Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board
Published
On this page
Techno-economic analysis (TEA) is a method for analyzing the technical and economic performance of a process, product or service by systematically assessing technology states against a fixed reference case. In practice, a TEA pairs an engineering performance model (mass and energy balances, equipment sizing) with a cost estimate, so that a new or improved technology can be compared with a defined baseline on cost per unit of product.
Short answer
A TEA answers one question: given a stated design, a stated technology maturity and stated economic assumptions, what does a unit of product cost, and which inputs move that number most? The definition used by the U.S. Department of Energy’s National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) in its guidance for carbon-utilization grant applicants is the one above: assessing technology states against a fixed reference case. What separates a credible TEA from a spreadsheet exercise is that the reference case, system boundaries, assumptions and sensitivity ranges are all written down and defensible.
Definition and scope
NETL’s guidance frames a TEA as a system performance and cost analysis at commercial scale, even when the technology itself is still at bench or pilot scale. That framing matters for laboratory researchers: the analysis does not ask what the lab apparatus costs, it asks what a commercial plant based on the lab result would cost to build and run, and how that compares with the technology it would replace.
Two cases are normally defined. The reference case is the state-of-the-art technology. The advanced case (or novel technology case) replaces part of the reference case with the new technology. Comparing them quantifies the benefit of the new technology, sets performance and cost goals, and identifies the critical parameters that should drive research and development priorities.
A TEA is distinct from process simulation, although it depends on it. A simulator such as Aspen Plus produces the performance model; the TEA is the larger framework that turns the model outputs into costs and reports them under fixed assumptions. NETL’s training slides name Aspen, ChemCAD and Thermoflow as common tools for the performance model.
How a TEA is run in practice
The NETL systems-analysis guidance presents a TEA for power generation systems as four steps.
Step 1: Form a Technology Analysis Plan
The Technology Analysis Plan (TAP) documents the approach and methodology and is presented to stakeholders before the TEA starts. It records the assumptions and is updated as the TEA proceeds. Its contents include the reference plant, plant-wide assumptions, the novel technology cases, the design basis, performance and cost assumptions, the technology integration plan and the proposed sensitivity analysis.
Step 2: Create a performance model
The performance model computes the material and energy balances (MEBs): the mass and energy flows through the system, based on conservation of mass and energy and a defined system boundary. NETL’s grant requirements ask for the process flow diagram, a stream table, an auxiliary load table, an equipment list (description, number of units, size and material specifications), plant emissions compared with regulatory limits, and a stated technology readiness level.
Step 3: Estimate costs
Costs are built up through the capital cost levels described below, together with fixed and variable operating and maintenance (O&M) costs. Where equipment does not yet exist, NETL says capital cost uncertainties may be established using AACE International guideline uncertainties at the class level appropriate to the analysis (AACE Recommended Practice 18R-97).
Step 4: Report
The report states the assumptions, results and sensitivities in a form a reviewer can reproduce. The checklist later on this page lists what NETL requires applicants to state.
One warning from the NETL slides is specific and useful: parameters such as condenser pressure, steam cycle conditions, turbine inlet temperature, cooling water temperature, air separation unit performance, emissions levels and equipment selection are commonly varied between the reference and novel cases without justification. NETL notes that unjustified variation may require resubmission, because a benefit that comes from an unexplained change in the baseline is not a benefit of the new technology.
Capital cost levels
A TEA does not report a single capital number. NETL’s grant basis document defines five cumulative levels, from bare erected cost to total as-spent cost. The data table below sets out what each level adds and its dollar basis. In short, each level includes everything in the one before it, so quoting a figure without naming its level makes two TEAs impossible to compare.
The document also notes that in most NETL studies the as-spent period assumed for TASC is five years for coal plants and three years for natural gas plants, which is why TASC is always larger than TOC for the same plant when the same base-year costs are used.
Contingency and technology readiness
Contingency is how a TEA admits what it does not know. NETL separates two kinds. Process contingency compensates for uncertainty from the performance uncertainties associated with the development status of a technology. Project contingency covers general uncertainty in cost estimates and potential risks in the development of a plant.
The NETL training slides cite AACE guidance (16R-90) for both. Project contingency for a budget-type estimate (AACE Class 4 or 5) is 15 to 30 percent of the sum of bare erected cost, EPC fees and process contingency. Process contingency scales with technology status:
| Technology status | Process contingency (percent) |
|---|---|
| New concept with limited data | 40+ |
| Bench scale | 30 to 70 |
| Small pilot | 20 to 35 |
| Full-size modules tested | 5 to 20 |
| Commercial | 0 to 10 |
The practical consequence is that a lab-stage result should be expected to carry a much wider cost band than a commercial one, and that the claimed technology readiness level (see technology readiness level) has to be consistent with the contingency applied. NETL requires the readiness level to be stated.
Levelized cost of product
The headline output of many TEAs is a levelized cost, here the levelized cost of product (LCOP). The NETL grant basis gives it as: LCOP = (TVOM + TFOM + TOC × (TASC/TOC) × FCF) / product units per year, where TVOM is total annual variable O&M including fuel, TFOM is total annual fixed O&M, and FCF is the fixed charge factor. It is computed at an assumed capacity factor. For a retrofit, the analysis uses the incremental difference between the after-retrofit and existing plant.
The same document includes an illustrative reactor case in which the breakeven levelized cost of methanol is reported as $1.86 per gallon at an 85 percent capacity factor with CO2 supplied free. That figure belongs to NETL’s example and its stated conditions; it is not a general benchmark.
A reviewer-ready TEA checklist
Drawing on the NETL grant basis, a TEA that a reviewer can evaluate states at least the following.
- Reference case and system boundaries: what is being compared with what, and what is inside the analysis.
- Material and energy balances, stream table and process flow diagram: the performance model made visible.
- Equipment list: description, number of units, size and material specifications.
- Technology readiness level: consistent with the process contingency applied.
- Reporting assumptions: capacity factor, fixed charge rate, TASC/TOC ratio, feedstock price, year of the cost basis, CO2 price, purchased electricity price and makeup water price.
- Capital cost level: BEC, EPCC, TPC, TOC or TASC, named for every figure.
- Emissions: plant emissions compared with regulatory limits.
- Sensitivity analyses: on the impactful parameters, including capital cost, O&M cost, fuel cost, utilities cost and capacity factor.
Where it matters for labs and project proposals
For a research group, a TEA is most often a section of a funding proposal or an internal stage-gate case: it shows that a laboratory result could matter at commercial scale and which parameters the next experiments should target. NETL’s guidance exists in exactly this context, as the stated basis for carbon-utilization procurement grant applicants, and it says the comparison identifies the critical parameters that should inform R&D prioritization.
Sensitivity analysis is where the lab connects to the model. A National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL, now the National Laboratory of the Rockies) cost analysis of stationary fuel cell power plants, for example, models a 100 MW plant and computes levelized cost of electricity across capacity factors of 2 to 10 percent and across hydrogen prices. It finds that the result is highly sensitive to capacity factor, and that at a low capacity factor the plant can tolerate a higher hydrogen price. The general lesson is the one to take into a proposal: vary the parameters that matter and show the result. A tornado diagram is a common way to display which inputs move the output most.
Process choice also shapes the analysis. A route such as steam methane reforming has its own stages, conditions and CO2 balance, which would define the system boundary of any TEA built around it.
Common misunderstandings
- A TEA is a price forecast. It is not. It compares technology states against a fixed reference case under stated assumptions; change the assumptions and the output changes.
- One capital cost number exists. Five levels exist, and TOC and TASC differ in dollar basis and in whether escalation and interest during construction are included.
- Contingency is padding. In NETL’s framework process contingency is tied to the development status of the technology, and project contingency to general estimate uncertainty and plant development risk.
- A better advanced case proves the technology. If the advanced case differs from the reference case in unjustified ways beyond the new technology itself, the comparison is not valid.
- Lab-scale cost equals TEA cost. The analysis is of a commercial-scale system, not of the laboratory apparatus.
Frequently asked questions
What is techno-economic analysis?
It is a method of analyzing the technical and economic performance of a process, product or service by systematically assessing technology states against a fixed reference case (NETL, DOE/NETL-2023/3838).
What are the steps in a TEA?
NETL’s guidance lists four: form a Technology Analysis Plan, create a performance model, estimate costs, and report.
What is the difference between TOC and TASC?
Total overnight cost (TOC) is in base-year dollars with no escalation or construction financing. Total as-spent cost (TASC) covers all capital expenditure as incurred, including escalation and interest during construction, in mixed current-year dollars.
What is LCOP?
The levelized cost of product: annualized variable and fixed O&M plus the capital charge, divided by product units per year, at an assumed capacity factor.
Why does technology readiness matter in a TEA?
Because process contingency rises as the technology is less mature: 0 to 10 percent for commercial technology against 30 to 70 percent at bench scale in the NETL training slides.
Which software is used for the performance model?
NETL’s slides name Aspen, ChemCAD and Thermoflow as common tools.
Sources
- NETL, Basis for Techno-Economic Analysis: Carbon Utilization Procurement Grants, DOE/NETL-2023/3838, 30 January 2023, netl.doe.gov. Read 2026-11-14.
- J. C. Fisher II, NETL, Introduction to Performing a Techno-Economic Analysis for Power Generation Systems, 23 June 2015, netl.doe.gov. Read 2026-11-14.
- Reznicek et al., NREL (now NLR), Cost Analysis of Heavy-Duty Vehicle PEM Fuel Cell Stationary Power Plants, osti.gov. Read 2026-11-14.
Data: NETL capital cost levels for techno-economic analysis (BEC to TASC)
The five cumulative capital cost levels defined in the NETL grant basis for techno-economic analysis, with what each level adds beyond the previous one and the dollar basis the source states for it.
Period covered: 2023.
| Level | Full name | Adds beyond the previous level | Dollar basis stated in source |
|---|---|---|---|
| BEC | Bare erected cost | Process equipment, on-site facilities, and direct and indirect construction labor (first level) | Not specified for this level |
| EPCC | Engineering, procurement and construction cost | EPC contractor services: detailed design, contractor permitting, project and construction management | Not specified for this level |
| TPC | Total plant cost | Project and process contingencies | Not specified for this level |
| TOC | Total overnight cost | Other overnight costs, including owner's costs | Base-year dollars; no escalation or construction financing |
| TASC | Total as-spent cost | All capital expenditure as incurred, including escalation and interest during construction | Mixed current-year dollars |
Sources
- NETL, Basis for Techno-Economic Analysis: Carbon Utilization Procurement Grants (DOE/NETL-2023/3838) (accessed 2026-11-14)
Compiled by CASRAI from the sources above. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution.







