U.S. District Judge Noël Wise on November 14, 2026 let an antitrust case against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron proceed in the Northern District of California. The order finds a plausible claim over alleged restrictions on conventional DRAM supply, without deciding liability. For research computing, it puts the relationship between ordinary server memory and AI accelerator memory under legal scrutiny.
What the DRAM ruling decides
Wise denied the companies’ joint motion to dismiss in Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., No. 5:26-cv-06345-NW. The 20-page order, ECF 68, concerns a proposed class action brought by 17 consumers and small businesses from five states. They filed their complaint on June 25, 2026, alleging a continuing agreement to restrict conventional dynamic random-access memory supply in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act, alongside state-law claims.
The distinction between an allegation and a finding matters throughout the decision. On this motion, the court takes well-pleaded factual allegations as true and asks whether they state a legally plausible claim. The plaintiffs have crossed that threshold. They have not proved an agreement, and the ruling does not find the defendants liable for collusion. The court expressly acknowledges that independent decisions remain a possible explanation.
The defendants argued that each company made rational decisions serving its own interests in response to common market pressures. They also invoked an earlier case involving the same manufacturers: the Ninth Circuit’s 2022 DRAM II decision, which upheld dismissal of allegations concerning a 2016–2018 supply restriction. Wise concluded that the new complaint presents materially different allegations.
Why the allegations survived dismissal
The complaint describes several related courses of conduct: production cuts beginning in late 2022, a shift of manufacturing capacity toward high-bandwidth memory, or HBM, beginning in 2023, exits from older memory products, and decisions against expanding conventional DRAM capacity. Wise found adequately pleaded parallel conduct in the initial supply cuts, the HBM pivot and the winding down of DDR4 production. Similar conduct alone, however, does not establish an agreement.
The court therefore examined additional circumstances, called plus factors, that could make an agreement plausible when considered together. These included alleged long-term commitments of HBM supply, refusals by Samsung and SK Hynix to enter long-term agreements with major conventional DRAM customers, Micron’s announced closure of its Crucial consumer brand, and delays or halts to new manufacturing facilities. The order’s separate analysis of the facility allegations concerns Samsung and Micron.
Another significant allegation concerns customer vetting. The plaintiffs say all three manufacturers introduced substantially similar questions in January 2026 about customers’ end users, quantities and whether demand was real. The defendants attributed the practice to AI demand consuming available capacity. Wise found that explanation did not resolve the alleged timing and similarity sufficiently to defeat the claim at this stage. The order also counted the manufacturers’ earlier price-fixing history as part of the overall analysis.
Arguments the court did not accept
The ruling does not endorse every component of the complaint. Wise set aside the DDR3 allegations because the complaint did not allege that Micron stopped producing that generation. She gave no weight to the cited investor statements or industry-conference meetings, and treated the concentrated market structure as neutral. She also accepted that investing in HBM during its earlier, more profitable period was insufficient by itself to suggest conspiracy. The surviving claim depends on the combined allegations, rather than an assumption that moving into AI memory is unlawful.
The conventional DRAM and HBM distinction
The order describes conventional DRAM as working memory used in computers, phones and servers, while HBM is a specialized form used for AI accelerators. The plaintiffs’ theory connects the two through manufacturing allocation: they allege that moving resources into HBM restricted conventional output. That remains a contested account of the manufacturers’ conduct, not a judicial determination of why the market developed as it did.
A scientific computing example shows why both memory classes matter to universities. NERSC’s Perlmutter architecture documentation lists DDR4 host DRAM on its GPU nodes alongside HBM on the GPUs; its CPU-only nodes also use DDR4. Accelerator memory and host memory therefore coexist within the same research system. The NERSC research computing overview explains the facility’s role, while CASRAI’s guide to requesting GPU resources in Slurm covers the separate operational question of allocating accelerator resources to jobs.
For research offices following server infrastructure or preparing research equipment requests for proposal, the relevance is the scope of the dispute: conventional memory remains part of scientific infrastructure even where GPUs are central to the workload. The order changes the litigation’s procedural position. It does not direct a university’s procurement, require a manufacturer to change production, or establish a future supply outcome.
How technology outlets covered the decision
Wccftech’s Omar Sohail reported the refusal to dismiss on November 15, citing LitNews. Jowi Morales’s Tom’s Hardware report, syndicated by Yahoo Finance the same day, also described the case advancing and emphasized that the decision was not a judgment resolving the allegations. These are separate outlets covering the proceeding, but their accounts draw on the order or reporting about it; they are not independent factual corroboration of the alleged agreement.
What happens next
The conclusion of the November 14 order requires the defendants to answer by December 7, 2026. It also grants their unopposed administrative motion to continue early case deadlines and resets the initial case management conference for January 12, 2027, at 9 a.m. LitNews’s report of the ruling identifies the same milestones. Those are the dated next steps in this decision; its conclusion contains no production mandate or determination of the ultimate merits.
Sources
- U.S. District Court, Northern District of California: Garciaguirre v. Samsung, order denying motion to dismiss, ECF 68, November 14, 2026. Checked 2026-11-16.
- LitNews Newsroom: Judge Refuses to Dismiss DRAM Supply Conspiracy Suit Against Samsung, SK Hynix, Micron, November 14, 2026. Checked 2026-11-16.
- Wccftech, Omar Sohail: Federal Judge Rejects Memory Makers’ Defense To Advance Class-Action Antitrust Lawsuit, November 15, 2026. Checked 2026-11-16.
- Tom’s Hardware, Jowi Morales, via Yahoo Finance: Judge denies motion to dismiss DRAM price-fixing lawsuit against Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix, November 15, 2026. Checked 2026-11-16.
- NERSC Documentation: Perlmutter Architecture, undated technical documentation. Checked 2026-11-16.







