Skip to main content
v2026.11,986 entries · CC-BY 4.0

CASP Checklists: Which One and How to Apply It

A decision table for picking the right CASP checklist by study design (RCT, cohort, qualitative, systematic review and more), how the shared validity/results/applicability structure works, and how CASP compares to JBI, Newcastle-Ottawa, and GRADE.

Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board

Published · Last updated

On this page

The CASP checklist you need is set by the design of the paper you are appraising: CASP (the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme) publishes eleven free checklists, one per study design, and each asks you to judge validity, results and local usefulness using Yes, No or Can’t tell answers with reasons. Pick the checklist that matches the paper’s methodology (randomised controlled trial, cohort, qualitative and so on), not your review topic.

Below: a decision table for picking the checklist, how the sections and answer boxes really differ by checklist (the data table after this text compares ten of them), question-by-question walkthroughs for the RCT, cohort and qualitative checklists, why CASP gives no score, how to cite CASP and what its licence allows, and where CASP sits next to JBI, Newcastle-Ottawa and GRADE.

Which CASP checklist to use, by study design

CASP publishes its checklists at casp-uk.net. Match the checklist to the design of the paper you are appraising, not to the design of your own review: a qualitative study cited inside a mixed-methods systematic review still gets the qualitative checklist. The official 2024 titles all begin “CASP checklist: for …”.

If the paper you’re appraising is a… Use this CASP checklist (2024 edition)
Randomised controlled trial (RCT) Randomised controlled trials (RCTs)
Systematic review (the paper itself is a review) Systematic reviews
Systematic review with meta-analysis of RCTs Systematic reviews with meta-analysis of RCTs
Systematic review with meta-analysis of observational studies Systematic reviews with meta-analysis of observational studies
Qualitative study (interviews, focus groups, ethnography) Qualitative research
Cohort study (prospective or retrospective) Cohort studies
Case-control study Case control studies
Cross-sectional study Descriptive/cross-sectional studies
Diagnostic accuracy study Diagnostic test studies
Economic evaluation (cost-effectiveness, cost-utility) Economic evaluations
Clinical prediction rule / risk-prediction model Clinical prediction rule

If a paper does not fit one design cleanly (a mixed-methods study, for instance), appraise each component with its matching checklist rather than forcing the whole paper through one tool. Older editions (for example 2018 and 2022 versions) are still found on the web, so always state which edition you used when you report an appraisal.

How many sections does a CASP checklist have?

Most CASP checklists have three lettered sections: A asks whether the study is valid, B asks what the results are, and C asks whether the results will help locally. CASP’s how-to-use page says most checklists currently have three sections and that a new section, “Is the study methodologically sound?”, is being added as checklists are updated. The 2024 files show the transition:

  • The RCT checklist has four sections: A basic design valid, B methodologically sound, C results, D help locally.
  • The two systematic-review-with-meta-analysis checklists have five (A to E), the last asking whether implementing the results would represent greater value for your service.
  • The economic evaluation checklist uses its own headings: A is the evaluation valid, B how consequences and costs were assessed and compared, C will the results help in purchasing for local people.

The data table below the text sets out the sections and the number of answer boxes for ten of the 2024 checklists. The box counts include sub-items such as (a) and (b), each of which has its own box.

Answer options: Yes, No and Can’t tell

Each question is answered Yes, No or Can’t tell, and CASP asks you to record the reasons for your answer. The 2024 Word files open with the same guidance: never assume what the researchers did; if it is not possible to tell from the paper, answer “Can’t tell”; and if many answers are “Can’t tell”, consider whether the findings are trustworthy and interpret them with caution. The header of each file asks for reviewer name, paper title, author, web link and appraisal date, so an appraisal can be traced later.

“Can’t tell” is a finding in its own right. It usually means the paper under-reports (for instance, it never says who was blinded), and that gap should carry into your write-up rather than be resolved in the study’s favour.

RCT checklist walkthrough

The 2024 RCT checklist asks, in order:

  1. Section A, is the basic design valid? Did the trial address a clearly focused research question (population, intervention, comparator, outcome)? Was assignment to groups randomised, with attention to allocation concealment? Were all participants who entered the trial accounted for at its conclusion, including whether analysis was by intention to treat and whether the trial stopped early?
  2. Section B, is it methodologically sound? Were participants, investigators and outcome assessors blinded? Were the groups similar at the start? Apart from the experimental intervention, were the groups treated equally?
  3. Section C, what are the results? Are effects reported comprehensively (including whether a power calculation is reported, and relative and absolute effects)? How precise are they (confidence intervals)? Do the benefits outweigh the harms and costs?
  4. Section D, will the results help locally? Can the results be applied to your local population?

Illustrative example: applying the RCT checklist

The following is an illustrative composite, not a real trial or a real appraisal; it shows the mechanics, not a verified result. Take a hypothetical trial of a new medication. In Section A the reviewer finds a computer-generated random sequence and sealed opaque envelopes for allocation concealment, so both answers are Yes. In Section B outcome assessors were blinded, but participants could tell which arm they were in because of side effects, so the blinding question is answered with a partial answer and the reason recorded in the reasons box. That limitation is then carried into the Section C judgement about how far to trust the effect size, and is stated in the write-up rather than averaged away.

Cohort study checklist walkthrough

The 2024 cohort checklist runs through these questions: did the study address a focused issue; was the cohort recruited in an acceptable way; was the exposure accurately measured to minimise bias; was the outcome accurately measured; have the authors identified all important confounding factors (a) and taken account of them in the design and analysis (b); was follow-up complete enough (a) and long enough (b)? The results questions then cover what the results are, how precise they are, and whether you believe them, where the checklist points to the Bradford Hill considerations for causality. The local-use questions ask whether the results apply to the local population, fit with other available evidence, and what the implications for practice are.

Qualitative checklist walkthrough

The 2024 qualitative checklist has ten questions. It asks whether there was a clear statement of aims; whether a qualitative methodology is appropriate; whether the research design suits the aims; whether recruitment suited the aims; whether data collection addressed the research issue (including whether saturation was discussed); whether the relationship between researcher and participants was adequately considered (reflexivity); whether ethical issues were taken into consideration; whether data analysis was sufficiently rigorous; whether there is a clear statement of findings; and how valuable the research is. The file ends with an appraisal summary (what is positive and methodologically sound, what is negative or relatively poor, and what remains unknown) and a recommended reference line. This is the checklist for interview, focus-group and ethnographic studies, not the systematic review checklist, even when such a study is being appraised for inclusion in a broader review.

Systematic review checklists: appraising the review itself

Use the systematic reviews checklist when the paper being appraised is itself a systematic review. This is distinct from PRISMA 2020, a reporting checklist for authors writing a review, not an appraisal tool for readers judging one; a review can report everything PRISMA asks for and still be methodologically weak. For reviews that pool results, CASP’s separate meta-analysis checklists (one for RCTs, one for observational studies) use five lettered sections, as set out above.

Does CASP give a score?

No. CASP’s FAQ states that it does not assign a scoring system. It suggests that if the first two or three screening questions are not answered Yes, the evidence may be poor, and it accepts classifying overall quality or risk of bias as high, moderate or low as a way of summarising an appraisal. If your protocol demands a numeric threshold for inclusion, a scored tool such as the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale fits that requirement better.

CASP vs. other critical appraisal tools

Tool Format Best fit
CASP checklists Yes/No/Can’t tell prompts with recorded reasons, no numeric score Individual study appraisal, teaching critical appraisal, journal clubs
JBI Critical Appraisal Tools Yes/No/Unclear/Not applicable items per question Reviews following JBI methodology; see JBI critical appraisal checklists
Newcastle-Ottawa Scale Star-based numeric scoring Cohort and case-control studies where a quantifiable quality score is wanted; see the NOS guide
Cochrane RoB 2 / ROBINS-I Domain-by-domain risk-of-bias judgement Cochrane reviews of RCTs (RoB 2) or non-randomised studies of interventions (ROBINS-I)
GRADE Certainty rating per outcome across the body of evidence Rating overall certainty after study-level appraisal, alongside rather than instead of a study-level tool

These tools are not interchangeable. Check your registered protocol or target journal’s methods requirements before choosing; for a wider overview see choosing a critical appraisal tool for your study design.

Citing CASP and what the licence allows

CASP’s referencing page asks for Harvard-style references with the organisation as author, in this pattern: Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (2024) CASP checklist: for systematic reviews. [online] Available at: URL (Accessed: date). Replace the title, year and URL with those of the checklist and edition you used.

CASP states that its checklists are licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0). In practice that means you may copy and adapt them with attribution, for non-commercial purposes, indicating changes, and share adaptations under the same licence.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a CASP checklist score or cutoff for excluding a study?

No. CASP says it does not assign a scoring system. Many “No” or “Can’t tell” answers in the early screening questions suggest weak evidence, but the judgement is the reviewer’s.

How many questions does a CASP checklist have?

It varies. In the 2024 Word files the qualitative checklist has 10 answer boxes and the RCT checklist 13, while the meta-analysis checklists have 19; see the data table.

What do I do if I answer “Can’t tell” a lot?

Record the reason each time, consider whether the findings are trustworthy, and interpret them with caution, as CASP’s own instructions advise.

Do two reviewers need to apply the checklist independently?

CASP does not mandate a number of appraisers. Systematic review practice, as in the Cochrane Handbook and PRISMA guidance, is two independent reviewers resolving disagreements by discussion; your protocol or journal sets the requirement.

Can I use a CASP checklist for a journal club?

Yes. The checklists are widely used for teaching and journal clubs as well as formal reviews.

Can I adapt or redistribute a CASP checklist?

Under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, yes for non-commercial use with attribution, changes indicated and the same licence on the result.

Is the CASP systematic review checklist the same as PRISMA?

No. PRISMA 2020 tells authors what to report; the CASP checklist helps readers judge whether a published review was methodologically sound. See the PRISMA guide.

Sources

Sources (accessed 15 November 2026).

Data: Structure of the ten CASP 2024 Word checklists: sections and answer boxes

Lettered sections and Yes/No/Can’t Tell answer boxes in ten of the eleven CASP 2024 Word checklists, with the edition year listed on CASP’s referencing page; sub-items such as (a)/(b) each have their own box. The cross-sectional checklist is not included.

Period covered: 2024.

Structure of the ten CASP 2024 Word checklists: sections and answer boxes
CASP checklistEdition yearLettered sections (sections)Section headings (abridged)Answer boxes (boxes)
Systematic reviews (SR)20243A valid review; B results; C help locally10
Systematic reviews with meta-analysis of RCTs20245A basic design valid; B methodologically sound; C results trustworthy; D relevant locally; E value for your service19
Systematic reviews with meta-analysis of observational studies20245A basic design valid; B methodologically sound; C results trustworthy; D relevant locally; E value for your service19
Randomised controlled trials (RCTs)20244A basic design valid; B methodologically sound; C results; D help locally13
Cohort studies20243A results valid; B results; C help locally14
Case control studies20243A results valid; B results; C help locally12
Qualitative research20243A results valid; B results; C help locally10
Economic evaluations20243A evaluation valid; B costs and consequences assessed and compared; C help in purchasing for local people12
Diagnostic test studies20243A results valid; B results; C help locally11
Clinical prediction rule20243A results valid; B results; C help locally11

Sources

Compiled by CASRAI from the sources above. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution.

Follow CASRAI

Research-administration guidance, standards updates and independent tool reviews.

Ask CASRAI · free to try

Ask about CASP Checklists: Which One and How to Apply It

2 free questions a day, no account.

An AI assistant for research: funder rules, compliance, methods and publishing. It links the sources behind its answers and labels answers that come from a web search.

Answers draw on CASRAI's guides and dictionary plus the federal and funder documents we index: Federal Register, Grants.gov, Regulations.gov and UKRI.

Works on this site and inside Claude, Cursor and the AI tools you already use.

Everything CASRAI publishes — this page, the dictionary, the guides and the news — stays open to read, with no account and no card.

Referenced across the research world

University of Cambridge logoColumbia University logoCrossref logoUniversity of Edinburgh logoHarvard University logoUniversity of Oxford logoPrinceton University logoStanford School of Medicine logoUniversity College London logoORCID logoUniversity of Cambridge logoColumbia University logoCrossref logoUniversity of Edinburgh logoHarvard University logoUniversity of Oxford logoPrinceton University logoStanford School of Medicine logoUniversity College London logoORCID logo
  • University of Cambridge logo
  • Columbia University logo
  • Crossref logo
  • University of Edinburgh logo
  • Harvard University logo
  • University of Oxford logo
  • Princeton University logo
  • Stanford School of Medicine logo
  • University College London logo
  • ORCID logo

View CASRAI adoption →