Skip to main content
v2026.11,986 entries · CC-BY 4.0

The Iowa Model of Evidence-Based Practice: The Full Decision Pathway

The Iowa Model of Evidence-Based Practice is a decision pathway, not a checklist: a trigger moves through explicit go/no-go gates, with two feedback loops, on its way to an adopted practice change. This guide walks the full pathway—triggers, decision points, and both loops—and distinguishes it from RE-AIM (evaluation) and PRECEDE-PROCEED (planning).

Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board

Published · Last updated

On this page

The Iowa Model of Evidence-Based Practice is a decision pathway that carries a clinical problem or new knowledge through nine steps, three of them go/no-go decisions (is the topic a priority, is the evidence sufficient, is the change appropriate for adoption), to an adopted, sustained and disseminated practice change. It was developed at University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics and revised in 2017.

That makes it different from two frameworks it is often confused with. RE-AIM evaluates an intervention someone has already decided to implement; it does not help decide whether to implement one. PRECEDE-PROCEED is a diagnostic planning framework, typically used in health-education and health-promotion programs, upstream of the decision to act. The Iowa Model is the decision pathway itself. The data table below the guide compares the published versions of the model and its companion framework.

What the Iowa Model Is, and Where It Comes From

In one sentence: a team starts from a trigger and a stated question, decides whether the topic is an organizational priority, forms a team, appraises and synthesizes the evidence, and asks whether the evidence is sufficient. It then designs and pilots the change, decides whether it is appropriate for adoption, integrates and sustains it, and disseminates the results.

The model originated at University of Iowa Hospitals & Clinics (UI Health Care). Its first version, the Iowa Model of Research in Practice, was published by Marita Titler and colleagues in Nursing Research in 1994 (43(5):307-313), and a revised evidence-based-practice version followed in 2001 (Critical Care Nursing Clinics of North America 13(4):497-509). It was revised again in 2017 by the Iowa Model Collaborative and republished as “The Iowa Model Revised: Evidence-Based Practice to Promote Excellence in Health Care©” in Worldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing. UI Health Care describes it as the most frequently used EBP model in Magnet®-designated hospitals, and it guides evidence-based decision-making from both a clinician and a systems perspective — it was built for organizational adoption, not individual practitioner judgment alone.

The 2017 revision is documented in “Iowa Model of Evidence-Based Practice: Revisions and Validation” (Iowa Model Collaborative: Buckwalter, Cullen, Hanrahan, Kleiber, McCarthy, Rakel, Steelman, Tripp-Reimer and Tucker; Worldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing, 2017;14(3):175-182; doi 10.1111/wvn.12223). It was a user-driven revision built on a literature review, a survey of 431 people who had requested the model (379 of them, 88%, had used it; requests were logged from 2001 to 2013), and feedback from 299 participants at the 22nd National Evidence-Based Practice Conference in 2015, who validated the revised version. The main changes expanded the model’s treatment of piloting, implementation, patient engagement, and sustaining change.

A separate companion tool, the Iowa Implementation for Sustainability Framework, deals specifically with what happens after a change is adopted. It is covered in its own section below. The pathway that follows is the Iowa Model itself.

The Full Decision Pathway

The revised model has nine steps. Steps 3, 6 and 8 are decisions; the others are activities:

  1. Identify triggering issues or opportunities.
  2. State the question or purpose.
  3. Decision: determine whether the topic is a priority.
  4. Form a team.
  5. Assemble, appraise and synthesize the body of evidence.
  6. Decision: determine whether there is sufficient evidence for the practice change.
  7. Design and pilot the practice change.
  8. Decision: determine whether the change is appropriate for adoption in practice, then integrate and sustain it.
  9. Disseminate results.

Step numbers and wording follow the revised model as reproduced by the University of Hawaii at Manoa library guide to evidence-based nursing. The sections below walk each step in order; the headings keep the older “Decision Point 1-3” labels that many summaries use.

Step 1 — The Trigger: Problem-Focused or Knowledge-Focused

Every pathway starts with one of two trigger types, and naming which one you have shapes everything downstream:

  • Problem-focused triggers surface from an organization’s own operational data: a risk-management event, a quality-improvement or benchmarking finding, a financial pressure, or a recurring clinical problem staff keep raising.
  • Knowledge-focused triggers come from outside the organization’s own data: new research findings, a revised clinical guideline or standard from a professional body, a new accreditation requirement, or a philosophy-of-care shift in the field.

Both trigger types feed the same pathway from this point forward.

Step 2 — State the Question or Purpose

The revised model asks the team to state the question or purpose explicitly before the priority decision. A focused statement, for example whether a particular practice should change on a particular unit, is what the priority decision, the evidence search and the later pilot are all measured against.

Step 3 (Decision Point 1) — Is This Topic a Priority for the Organization?

This is the first real gate, and it exists precisely because not every legitimate trigger is worth an organization’s limited implementation capacity right now. The question is deliberately about organizational fit and timing, not about whether the underlying clinical concern is valid.

If no — the trigger doesn’t proceed under this initiative. It isn’t discarded as wrong; it’s set aside, and a well-run program logs it so a later, better-timed trigger (a new grant, a new hire, a related initiative) can pick it back up. This is the pathway’s first honest exit, not a failure state.

If yes — the topic proceeds to team formation.

Step 4 — Form a Team

An interdisciplinary team is assembled around the specific topic — not a standing committee repurposed for every trigger, but people with a direct stake in the practice area, typically spanning nursing, medicine, and whichever other disciplines the change would touch. Team composition at this stage determines whether the evidence review and pilot design that follow reflect how the change will actually be used, or just how it looks on paper.

Step 5 — Assemble, Appraise, and Synthesize the Evidence

The team searches, retrieves, and critically appraises the available research and other evidence relevant to the trigger, then synthesizes it into a recommendation. This step is where the Iowa Model leans on, without duplicating, formal evidence-synthesis methodology — a team appraising evidence for an Iowa Model pathway is doing critical appraisal, not running a full systematic review with its own registered protocol; that is separate, heavier-weight work with its own methodology and its own place on this site.

Step 6 (Decision Point 2) — Is There Sufficient Evidence for the Practice Change?

This is the gate most implementation efforts genuinely get stuck at, and it’s a real either/or, not a formality on the way to “yes.”

If no — in the 2001 version of the model, the team has two options that the model treats as legitimate rather than as failure: conduct the needed research directly, if the organization has the capacity and the question warrants it; or, more commonly, base practice for now on other available forms of evidence — case reports, expert opinion, scientific principles, theory — while explicitly monitoring and evaluating outcomes as the practice continues. Either branch loops back into the evidence-gathering step rather than ending the pathway: new studies get incorporated as they appear, and monitoring data collected under the interim practice becomes evidence in its own right for a later pass through this same gate.

If yes — the team moves to designing and piloting the change.

Step 7 — Design and Pilot the Practice Change

The team translates the synthesized evidence into a concrete practice change — a guideline, protocol, order set, or care-process redesign — and pilots it on a defined unit or population rather than rolling it out organization-wide. The pilot phase collects both process data (did staff actually do the new thing, and how) and outcome data (did it produce the intended clinical or operational result), because both feed the next decision point.

Step 8 (Decision Point 3) — Is the Change Appropriate for Adoption in Practice?

This is the second gate most summaries compress into a single arrow, and it’s where pilot data either earns organization-wide adoption or sends the team back to the drawing board.

If no — in practice the team returns to earlier work rather than abandoning the topic (this reading is editorial, not a quotation from the model). Depending on what the pilot revealed, the team may redesign the pilot itself, gather additional evidence, or reconsider the practice change’s scope or population before attempting another pilot cycle. A pilot that doesn’t clear this gate has still produced usable information; it just hasn’t produced a green light.

If yes — the change proceeds to organization-wide adoption.

Step 8 (continued) — Integrate and Sustain the Change

The revised model words this as “integrate and sustain” (the 2001 version said “institute”). The practice change moves from pilot unit to standard of care across the organization — updated policies, procedures, competencies, and order sets, not just a memo. This is also the handoff point to the companion Iowa Implementation for Sustainability Framework, whose whole purpose is keeping an adopted change from quietly eroding once the original project team disperses.

Step 9 — Disseminate the Results

The final step is sharing what was learned, both inside the organization and externally — conference presentations, publications, or contribution to a broader evidence base other institutions’ Decision Point 2 will eventually draw on. This step is easy to treat as optional; the model treats it as part of the pathway, not an afterthought, because every dissemination outward is a future knowledge-focused trigger somewhere else.

The Two Feedback Loops, Explicitly

Most secondary summaries of the Iowa Model draw it as a straight line with a couple of diamonds on it. The two loops are the actual mechanism, and both point backward into evidence work rather than forward into abandonment:

  • The evidence-sufficiency loop (out of Decision Point 2): insufficient evidence doesn’t stop the pathway — it routes back into further inquiry, either through direct research or through monitored interim practice on other evidence types, and either route eventually feeds back into a re-appraisal of whether evidence is now sufficient.
  • The adoption-appropriateness loop (out of Decision Point 3): a pilot that doesn’t clear adoption routes back into redesign — of the pilot, the evidence base, or the change’s scope — rather than closing the topic out as failed.

Both loops are an editorial reading of how a “no” at those gates plays out in practice. They are what make the Iowa Model a genuine decision pathway rather than a linear checklist: a “no” at either gate is routing information, not an end state.

What the 2017 Validation Found

The 2017 revision was explicitly user-driven. The authors reviewed the literature, surveyed people who had requested the model between 2001 and 2013 (431 respondents; 88%, or 379, had used it), and collected 587 comments. The steps respondents found most problematic were determining the topic priority, critiquing the evidence, piloting the change and instituting the change. A later round of feedback from 299 participants at the 22nd National Evidence-Based Practice Conference in 2015 validated the revised model. The result expanded the treatment of piloting, implementation, patient engagement and sustaining change, and the authors describe it as an application-oriented guide for point-of-care clinicians (Iowa repository record of the paper; PMID 28632931).

Practically, that explains why the revised sequence adds an explicit “state the question or purpose” step and splits “design and pilot” from “integrate and sustain”: those are the places users reported needing more help.

Version History at a Glance

The model has been published in three forms, with a separate companion framework added in 2022. The data table below the guide compares them side by side (citation, scope and the evaluation figures the authors report). In short: the 1994 Iowa Model of Research in Practice was a heuristic for infusing research into practice at University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics; the 2001 version broadened it to other types of evidence and added detail on pilot testing and implementation; the 2017 revision added the nine-step sequence described above; and the 2022 Iowa Implementation for Sustainability Framework moved from the model’s decision pathway to the strategies for making a change stick.

The Iowa Implementation for Sustainability Framework

The Iowa Implementation for Sustainability Framework is a companion to the Iowa Model, not a replacement for it. It was published by Cullen, Hanrahan, Edmonds, Reisinger, and Wagner in Implementation Science in 2022 (PubMed 34983585). It is aimed at clinicians and is based on Diffusion of Innovations theory. Where the Iowa Model asks whether to change practice, this framework catalogues the implementation strategies that help a chosen change take hold and stay in place.

  • Structure. The authors started from a framework listing 81 strategies with suggested timing across four implementation phases. They surveyed past users, had nurse leaders sort the strategies into groups, and had an expert panel refine the result.
  • Result. The revised version specifies 75 strategies across four phases and 10 domains, presented as a typology for guiding evidence-based healthcare implementation.
  • How it connects to the pathway. UI Health Care presents it as the tool for implementing and maintaining EBP changes, which is the part of the pathway that follows the decision to adopt.

Phases and domains

The four phases are Creating awareness and interest; Building knowledge and commitment; Promoting action and adoption; and Pursuing integration and sustained use. The ten domains are Marketing, Information, Learning, Commitment, Change Agents, Decision Support, Adaptation, Data, Organizational Infrastructure and Reinforcement.

How the revision was built

The authors surveyed past users of the framework: 127 of 1,578 requesters (8%) responded. Twenty-three nurse leaders sorted the strategies into groups. Of the 81 original strategies, 54 (66.7%) were tied to a single phase by the sorting, and 30 of those 54 matched the original placement. In the usability questions, 92% of respondents rated the framework useful and 96.4% judged its four phases accurate.

University of Iowa Health Care lists the framework alongside the Iowa Model as a tool for putting EBP changes into practice and keeping them going (UI Health Care, Evidence-Based Practice).

How the Iowa Model Differs from RE-AIM and PRECEDE-PROCEED

All three names show up in the same implementation-science reading lists, which is exactly why they get conflated. They answer different questions:

  • The Iowa Model answers: given this trigger, should we change practice, and how do we get from here to an adopted, sustained change? It is a decision pathway with go/no-go gates, built for organizational, unit-level adoption decisions in a clinical setting.
  • RE-AIM (Reach, Effectiveness, Adoption, Implementation, Maintenance) answers: now that an intervention exists, how well is it actually performing across those five dimensions? It is an evaluation framework, applied to a program or intervention that has already been implemented — it doesn’t help decide whether to start.
  • PRECEDE-PROCEED answers: before we design an intervention at all, what social, epidemiological, behavioral, and environmental factors should shape it? It is a planning and diagnostic framework, most associated with health-education and health-promotion program design, and it operates upstream of the decision the Iowa Model’s first gate makes.

A program can legitimately use all three in sequence — PRECEDE-PROCEED to diagnose and design, the Iowa Model to decide and pilot the practice change, RE-AIM to evaluate how it performs once live — because they’re not competing for the same job. For a framework built around an individual practitioner’s own call rather than a team gate, see the Stetler Model of Research Utilization.

When the Iowa Model Fits

The Iowa Model was developed in and for hospital nursing practice and remains most at home there — it’s the model UI Health Care itself reports as most common in Magnet-designated organizations, and its interdisciplinary-team, unit-level-pilot structure assumes a hospital or health-system operating context. It fits well when a trigger is genuinely unit- or organization-scale (a care protocol, an order set, a unit workflow) and there’s an interdisciplinary team available to run the evidence review and pilot. It fits less well as a tool for an individual clinician’s point-of-care decision, or for research questions that need formal systematic-review methodology rather than team-level critical appraisal — those belong to a registered review protocol, not this pathway. Other EBP models (Johns Hopkins Nursing EBP, ARCC, Stetler, ACE Star) cover overlapping ground with different mentor-requirement and appraisal-tool tradeoffs; choosing among them is a separate question from understanding how this one’s pathway actually works.

Using, Training and Citing the Model

UI Health Care publishes the model and its companion tools on its evidence-based practice page, together with training offerings such as an EBP staff nurse internship, change champion training, advanced EBP immersion, mentorship and a scholarship to the National EBP Conference (UI Health Care, Evidence-Based Practice). The revised model is copyrighted under the title “Iowa Model Revised: Evidence-Based Practice to Promote Excellence in Health Care©” and its flowchart is marked as revised in June 2015. Request permission from UI Health Care before reproducing the chart; this guide describes it in words and does not copy it.

To cite it, use the 2017 paper: Iowa Model Collaborative, Buckwalter, K. C., Cullen, L., Hanrahan, K., Kleiber, C., McCarthy, A. M., Rakel, B., Steelman, V., Tripp-Reimer, T., & Tucker, S. (2017). Iowa Model of Evidence-Based Practice: Revisions and Validation. Worldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing, 14(3), 175-182. https://doi.org/10.1111/wvn.12223

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the two types of triggers in the Iowa Model?

Problem-focused triggers come from an organization’s own operational data — risk-management events, quality or benchmarking data, financial pressure, or a recurring clinical problem. Knowledge-focused triggers come from outside the organization — new research, revised professional guidelines, or new accreditation standards. Both feed the same downstream pathway.

What happens if there isn’t sufficient evidence at Decision Point 2?

The pathway doesn’t end. The team either conducts the needed research directly or bases interim practice on other evidence types (case reports, expert opinion, theory) while monitoring outcomes, and both routes loop back into the evidence-gathering step rather than closing the topic out.

How is the Iowa Model different from a PDSA cycle?

They operate at different scopes and answer different questions. The PDSA cycle is a small, rapid test-of-change method for learning whether a specific change works, typically run in hours or days on a handful of patients. The Iowa Model is the larger organizational decision pathway that determines whether a practice change should be pursued at all, appraises the evidence behind it, and governs the pilot-to-adoption decision — a team could reasonably use PDSA cycles as the mechanism for the Iowa Model’s own pilot step.

Is the Iowa Model only used in nursing?

It originated in nursing at University of Iowa Hospitals & Clinics and remains most associated with hospital nursing practice, particularly in Magnet-designated organizations, but its interdisciplinary-team structure means it is applied across other clinical disciplines within a health system, not exclusively by nurses.

What changed in the 2017 revision?

The 2017 revision, published by the Iowa Model Collaborative as “Iowa Model of Evidence-Based Practice: Revisions and Validation” (the revised model carries the copyrighted title “Iowa Model Revised: Evidence-Based Practice to Promote Excellence in Health Care”), was a user-driven revision, validated through a user survey and conference feedback, that expanded the model’s treatment of piloting, implementation, patient engagement, and sustaining change. Its companion, the Iowa Implementation for Sustainability Framework, is a separate publication (2022).

What are the steps of the Iowa Model of Evidence-Based Practice?

The pathway runs from a trigger (problem-focused or knowledge-focused) to a priority decision, team formation, evidence assembly, appraisal and synthesis, a sufficiency-of-evidence decision, design and pilot of the change, an adoption decision, institution and sustaining of the change, and dissemination of results. The two decisions that can send a team back to earlier work are evidence sufficiency and adoption.

What is the Iowa Implementation for Sustainability Framework?

It is a clinician-oriented companion framework published in 2022 that organizes 75 implementation strategies into four phases and 10 domains, based on Diffusion of Innovations theory. It helps a team put an adopted change into practice and keep it there.

What are the decision points in the revised Iowa Model?

Three of the nine steps are decisions: whether the topic is a priority (step 3), whether there is sufficient evidence for the practice change (step 6), and whether the change is appropriate for adoption in practice (step 8).

Who developed the Iowa Model and when?

It was developed at University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics, first published by Titler and colleagues in 1994, revised in 2001, and revised again in 2017 by the Iowa Model Collaborative.

How do I cite the Iowa Model or get permission to use its flowchart?

Cite Iowa Model Collaborative et al. (2017), Worldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing 14(3):175-182. The model is copyrighted, so request permission from UI Health Care before reproducing the flowchart.

Sources

Sources (accessed 2026-11-14):

Data: Published versions of the Iowa Model and its companion framework, 1994-2022

Compares each published version of the Iowa Model of Evidence-Based Practice and the Iowa Implementation for Sustainability Framework: citation, what the version covers and the evaluation figures its authors report. Compiled from the journal records and abstracts listed in sources.

Period covered: 1994/2022.

Published versions of the Iowa Model and its companion framework, 1994-2022
VersionYear (year)PublicationScope or changeUsers or participants surveyed (people)Strategies specified (count)
Iowa Model of Research in Practice1994Nursing Research 43(5):307-313 (Titler et al.)Heuristic model for infusing research into practice at University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics
Iowa Model of EBP to Promote Quality Care2001Critical Care Nursing Clinics of North America 13(4):497-509Revised to include other types of evidence and more detail on pilot testing and implementing the change
Iowa Model Revised2017Worldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing 14(3):175-182 (Iowa Model Collaborative; Buckwalter et al.)Expanded piloting, implementation, patient engagement, sustaining change; validated with 299 conference participants431
Iowa Implementation for Sustainability Framework2022Implementation Science 17 (Cullen et al.)Typology of strategies in 4 phases and 10 domains, revised from an 81-strategy framework12775

Follow CASRAI

Research-administration guidance, standards updates and independent tool reviews.

Ask CASRAI · full access

Ask about The Iowa Model of Evidence-Based Practice: The Full Decision Pathway

Full access: large monthly usage, up to 10 source passages behind each answer, and MCP and API access for Claude Code, Codex and other CLIs. Cancel any time.

An AI assistant for research: funder rules, compliance, methods and publishing. It links the sources behind its answers and labels answers that come from a web search.

Answers draw on CASRAI's guides and dictionary plus the federal and funder documents we index: Federal Register, Grants.gov, Regulations.gov and UKRI.

Works on this site and inside Claude, Cursor and the AI tools you already use.

Everything CASRAI publishes — this page, the dictionary, the guides and the news — stays open to read, with no account and no card.

Referenced across the research world

University of Cambridge logoColumbia University logoCrossref logoUniversity of Edinburgh logoHarvard University logoUniversity of Oxford logoPrinceton University logoStanford School of Medicine logoUniversity College London logoORCID logoUniversity of Cambridge logoColumbia University logoCrossref logoUniversity of Edinburgh logoHarvard University logoUniversity of Oxford logoPrinceton University logoStanford School of Medicine logoUniversity College London logoORCID logo
  • University of Cambridge logo
  • Columbia University logo
  • Crossref logo
  • University of Edinburgh logo
  • Harvard University logo
  • University of Oxford logo
  • Princeton University logo
  • Stanford School of Medicine logo
  • University College London logo
  • ORCID logo

View CASRAI adoption →