Skip to main content
v2026.11,986 entries · CC-BY 4.0
CASRAIAsk CASRAI · AI assistant for researchAsk a research question. Answers come with their sources.Funder rules, compliance, methods and publishing. Answers link the sources they rest on.
NIKOLAI elementN4 · Claims and argumentProposednikolai-v0.3

Marginal versus Absolute Risk Basis

Definition

A marginal versus absolute risk basis is the baseline a risk statement is measured against. Marginal risk counts only the extra risk a model adds beyond what already exists, such as other available models and tools; absolute risk counts the total risk the model poses, without subtracting that existing baseline.

Also called: Marginal risk, Absolute risk, Baseline risk, Risk baseline

NIKOLAI's proposed operational definition

NIKOLAI proposes Marginal versus Absolute Risk Basis as a controlled value naming the baseline against which a stated risk is measured -- e.g. a no-AI world, publicly available tools as of a stated date, other developers' current models, or an industry-wide hypothetical where all developers matched the reporting developer's practices. This is a NIKOLAI editorial proposal because at least four incompatible baselines are in active use across the corpus with no shared vocabulary connecting them, which the cited sources themselves flag as enabling a collective-action failure ('risk creep') if left unnamed.

The operational definition is CASRAI's own proposal, not a definition any named organisation has agreed to. See what NIKOLAI is and is not, or browse the AI safety glossary.

Examples

Examples from published documents

  • Anthropic says its CB-1 assessment "also works as a description of the level of risk our systems impose over and above the risks posed by other AI developers' systems" and also "holds for the level of risk that would be imposed industry-wide" (Anthropic Risk Report, August 2026, §4.6.1)
  • Google DeepMind measures uplift "relative to a baseline without generative AI" (Google DeepMind Frontier Safety Framework v3.1, footnote 8)
  • OpenAI's Tier 2 is "meaningful counterfactual assistance (relative to unlimited access to baseline of tools available in 2021) to novice actors" (OpenAI Frontier Governance Framework, CBRN risk tiers, p.11)

Counter-examples

Not to be confused with

  • Uplift measured against tools available in 2021 uses a fixed historical baseline; it is not a marginal basis, even though both compare against something other than zero risk.

Related terms

Related AI safety terms

Terms defined under this element that are not NIKOLAI elements themselves, each as the cited document uses it. Every term is also listed in the AI safety glossary.

Risk creep
Risk creep is the gradual build-up of risk when many models each add only a small marginal increase that crosses no individual threshold, so that total risk grows over time. The Frontier Model Forum names it as a weakness of purely marginal baselines.
Source: Frontier Model Forum: Risk Taxonomy and Thresholds
Net new risk
Net new risk is harm that could not currently be achieved with existing tools and resources without access to frontier or general-purpose AI. OpenAI's and Meta's frameworks use it as a test for which risks to track.
Source: OpenAI Preparedness Framework v2
Static historical standard
A static historical standard fixes a risk baseline at a specific point in time, for example 2023, and never adjusts it, regardless of what other developers later release. The Frontier Model Forum contrasts it with marginal risk assessment.
Source: Frontier Model Forum: Risk Taxonomy and Thresholds
Counterfactual assistance
Counterfactual assistance is help a model provides beyond what a person could already get without it, measured in OpenAI's framework relative to unlimited access to the baseline of tools available in 2021.
Source: OpenAI Frontier Governance Framework

Source of record

Where this definition comes from

  • Anthropic Risk Report, August 2026, §1.1

    “"Marginal risk": "the level of risk our systems pose over and above the risks posed by other AI developers' systems"; "Absolute risk": "the level of risk that would be posed industry-wide, if all AI developers had models and practices similar to ours" (§1.1).”

    https://www-cdn.anthropic.com/f61d49fa5596956a5dec75fea0e973bf6a6a8378/Redacted%20Risk%20Report%20August%202026%20.pdf
  • Frontier Model Forum: Risk Taxonomy and Thresholds, s3.2

    “"Marginal Risk Assessments: On the other hand, developers would consider the additional risk their model adds beyond what's already possible in the ecosystem." "they may facilitate gradual risk escalation through "risk creep" – where multiple models, each introducing only small marginal increases which do not cross individual "net new" thresholds, may collectively create significant risk growth over time as these small increases compound." (s3.2)”

    https://www.frontiermodelforum.org/technical-reports/risk-taxonomy-and-thresholds/

Crosswalk

How named organisations use this concept

Every row below is a shadow mapping. A shadow row is CASRAI's own reading of a published document. No lab, evaluator or regulator named on a shadow row has declared, endorsed, or been consulted on it. That changes only when an organisation files its own Mapping Declaration.
OrganisationTheir term, as publishedMatch & verificationSource
AnthropicShadow mapping
Anthropic Risk Report, August 2026
“"Marginal risk": "the level of risk our systems pose over and above the risks posed by other AI developers' systems"; "Absolute risk": "the level of risk that would be posed industry-wide, if all AI developers had models and practices similar to ours" (§1.1).”exactEQ
confidence: high
Anthropic Risk Report, August 2026
OpenAIShadow mapping
OpenAI Preparedness Framework v2
“Marginal-risk adjustment if another developer releases a comparable model and "may do so without instituting comparable safeguards to the ones we have committed to" (§4.3). The Safeguards sufficiency determination considers "The baseline risk from other deployments, based on a review of any non-OpenAI deployments of models which have crossed the capability thresholds" (§4.2). The "Net new" criterion compares against "existing tools and resources (e.g., available as of 2021) but without access to frontier AI" (§2.1).”closeCL
confidence: high
OpenAI Preparedness Framework v2
Google DeepMindShadow mapping
Google DeepMind Frontier Safety Framework v3.1
“"(e.g. if other models are similarly capable and have few mitigations, then the marginal risk added by our external deployment is likely low)" (s.1.3.5). Uplift baseline: "we intend this to mean relative to a baseline without generative AI" (fn 8).”closeCL
confidence: high
Google DeepMind Frontier Safety Framework v3.1
MetaShadow mapping
Meta Advanced AI Scaling Framework v2
“"Net new" criterion: "The outcome cannot currently be realized as described (e.g. at that scale / by that threat actor / for that cost) with existing tools and resources but without access to general-purpose AI." (§3.2)”closeCL
confidence: high
Meta Advanced AI Scaling Framework v2
Frontier Model ForumShadow mapping
Frontier Model Forum: Risk Taxonomy and Thresholds
“"Marginal Risk Assessments: On the other hand, developers would consider the additional risk their model adds beyond what's already possible in the ecosystem. While dynamic approaches allow responsiveness to changing risk landscapes, they may facilitate gradual risk escalation through "risk creep" – where multiple models, each introducing only small marginal increases which do not cross individual "net new" thresholds, may collectively create significant risk growth over time as these small increases compound." "Static Historical Standards: Under this approach, risk thresholds would be established at a specific point in time (e.g. 2023) and never adjusted" (s3.2).”exactEQ
confidence: high
Frontier Model Forum: Risk Taxonomy and Thresholds
What do these codes mean?
exact
The source term is equivalent to this element
close
The source term is close but not equivalent to this element
broad
The source term is broader than this element
narrow
The source term is narrower than this element
none
No mapping claim — used for false-friend and declared-but-undefined rows
EQ
Equivalent
CL
Close
BR
Source is broader than the element
NR
Source is narrower than the element
FF
False friend — same or similar label, different meaning
DU
Declared but undefined by the source
UV
Unverified

Related, not mapped

Pointers that are not crosswalk claims

These sources mention this concept but do not define or map it clearly enough to count as a crosswalk row — noted here so the research is visible without overstating it as a mapping.

  • EU GPAI Code of Practice

    A comparative-baseline exemption mechanism related to, but structurally distinct from, a marginal/absolute risk basis; recorded as a pointer, not a mapping.

    EU GPAI Code of Practice, Safety and Security Chapter
  • California SB 53

    A publicly-accessible-information carve-out, conceptually adjacent to a 'baseline of publicly available tools' but stated as a legal exclusion, not a risk-basis definition.

    California SB 53

Divergence

Where sources materially disagree

Four different baselines are in active use across the corpus: OpenAI's 2021-tools baseline; Google DeepMind's no-generative-AI baseline; Anthropic's and OpenAI's other-developers'-current-models baseline; and Anthropic's industry-wide hypothetical. Frontier Model Forum names the collective-action failure ('risk creep') that a purely marginal basis permits when every developer measures only against its immediate competitors rather than a fixed historical point. NIKOLAI's crosswalk keeps these four baselines as distinct controlled values rather than treating 'marginal risk' as one interoperable term.

Referenced across the research world

University of Cambridge logoColumbia University logoCrossref logoUniversity of Edinburgh logoHarvard University logoUniversity of Oxford logoPrinceton University logoStanford School of Medicine logoUniversity College London logoORCID logoUniversity of Cambridge logoColumbia University logoCrossref logoUniversity of Edinburgh logoHarvard University logoUniversity of Oxford logoPrinceton University logoStanford School of Medicine logoUniversity College London logoORCID logo
  • University of Cambridge logo
  • Columbia University logo
  • Crossref logo
  • University of Edinburgh logo
  • Harvard University logo
  • University of Oxford logo
  • Princeton University logo
  • Stanford School of Medicine logo
  • University College London logo
  • ORCID logo

View CASRAI adoption →