policy, naming and accessibility rules vary by publisher; confirm them in the specific journal’s Guide for Authors.
  • Large reusable datasets often belong in a repository with a data availability statement.

Sources

Sources (accessed 14 November 2026):

Data: Supplementary file requirements stated by PLOS ONE, SAGE and Springer Nature

Compares publisher-stated rules for supplementary files (size, zip, labelling, post-publication changes, copyediting, accessibility) compiled from three publisher author-guidance pages. Cells state only what each page says; 'Not stated' means the page read did not address the point.

Period covered: 2026.

Supplementary file requirements stated by PLOS ONE, SAGE and Springer Nature
PublisherPreferred maximum file sizeZip guidanceLabelling ruleCopyedited or typesetAccessibility requirement
PLOS ONEPreferably under 10 MBZIP suggested for bundling multipage datasetsItem name with S and a whole number; file name must match caption; captions listed at end of manuscriptNo: published as submittedNot stated
SAGEBelow 10 MB where possibleAvoid zip filesTitle and description per item; default built from file name if absentNo: published as submitted, print readyNot stated
Springer NatureNot statedNot statedDescriptive summary as caption for audio-only and silent-speech videoNot statedHuman-readable files accessible; PDFs tagged; images need alt text

Sources

Compiled by CASRAI from the sources above. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution.

Follow CASRAI

Research-administration guidance, standards updates and independent tool reviews.

Ask CASRAI · free to try

Ask about Supplementary Materials: What to Include and How to Format Them for Journal Submission

2 free questions a day, no account.

An AI assistant for research: funder rules, compliance, methods and publishing. It links the sources behind its answers and labels answers that come from a web search.

Answers draw on CASRAI's guides and dictionary plus the federal and funder documents we index: Federal Register, Grants.gov, Regulations.gov and UKRI.

Works on this site and inside Claude, Cursor and the AI tools you already use.

Everything CASRAI publishes — this page, the dictionary, the guides and the news — stays open to read, with no account and no card.

Referenced across the research world

University of Cambridge logoColumbia University logoCrossref logoUniversity of Edinburgh logoHarvard University logoUniversity of Oxford logoPrinceton University logoStanford School of Medicine logoUniversity College London logoORCID logoUniversity of Cambridge logoColumbia University logoCrossref logoUniversity of Edinburgh logoHarvard University logoUniversity of Oxford logoPrinceton University logoStanford School of Medicine logoUniversity College London logoORCID logo
  • University of Cambridge logo
  • Columbia University logo
  • Crossref logo
  • University of Edinburgh logo
  • Harvard University logo
  • University of Oxford logo
  • Princeton University logo
  • Stanford School of Medicine logo
  • University College London logo
  • ORCID logo

View CASRAI adoption →