Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board
Published · Last updated
On this page
The HEC Journal Recognition System (HJRS) is the Higher Education Commission of Pakistan’s classification of journals into three recognition categories, W, X and Y. Under the HEC Journals and Publications Policy 2024 (applicable from 1 October 2024, amended with effect from 5 November 2025), the category a journal receives is assigned by where it is indexed: Web of Science SCIE, SSCI or AHCI gives W; Web of Science ESCI and qualifying Pakistani Scopus journals give X; other Scopus, MEDLINE/PubMed, CNKI, DOAJ and HEC-recommended national journals give Y.
HJRS is Pakistan’s direct analogue of the mechanism India’s University Grants Commission ran under the name UGC-CARE (see CASRAI’s guide to the UGC-CARE list, its Group I/II structure, and its 2024-2025 discontinuation). Both exist because a national body needed an objective gate on which journals count for career-stage academic decisions, in systems where a raw count of “peer-reviewed publications” was easy to inflate with low-quality or predatory venues. Unlike CARE, HJRS remains an active system run by HEC directly.
This guide covers the W/X/Y rules clause by clause, how the system changed from the Journal Prestige Index (JPI) era to the indexing-based policy, how a journal applies for recognition and what it costs, the conditions attached to the Y category, who decides what counts for promotion and PhD requirements, the weighted authorship model, and how HJRS differs from Scopus and Web of Science indexing. The data table after this article sets the indexing routes side by side for the policy text before and after the 5 November 2025 amendment.
What HJRS Is and Why It Exists
Pakistan’s Higher Education Commission (HEC) is the national regulator for higher education, responsible for university accreditation, funding and quality-assurance policy (see CASRAI’s guide to HEC’s research-funding role for its funder-side function, which is a separate topic from journal recognition). HJRS answers one recurring question: is this a journal whose articles should be treated as recognized scholarly output for HEC-governed purposes? HEC recognition is a precondition for institutions that use HEC-recognized journals when they set publication requirements for appointments, promotions and doctoral degrees. The HEC policy states that the verification of those publications is the job of universities, not HEC (see the section on who decides, below).
The W, X, Y Categories Under the 2024 Policy
The 2024 policy (clause 5a, as amended with effect from 5 November 2025) assigns a category by indexing route:
| Category | What places a journal there |
|---|---|
| W | Indexed in Web of Science SCIE, SSCI or AHCI. The HEC FAQ also states that a W journal must have an official impact factor. |
| X | Indexed in Web of Science ESCI; or a Pakistani journal in Scopus (and not in Web of Science) that meets additional criteria: 25% international authorship (15% for National Strategic Journals), an online management system such as OJS, no self-institutional or editor/board publication, and international expert peer review. |
| Y | Scopus journals (national and international) that do not meet the X criteria; journals in MEDLINE (PubMed), CNKI or DOAJ that are not in Web of Science or Scopus; and national journals recommended by the HEC local committee that meet the Y mandatory criteria. |
Three points are commonly misunderstood. First, ESCI is not a borderline status without a category: the policy places ESCI journals in X. Second, W does not mean “best bibliometrics” by a calculated score; it means membership of one of the three core Web of Science citation indexes. Third, Y is not simply “weak” or “regional”: it covers several international databases (MEDLINE/PubMed, CNKI, DOAJ) as well as national journals. The Scopus, MEDLINE/PubMed, CNKI and DOAJ routes to Y were stated in the HEC FAQ and the policy as amended on 5 November 2025; the earlier HEC-hosted policy text listed Pakistani Scopus journals and HEC-recommended national journals for Y and did not list the other routes.
Is a Scopus-indexed journal always X or Y?
If a journal is indexed only in Scopus, it falls in X when it is Pakistani and meets the extra X criteria above, and otherwise in Y. If it is also in a Web of Science index, the Web of Science route applies (W for SCIE, SSCI or AHCI; X for ESCI). Scopus indexing alone never produces W.
How the System Changed: JPI Era to the 2024 Policy
HJRS in its original form took effect on 1 July 2020 and assigned categories using the Journal Prestige Index (JPI), a composite of six parameters: Eigenfactor and Article Influence Factor from Web of Science, and SCImago Journal Rank (SJR), H-Index, Cites per Document (CD2) and Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) from Scopus. HEC’s own policy text records that HJRS 2023-24 applied until 30 September 2024 and that the revised policy applies from 1 October 2024.
The HEC-hosted policy text also records the complaints that preceded the change. Under the JPI-based HJRS only 14 Pakistani journals were in X and none in W, against 59 in X and 11 in W before it; the JPI did not use the impact factor; the annual update lagged; and journals appearing in DOAJ or ABDC blacklists were excluded. The 2024 policy replaced the calculated score with indexing-based categories. JPI therefore describes the 2020 to September 2024 system and should not be used to work out the category of a journal today.
| Period | How the category was assigned |
|---|---|
| 1 July 2020 to 30 September 2024 | JPI score from two Web of Science and four Scopus parameters (HJRS 2023-24 was the last list) |
| From 1 October 2024 | Indexing route under the HEC Journals and Publications Policy 2024 |
| From 13 July 2025 | Amendment: publisher must be a registered body (see eligibility below) |
| From 5 November 2025 | Amendment: MEDLINE, CNKI and DOAJ routes to Y; Cabell’s list exclusion; clause 6 and 10 provisions below |
Applying for Recognition: Eligibility, Fees and Timeline
Recognition of national journals runs on an annual Call for Accreditation, with applications made through HEC’s portal only. Recognition under the policy ran from 1 October 2024 to 31 December 2025 for the first period, and national journals are recognized per calendar year. The HEC FAQ states the fee as Rs 25,000 for public-sector journals and Rs 50,000 for private-sector journals, non-refundable. An appeal to the Ethical Appeal Review Board (EARB) carries a fee equal to the application fee.
The policy sets these eligibility conditions for a journal applying:
- A verified ISSN, a journal URL and an online archive.
- A public statement of the submission process, fees and funding.
- At least 5 articles per issue in the preceding calendar year, and no more than 30 per issue.
- A registered publisher: a higher education institution, a research institution, or a non-profit society registered with SECP or the Registrar of Societies (this registration condition applies from 13 July 2025).
- A governing body for the journal.
For journals indexed in Web of Science or Scopus, accreditation uses the latest Journal Citation Reports or equivalent (clause 6c). Journals on the Cabell’s predatory list are not recognized (from 5 November 2025).
Y-Category Conditions and the Indexing Deadline
Journals admitted to Y on the national route must meet mandatory criteria (clauses xii to xx of the policy):
- Separate editorial and advisory boards whose members hold PhDs (FCPS, FRCS or MCPS for medical journals).
- At least two reviewer reports per article.
- No more than 20% of articles from the journal’s own institution.
- No more than one article per author per issue.
- No publication by editorial board members, with an exception for regional-language and National Strategic journals: at most 10% per issue, once every two years, with independent foreign peer review.
Y carries a time limit. A national Y journal must become internationally indexed within 7 years if it was recognized under the policy before 1 October 2024, or within 5 years if recognized later; otherwise its Y status is discontinued. For example, a journal first recognized on the national route in the 2025 cycle must be indexed in an international database such as Scopus or DOAJ within five years of that recognition to keep its status, whereas a journal recognized in 2022 has until the seven-year mark.
The FAQ also describes seed funding of up to Rs 250,000 for newly accredited or indexed Y journals from public higher education institutions, usable for two years at most and not for publication fees or APCs. HEC monitors recognized journals and may delist or de-recognize them, conduct site visits and require refund of grants. It also lists capacity-building for editors and collaboration with COPE.
Who Decides What Counts for Promotion and PhD Requirements
HEC classifies journals; it does not decide how many W, X or Y papers a candidate needs. Clause 10a of the policy says the HEC Research and Innovation Division plays no role in utilization criteria, validity or verification of publications for faculty appointments, promotions, PhD supervisors or PhD awards. Quality Enhancement Cells (QECs) of the higher education institutions verify the publications. Universities publish their own thresholds, and those vary between institutions and over time. Check the rule that applies to your own institution and the date of your application with your QEC and your university’s current statutes rather than a general summary.
The practical checklist for a researcher is therefore: confirm the journal is currently recognized, note its category and the date of recognition, confirm that the category is the one your university’s rule names, and keep the dated evidence in your promotion or degree file.
Weighted Authorship and Hijacked Journals
For papers with more than three authors, clause 6a of the policy uses a weighted authorship model: the first author receives 30%, the corresponding author 30%, and the remaining 40% is shared among the other authors. Clause 6b places the responsibility on authors and universities to verify that a journal is genuine and not a hijacked or cloned copy of a real title, for example by checking the ISSN and URL against the publisher’s own site and the indexing database.
HJRS vs. Scopus and Web of Science
Scopus (Elsevier) and Web of Science (Clarivate) are independent bibliographic databases that index journals through their own review. Under the 2024 policy, HJRS uses them as inputs: membership of a particular index places a journal in a category. But the recognition itself is HEC’s. A Pakistani Scopus journal can sit in X or Y depending on whether it meets the extra criteria, a Scopus journal from elsewhere sits in Y, and a national journal not indexed anywhere can be Y at HEC’s recommendation, subject to the indexing deadline above. “Indexed in Scopus” and “recognized by HEC at X” are therefore different claims; check the live HJRS list at hjrs.hec.gov.pk for the current status.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does W, X and Y mean in the 2024 policy?
W is Web of Science SCIE, SSCI or AHCI; X is ESCI plus Pakistani Scopus journals that meet the extra criteria; Y is other Scopus, MEDLINE/PubMed, CNKI, DOAJ and HEC-recommended national journals.
Is the JPI still used?
No. The JPI-based HJRS applied from 1 July 2020, HJRS 2023-24 applied until 30 September 2024, and the revised policy applies from 1 October 2024.
Is ESCI X?
Yes. Journals in Web of Science ESCI are placed in X.
Is a DOAJ journal in Y?
Yes, if it is not in Web of Science or Scopus, under the policy as amended with effect from 5 November 2025.
How much does HEC recognition cost?
The HEC FAQ gives Rs 25,000 for public-sector and Rs 50,000 for private-sector journals, non-refundable; an EARB appeal costs the same as the application.
How long does a new Y journal have to get internationally indexed?
Five years if recognized on or after 1 October 2024; seven years if recognized earlier. Otherwise Y status is discontinued.
Can a journal be de-recognized?
Yes. The policy provides for monitoring, delisting or de-recognition, site visits and refund of grants.
Is a journal on Cabell’s predatory list recognized?
No, from 5 November 2025.
Who verifies publications for promotion?
University QECs. HEC’s Research and Innovation Division has no role in that verification (clause 10a).
What is the weighted authorship model?
For more than three authors: first author 30%, corresponding author 30%, others share 40%.
For the comparable system in India, see CASRAI’s guide to the UGC-CARE list. For HEC’s separate role as a research funder, see Pakistan’s HEC: Research Funding Overview. For the problem both systems guard against, see identifying predatory journals and publishers.
Sources
Sources (accessed 2026-11-12):
- HEC Journals and Publications Policy 2024, as amended with effect from 5 November 2025: https://uoc.edu.pk/Downloads/HEC%20Journals%20and%20Publication%20Policy%202024-As%20amended%20wef%2005-11-2025.pdf
- HEC-hosted journals policy text: https://www.hec.gov.pk/english/services/faculty/journals/Documents/Policies/Policy-Research-Journals.pdf
- HEC Journals FAQs: https://www.hec.gov.pk/english/services/faculty/journals/Pages/FAQs.aspx
Data: HEC journal category by indexing route: policy before and after the 5 November 2025 amendment
Compares which indexing route places a journal in HEC's W, X or Y recognition category, as written in the HEC-hosted journals policy text (before the 5 November 2025 amendment) and the HEC Journals and Publications Policy 2024 as amended with effect from 5 November 2025. Compiled by reading clause 5a of both documents; routes absent from a table are marked 'Not listed'.
Period covered: 2024/2025. Coverage: Pakistan.
| Indexing route | Category before 5 Nov 2025 amendment | Category as amended w.e.f. 5 Nov 2025 | Extra conditions stated in the policy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Web of Science SCIE, SSCI or AHCI | W | W | None stated in clause 5a |
| Web of Science ESCI | X | X | None stated in clause 5a |
| Pakistani journal in Scopus (not in Web of Science) meeting extra criteria | X | X | 25% international authorship; OJS or similar system; no self-institutional or editor/board publication; international expert peer review (National Strategic Journals: 15% international authorship) |
| Scopus journal not meeting the extra X criteria | Y (Pakistani journals) | Y (national and international journals) | Not in Web of Science |
| MEDLINE (PubMed) | Not listed | Y | Not in Web of Science or Scopus |
| CNKI (China National Knowledge Infrastructure) | Not listed | Y | Not in Web of Science or Scopus |
| DOAJ | Not listed | Y | Not in Web of Science or Scopus |
| National journal recommended by HEC local committee | Y | Y | Must meet Y mandatory criteria; must become internationally indexed within 7 years (recognised before 1 Oct 2024) or 5 years (recognised later) |
Sources
- HEC Journals and Publications Policy 2024 (as amended w.e.f. 5 November 2025) (accessed 2026-11-12)
- HEC Journals and Publications Policy (HEC-hosted text) (accessed 2026-11-12)
- HEC Journals FAQs (accessed 2026-11-12)
Compiled by CASRAI from the sources above. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution.







