Skip to main content
v2026.11,986 entries · CC-BY 4.0

Editorial · CASRAI · Research integrity and misconduct

Six Retractions for Spain’s Daniel Balsalobre as University of Castilla-La Mancha Reviews the Case

Three journals retracted six papers by Daniel Balsalobre; Springer Nature posted a further notice on 20 November and his university is reviewing the case.

Published 21 Nov 2026· 7 minute read
General Library building at the University of Castilla-La Mancha campus in Cuenca, Spain
Photo: BibliotecaUCLM / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 (cropped). Source · Licence

Springer Nature’s journal Environmental Science and Pollution Research posted a retraction notice on 20 November 2026 for a 2021 paper co-authored by Daniel Balsalobre-Lorente of the University of Castilla-La Mancha, according to the notice’s DOI record. It follows El País’s 17 November report that three journals have retracted six of his studies, citing manipulated citations and undisclosed conflicts of interest, while the university examines the case.

What happened

El País reporter Manuel Ansede wrote on 17 November 2026 that three scientific journals had retracted a total of six studies by Balsalobre, a professor of environmental economics at the University of Castilla-La Mancha, and that publishers cited bad practices including manipulation of citations to his work and concealed conflicts of interest. The paper reports that he was ranked first in Spain in Research.com’s Best Rising Stars of Science in the World ranking and that his papers have been cited more than 25,000 times, mostly in work by researchers in China, Pakistan, India, Saudi Arabia and Malaysia.

Four of the six retractions are in Environmental Science and Pollution Research (ESPR), a Springer Nature journal. The DOI records of those notices carry the dates 16 October 2025, 19 August 2026, 22 September 2026 and 23 October 2026 (October 2025, August, September, October). El País says the journal found the peer-review process had apparently been manipulated, and says he has had one paper retracted every month since August. The commentary site For Better Science, in a 20 November roundup, lists the same four ESPR notices and says each states that peer review “appears to have been compromised”.

A fifth retraction came from Frontiers. Its notice, published on 7 August 2025, retracts a 2022 paper in Frontiers in Environmental Science on which Balsalobre-Lorente is a co-author. The notice says the Frontiers Research Integrity Auditing team uncovered a network of authors and editors who conducted peer review with undisclosed conflicts of interest and engaged in citation manipulation, and that the investigation could not determine whether every author, editor or reviewer knew of the misconduct. For Better Science lists a sixth, in Energy Economics on 27 April 2026, which it says the authors requested after finding a critical misspecification in the econometric model.

The newest development is the 20 November ESPR notice. According to Crossref, the record was created on 20 November 2026 and lists as authors of the original paper Ugur Korkut Pata and Balsalobre-Lorente; the original, a 2021 study of tourism and energy consumption in Turkey, is now marked as a retracted article (Crossref record). El País had written that he expected a seventh retraction to follow soon.

Key details

Retraction notice Journal Notice date
Economic complexity, clean energy and ecological footprint (Indian perspective) Frontiers in Environmental Science 7 August 2025
Consumption spending and CO2 emissions in Pakistan Environmental Science and Pollution Research 16 October 2025
Human capital and environmental degradation in N-11 countries Environmental Science and Pollution Research 19 August 2026
Tourism, globalization and environmental degradation Environmental Science and Pollution Research 22 September 2026
Economic policy uncertainty and ecological footprint Environmental Science and Pollution Research 23 October 2026
Tourism and energy consumption, load capacity factor in Turkey Environmental Science and Pollution Research 20 November 2026

The titles are shortened from the Crossref records of the notices. Per El País, Balsalobre has published more than 230 papers, 26 of them in ESPR, and has some 400 co-authors. In 2023 he reached a pace of one paper every five working days.

Background and context

ESPR has been dealing with the same family of problems for some time. El País quotes the journal’s editor-in-chief, Philippe Garrigues, as saying last year that it had been overrun by groups of researchers who cite one another and by mass-produced papers whose authorship was sold, with the problem concentrated in its green-economy section. Up to December 2024 the title had retracted nearly 250 papers, more than 90 percent of them in green economics, according to Garrigues as quoted by the paper. A citation cartel and a paper mill are different things; our guide to paper mills and how journals and institutions detect them covers the detection side.

El País also reports that Balsalobre accepted more than 650 invitations to review papers, an unusual number, and acknowledges that he used some of those reviews to suggest authors cite his own work, including asking the two authors of a ChatGPT-in-higher-education paper to cite seven of his environmental-economics papers. That practice is what the dictionary calls coercive citation. In the paper’s account, 170 papers that cited his work have already been retracted for irregularities.

He has been on Stanford University’s list of highly cited scientists since 2022, according to El País, and was on the Clarivate list until 2023. A Clarivate spokeswoman told the paper the company does not comment on individual cases but has tightened its criteria to exclude researchers involved in bad practices. See how Clarivate selects Highly Cited Researchers.

Reaction

Balsalobre told El País by telephone: “I have never intentionally done anything that, to my way of thinking, would be unethical.” He said he increased his publication rate to obtain a full professorship, which he achieved in 2024, and that he has been more careful since. He said he blocked a co-author, Muntasir Murshed, as soon as he learned the co-author was asking for money to publish, and attributed the criticism to “Spanish envy”.

María de los Ángeles Oviedo, a professor at the University of Seville, accuses him of exploiting the system through “coercive citation manipulation”, in El País’s account. Tim Kersjes, Springer Nature’s head of research integrity, told the paper: “We can’t comment on individual cases, but we can confirm that we are continuing to investigate some papers at the journal, based on leads from previous cases.”

The university’s rector, Julián Garde, who has been president of the Conference of Rectors of Spanish Universities since May, said the alarms went off about a month ago and that the university’s research ethics committee has been asked to prepare a report, on which any decisions will be based. No institution has published a finding of misconduct about Balsalobre, and nothing in the notices or in El País’s report amounts to one. Retraction Watch pointed readers to the El País story in its 21 November weekend roundup.

What it means for researchers, universities and research offices

The points below are editorial interpretation of the reporting, not findings by any body named here.

  • Research-integrity offices. The notices arrived one at a time over more than a year and the latest is days old. A single signal, such as a retraction in one journal, is a prompt to look at the same author’s other papers, co-author network and refereeing pattern. The peer review fraud entry describes the mechanisms that notices of this kind refer to.
  • Journal editors. Reviewer reports that steer authors to the reviewer’s own papers are visible to the handling editor. Spot-checking whether suggested references in a decision letter cluster on one reviewer is a cheap control. ESPR’s editor said its worst-affected section was green economics, so topic-level risk can be tracked as well as author-level risk.
  • Research assessment. The case shows what happens when counts reward volume: the publication rate rose, citations followed, and rankings and prizes followed those citations. El País notes that institutions compete to recruit highly cited scientists because the hires help them climb world rankings, and that he lists additional affiliations at institutions in Ecuador, Azerbaijan and the Czech Republic. Offices weighing external affiliations or highly cited lists in promotion and hiring may want to check retraction records and review practices as well. DORA and CoARA are the main frameworks for moving away from count-based evaluation.
  • Co-authors and downstream citers. The El País figure of 170 retracted papers that cite Balsalobre shows how far one network can reach. Co-authors may want to review their own records.

What happens next

The University of Castilla-La Mancha’s research ethics committee is preparing a report, and the rector has said decisions will follow from it. Springer Nature says it is continuing to investigate some ESPR papers based on leads from earlier cases, and El País reports that Balsalobre himself expects further retractions.

Sources

Ask CASRAI · full access

Ask about this story

Full access: large monthly usage, up to 10 source passages behind each answer, and MCP and API access for Claude Code, Codex and other CLIs. Cancel any time.

An AI assistant for research: funder rules, compliance, methods and publishing. It links the sources behind its answers and labels answers that come from a web search.

Answers draw on CASRAI's guides and dictionary plus the federal and funder documents we index: Federal Register, Grants.gov, Regulations.gov and UKRI.

Works on this site and inside Claude, Cursor and the AI tools you already use.

Everything CASRAI publishes — this page, the dictionary, the guides and the news — stays open to read, with no account and no card.

Referenced across the research world

University of Cambridge logoColumbia University logoCrossref logoUniversity of Edinburgh logoHarvard University logoUniversity of Oxford logoPrinceton University logoStanford School of Medicine logoUniversity College London logoORCID logoUniversity of Cambridge logoColumbia University logoCrossref logoUniversity of Edinburgh logoHarvard University logoUniversity of Oxford logoPrinceton University logoStanford School of Medicine logoUniversity College London logoORCID logo
  • University of Cambridge logo
  • Columbia University logo
  • Crossref logo
  • University of Edinburgh logo
  • Harvard University logo
  • University of Oxford logo
  • Princeton University logo
  • Stanford School of Medicine logo
  • University College London logo
  • ORCID logo

View CASRAI adoption →