Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board
Published
On this page
The “Harvard Journal of International Law” that people search for is published under the name Harvard International Law Journal (HILJ): a student-edited journal of Harvard Law School that publishes scholarship on public and private international law, with a print edition, a short-form online section and student-written pieces. It is run by students rather than a faculty editorial board, and the pages that describe it do not present a peer-review process, so it is best read as a law review in the American tradition.
Ask CASRAI · free to tryQuestion about this guide? Ask CASRAI answers with linked sources. 2 free questions a day, no account.
What the Harvard International Law Journal is
HILJ describes itself as an officially recognized student-run journal of Harvard Law School whose content is primarily edited by J.D. and LL.M. students. Its home page says it publishes scholarship on international law from authors around the world, and its copyright line names the President and Fellows of Harvard College. The journal’s own “About” page gives its scope as public and private international law, and its submissions page widens that to international, comparative and foreign affairs law.
The name: Harvard Journal of International Law versus Harvard International Law Journal
The official title on the journal’s pages is Harvard International Law Journal, abbreviated HILJ. Searches for “Harvard Journal of International Law” and the generic “journal of international law” land on the same publication, but they can also reach unrelated titles: several Harvard Law School student journals share the “Harvard Journal of …” pattern (for example the Harvard Journal of Law and Technology and the Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy, both profiled in the table below), and many universities publish their own journals of international law. When you cite or submit, use the title exactly as the journal’s own site prints it.
Who runs it and what it covers
The journal’s About page calls HILJ the oldest and most-cited student-edited journal in international law, and says it was named among the ten most influential law journals in the Journal Citation Reports. Both statements are the journal’s own claims, not an independent ranking, so quote them as the journal’s description of itself. The same page says its articles have been cited by the United States Supreme Court, the International Court of Justice, the European Court of Justice, the Iran-United States Claims Tribunal and World Trade Organization dispute panels; the Scholastica page for the journal repeats that list.
Membership on the editorial staff is open to all Harvard Law School students, which is the usual model for a student-edited law review: the people who select and edit manuscripts are law students, working with the authors. Beyond the main volumes, the journal says it hosts speakers and an annual symposium at Harvard Law School, and student writers can take part through an annual Student Note Competition, pieces on recent developments in international law and book reviews of new works in the field.
Student-edited, not peer-reviewed in the usual sense
Researchers coming from the sciences and social sciences often expect a journal to run external peer review. None of the HILJ pages describes that process. They describe a Submissions Committee that reads manuscripts in review sessions. That is a difference in model, not a quality verdict, and it matters for practical reasons: an expedited-review request, the response timeline and the lack of reviewer feedback all follow from the student-edited model. If you are placing the journal in a wider picture of the genre, the Harvard Law Review entry and the guide to law review rankings, both linked below, explain how student-edited law reviews are compared.
The three ways to submit
The submissions page offers three routes: the print edition, HILJ Online and student writing. The journal seeks innovative, original scholarship in international, comparative or foreign affairs law and welcomes work from professors, practitioners and students. The data table below compares the three routes using only what the journal’s pages state.
Print edition
The print edition is the main journal. The journal’s print-submissions page says authors must use Scholastica. The review process runs in two sessions, described next. The journal asks that articles over 30,000 words, footnotes included, be avoided: it describes such articles as strongly discouraged, so that figure is a practical ceiling rather than a target.
HILJ Online
HILJ Online publishes short-form scholarship on international law from authors around the world. Its page says contributions are typically between 500 and 2,500 words and describes them as Perspectives pieces edited and published by Harvard Law School students. It also states that views in the articles belong to the authors, not to the HILJ editorial board. The page does not describe a selection or review procedure, and it points to a separate online submissions page for details.
Student writing
The student-writing route is for law students and covers the Student Note Competition, recent developments and book reviews. The journal’s pages do not set out competition rules on the main submissions page, which only links to the student route, so follow the route’s own page for current terms.
How to submit to the print edition
The print-submissions page, as described on the official page on 2026-11-17, sets out the process. The steps below follow it in order:
- Prepare the manuscript in English, with text and footnotes typed and double-spaced. The submissions page says exact length requirements vary by submission type.
- Format the footnotes to The Bluebook: A Uniform System of Citation. The print-submissions page names the 20th edition; the general submissions page says “most recent edition”, so check which edition the page names when you submit.
- Write an abstract of no more than 250 words and a CV listing recent publications, and include a direct e-mail address and phone number where you can be reached during review.
- Open the journal’s Scholastica site, which the page says must be used, and submit there. Scholastica charges $6.50 per article; the page tells authors facing hardship to contact the Managing Editors.
- Choose your timing. The Submissions Committee meets in two sessions each year, one from late January through April and one from September through November. Submissions made through Scholastica at other times of year are held for the next session unless expedited.
- If another journal has already made you an offer with a deadline, ask for expedited review, which the journal grants in limited cases; the page says to note the request on the Scholastica submission.
- Wait for the decision. The journal aims to respond within a month of receiving a submission and describes its review as taking about three weeks; it does not give feedback on articles that are not selected.
Two rights points to read before you submit: the submissions page states that manuscripts become the journal’s property and are not returned, and it asks authors to be ready to supply cited sources on request. The page does not address simultaneous submissions, so an author who plans to submit elsewhere in parallel should ask the Managing Editors using the contact details on the journal’s site rather than assume.
Where to find the sign-in
Print submissions are made on the journal’s Scholastica site, linked from the print-submissions page, and that is where the sign-in is; the journal’s page also lists an editorial contact for questions about the process. This page does not reproduce an e-mail address, so take it from the journal’s contact page.
Strengths and limits
Strengths
- A defined subject focus. International, comparative and foreign affairs law is stated clearly, so fit is easy to judge from the About page.
- A published timetable. Two review sessions, an abstract limit, a CV requirement and an expedite rule are all written down.
- Several formats. Long articles, 500-2,500 word online pieces and student writing give authors at different career stages a route.
- Author-visible reputation claims, attributed to the journal itself and checkable against the Journal Citation Reports by anyone with access.
Limits
- No stated external peer review, and no feedback on articles that are not selected.
- A per-submission fee through Scholastica, and a required platform for print submissions.
- Rights: the manuscript becomes the journal’s property and is not returned.
- Decisions follow the Submissions Committee’s two sessions, so timing depends on the session calendar rather than a rolling decision process.
- The pages read for this profile do not state an ISSN, indexing list, impact factor or article processing charge, so those fields are not given here; use the library catalogue or the Journal Citation Reports for them.
Alternatives and related pages
The journals below sit in the same family of Harvard Law School student publications or in the same field. The table links to the CASRAI pages that profile them; each page draws on that journal’s own site.
| If you want to | Read |
|---|---|
| Check another Harvard student journal on technology and law | Harvard Journal of Law and Technology |
| Check another Harvard student journal on law and public policy | Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy |
| Understand the flagship student-edited review at Harvard | Harvard Law Review |
| Compare law journals by prestige measures | Law review rankings |
| Look at a learned society in international law | American Society of International Law |
Sources
- Harvard International Law Journal: home page, checked 2026-11-17
- Harvard International Law Journal: About, checked 2026-11-17
- Harvard International Law Journal: Submissions, checked 2026-11-17
- Harvard International Law Journal: Print submissions, checked 2026-11-17
- Harvard International Law Journal Online, checked 2026-11-17
- Scholastica: Harvard International Law Journal submission site, checked 2026-11-17
Data: Harvard International Law Journal: submission routes compared
Compares the three submission routes the Harvard International Law Journal lists (print edition, HILJ Online, student writing) on audience, length guidance, channel and review model, compiled from the journal's own submissions, print-submissions and online pages.
Period covered: 2026. Coverage: Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States.
| Route | Stated audience | Length guidance | Channel | Selection or review as described |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Print edition | Professors, practitioners and students | Over 30,000 words incl. footnotes strongly discouraged | Scholastica, $6.50 per article | Submissions Committee sessions (late Jan-Apr, Sep-Nov); response aimed within a month; no feedback if not selected |
| HILJ Online | Authors around the world | Typically 500 to 2,500 words | Online submissions page linked from the journal site | Student edited; selection procedure not described |
| Student writing | Harvard Law School students | Not stated on the main submissions page | Student submissions page linked from the journal site | Annual Student Note Competition, recent developments, book reviews; rules on the route's own page |
Sources
- Harvard International Law Journal: Submissions (accessed 2026-11-17)
- Harvard International Law Journal: Print submissions (accessed 2026-11-17)
- Harvard International Law Journal Online (accessed 2026-11-17)
- Harvard International Law Journal: home page (accessed 2026-11-17)
Compiled by CASRAI from the sources above. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution.







