
Sen. Susan Collins, who chairs the Senate Appropriations Committee, supports extending the block on the White House’s proposed grant-making rule, her spokesperson said on 18 November 2026. That is a new development since casrai’s report on the Senate stopgap that bars the rule until 11 December. None of the five FY2027 spending bills the committee released on 16 November carries the prohibition.
What happened
The Senate Appropriations Committee released the text of its final five FY2027 funding bills on 16 November 2026: State and Foreign Operations, Defense, Financial Services and General Government, Labor-HHS-Education, and Transportation-HUD. According to Inside Higher Ed, none of those bills included language blocking the White House Office of Management and Budget (OMB) proposal that would give political appointees sweeping control over federal grant making. Legislation that funds the government through 11 December currently bars OMB from implementing the rule.
On 18 November, Inside Higher Ed reported that Collins supports maintaining the prohibition regardless, citing Phoebe Keller, a spokesperson for the committee’s Republicans. Keller told the outlet that “no bills are going to have moved by Dec. 11,” and that Democrats instead support another continuing resolution to fund the government. She said Collins, whom Inside Higher Ed describes as a Republican who lost re-election, supports extending the block through that resolution. A Democratic Senate aide confirmed that Democrats will push to continue the prohibition.
Key details
| Date | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 13 July 2026 | Comment period on OMB’s 400-plus-page proposal closes with at least 300,000 comments, after 45 days | Inside Higher Ed, 14 July |
| 16 November 2026 | Senate Appropriations Committee releases its final five FY2027 bills, none with the OMB-rule block | Senate Appropriations Committee; Inside Higher Ed |
| 17 November 2026 | Research!America calls it “deeply troubling” that none of the bills would extend the prohibition | Inside Higher Ed, 18 November |
| 18 November 2026 | Collins’s spokesperson says she supports continuing the block; Democrats say they will push for it | Inside Higher Ed |
| 11 December 2026 | Date through which current funding legislation bars OMB from implementing the rule | Inside Higher Ed |
Under the proposal, as Inside Higher Ed described it in July, federal agencies could terminate grants they determine are not in their “interest”, a word the proposal does not define, and the rule would elevate appointees’ “independent judgment” over scientific peer review. OMB said when it published the proposal that it wanted the new grant rules to take effect by 1 October.
Background and context
The proposal drew heavy opposition in the comment period. The American Council on Education, writing for about 50 groups, said the rule would undermine fair and proven evaluation processes and create risks for long-term research and infrastructure investment. COGR, which represents research universities on federal policy, filed a comment of more than 150 pages and asked for a longer comment period, saying the breadth of the revisions limited the ability of recipients to assess their cumulative impact. Lawyers at Democracy Forward and other groups said the comments were lining them up for litigation.
Collins was an early critic. She called for at least a 90-day extension of the comment period and wrote to OMB Director Russell Vought that the proposal would “undermine scientific and biomedical research, and conflict with Congress’ control over the federal funding process,” according to Inside Higher Ed. Casrai has also covered how NSF walked back contested grant rule changes and the underlying Uniform Guidance in 2 CFR 200, which the OMB proposal would rewrite.
Reaction
Russ Paulsen, president and chief executive of Research!America, said in a news release on 17 November, as reported by Inside Higher Ed, that it is “deeply troubling” that none of the appropriations bills would extend the prohibition. He said OMB’s proposal “would allow bureaucrats to terminate research grants and clinical trials at any time for political reasons,” and that “Americans don’t want medical progress to be a political football.”
When the House passed the continuing resolution that delays the rule, Paulsen said in a Research!America statement that the delay “gives us more time to work with Congress to stop this rule permanently.”
What it means for researchers, universities and research offices
The rule cannot be implemented before 11 December under current funding legislation, so existing award terms are unchanged for now. After that date, protection depends on whether the next continuing resolution repeats the language, which Collins’s office and Democrats say they want. Sponsored-programs offices should therefore read the text of any new stopgap for the OMB provision before that date, rather than assume it carries over.
The provision that most affects institutions is grant termination. Offices with multi-year clinical trials and long-running projects can review the termination terms in their current awards and the guidance in casrai’s overview of NIH grant terminations, and can follow positions taken by COGR, which has been tracking the proposal. Because OMB had wanted the rule in effect by 1 October, any lapse of the block would bring a fast change in compliance requirements that institutions should be ready to model.
What happens next
Congress faces the 11 December date for current funding. Collins’s spokesperson said no FY2027 bills will have moved by then, and Democrats are pressing for another continuing resolution that continues the prohibition on the OMB rule.
Sources
- Inside Higher Ed: Collins Supports Blocking OMB Grant Rule, Even if Not in Bills, 18 November 2026, checked 2026-11-19
- Inside Higher Ed: Legal Threats Loom Over OMB Grant Control Rule, 14 July 2026, checked 2026-11-19
- U.S. Senate Committee on Appropriations: Senate Appropriations Committee Releases Final Five FY 2027 Funding Bills, 16 November 2026, checked 2026-11-19
- Research!America: Research!America Welcomes House Action to Delay OMB Rule, checked 2026-11-19







