Skip to main content
v2026.11,986 entries · CC-BY 4.0

The PRECEDE-PROCEED Model: What Each of the 8 Phases Produces, and How It Differs From RE-AIM

PRECEDE-PROCEED is an eight-phase framework for planning and evaluating health and social-behavior programmes: four assessment phases (social, epidemiological/behavioral/environmental, educational/ecological, administrative/policy) that diagnose what to target and why, followed by implementation and three evaluation phases (process, impact, outcome) that check whether it worked. This guide covers what each phase actually produces as a planning artifact, works through an illustrative example, and distinguishes the model from RE-AIM, which evaluates an intervention that already exists rather than diagnosing what to build.

Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board

Published · Last updated

On this page

The PRECEDE-PROCEED model is an eight-phase framework for planning and evaluating health and social-behavior programmes, developed by Lawrence W. Green and later formalised with Marshall W. Kreuter. Its defining feature is sequencing: the model runs backwards from a community-defined quality-of-life outcome to the specific behaviours, environmental conditions, and administrative resources an intervention has to change to reach it, then runs forward again through implementation and evaluation to check whether it actually did.

That backwards-then-forwards structure is what separates PRECEDE-PROCEED from a framework like RE-AIM, which is evaluation-only. PRECEDE-PROCEED’s first four phases exist to produce the diagnostic case for an intervention design before anything is built; its last four evaluate the specific things those first four phases said mattered. A programme can use RE-AIM to report on an intervention that already exists. It cannot use RE-AIM to decide what that intervention should target in the first place — that is what PRECEDE-PROCEED’s front half is for.

Terminology. PRECEDE is an acronym for Predisposing, Reinforcing, and Enabling Constructs in Ecological Diagnosis and Evaluation — the four assessment phases described below. PROCEED stands for Policy, Regulatory, and Organizational Constructs in Educational and Environmental Development — the implementation and evaluation phases that follow. The eight-phase structure below is the numbering most widely taught and cited; the data table after this article compares how two sources label each phase.

Short Answer: How Many Phases Does PRECEDE-PROCEED Have?

Eight. Phases 1 to 4 are the PRECEDE half (diagnosis and planning): social, epidemiological, educational and ecological, and administrative and policy assessment. Phases 5 to 8 are the PROCEED half: implementation, process evaluation, impact evaluation and outcome evaluation. The Community Tool Box at the University of Kansas presents the model as a circular flowchart that starts at the upper right with a community demographic and quality-of-life assessment and moves counterclockwise through the four PRECEDE phases to the health program itself, then through the PROCEED phases, looping back to the start either after the outcome is achieved or to begin a new cycle with lessons learned.

Edition History of the Model

The model has been published in five textbook editions, according to the editions list on Lawrence Green’s site:

Edition Year Title Authors
1st 1980 Health Education Planning: A Diagnostic Approach Green, Kreuter, Deeds and Partridge
2nd 1991 Health Promotion Planning: An Educational and Environmental Approach Green and Kreuter
3rd 1999 Health Promotion Planning: An Educational and Ecological Approach Green and Kreuter
4th 2005 Health Program Planning: An Educational and Ecological Approach Green and Kreuter
5th 2022 Health Program Planning, Implementation, and Evaluation: Creating Behavioral, Environmental, and Policy Change Green, Gielen, Ottoson, Peterson and Kreuter

The subtitles explain why the acronym wording varies between sources: the second edition framed the approach as educational and environmental, and the third and fourth as educational and ecological. Phase 3 is therefore labelled “educational and ecological” in some sources and “educational and organizational” in the Community Tool Box, and some summaries expand the acronym with “Educational” where others use “Ecological”. They describe the same phase: the assessment of predisposing, enabling and reinforcing factors.

The Eight Phases, and What Each One Actually Produces

Each phase of PRECEDE-PROCEED is easy to describe as a diagnostic question, but the question alone doesn’t tell you what to do with the answer. What matters for actually running the model is the concrete planning artifact each phase is supposed to hand to the next one — the document, list, or dataset that phase 2 can’t start without phase 1’s output, and so on down the chain.

Phase 1: Social Assessment

Question: What quality-of-life problem does the target population itself say it has? Method: participatory data collection directly from the population — surveys, focus groups, community forums, existing social indicators (unemployment, crime, absenteeism, housing instability). Artifact produced: a written statement of the community-prioritized social problem(s) and quality-of-life goals. This is the reference point every later phase has to trace back to — Phase 8’s outcome evaluation measures against exactly this document, not against whatever health metric turned out to be convenient to collect.

Phase 2: Epidemiological, Behavioral, and Environmental Assessment

Question: Which specific health problems contribute to the Phase 1 social problem, and which behaviors and environmental conditions cause those health problems? Method: vital statistics, morbidity and mortality data, surveillance records, and epidemiological literature, decomposed into what people do (behavioral) versus what surrounds them outside individual control (environmental). Artifact produced: a ranked list of health determinants plus a set of specific, measurable behavioral and environmental objectives — who will do what, by how much, by when — that the intervention is accountable for moving.

Phase 3: Educational and Ecological (Organizational) Assessment

Question: Of the behavioral and environmental factors named in Phase 2, which ones can an educational or environmental intervention actually change, and why do they currently look the way they do? Method: sorting causes into three categories — predisposing factors (existing knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, values, perceived self-efficacy: the motivational precursors to a behavior), reinforcing factors (the attitudes and responses of influential people and groups, such as family, peers, teachers, employers, service providers, the media and community leaders, that determine whether a behavior is encouraged and repeated), and enabling factors (internal and external conditions that help people adopt or maintain a behavior: resource availability, service accessibility, laws and policies, and issue-related skills — for example clinic hours, cost, transportation and service availability) — then rating each factor on importance and changeability. Artifact produced: a predisposing/reinforcing/enabling factor matrix, ranked by importance × changeability, that becomes the direct target list for intervention design. This is the phase that gives PRECEDE its name, and the one most under-resourced programmes shortcut by guessing at factors instead of assessing them.

Phase 4: Administrative and Policy Assessment

Question: Given the target list from Phase 3, what can the implementing organization actually build, and what will help or block it? Method: an audit of available budget, staff time and skill, facility and equipment resources, plus existing policies, regulations, or organizational rules — including those inside partner organizations the programme depends on. Artifact produced: a resourced, sequenced implementation plan — the intervention design, budget, staffing assignment, and timeline — plus a documented list of policy or administrative barriers that have to clear before Phase 5 can start. This is where PROCEED’s own name-giving constructs (Policy, Regulatory, Organizational) get resolved into a go/no-go on the intervention as designed.

Phase 5: Implementation

Question: Does the Phase 4 plan actually run as designed? Method: delivery of the intervention itself — this is not a diagnostic phase, it is the programme happening. Artifact produced: the intervention as actually delivered, documented through attendance and enrollment logs, delivery records, and any deviations from the Phase 4 plan noted as they occur — because Phase 6 has to account for those deviations, not the plan as originally written.

Phase 6: Process Evaluation

Question: Did Phase 5 happen the way Phase 4 planned? Method: measuring reach (who actually enrolled versus who was targeted), dose delivered versus dose planned, and fidelity to the intervention design. Artifact produced: a fidelity and reach report that tells you, if Phase 7 or 8 disappoints, whether the problem was the intervention’s design or its delivery — a distinction the later evaluation phases cannot make on their own.

Phase 7: Impact Evaluation

Question: Did the intermediate objectives set in Phases 2 and 3 actually move? Method: pre/post or comparison-group measurement of the specific predisposing, reinforcing, and enabling factors, and the behavioral and environmental targets, named earlier in the model. Artifact produced: a direct test of whether the programme’s underlying causal logic — change these factors, and behavior changes — actually held up in this population.

Phase 8: Outcome Evaluation

Question: Did the health status and quality-of-life indicators the community named in Phase 1 actually change? Method: outcome measurement against the Phase 1 social-diagnosis goals, on the timescale those goals genuinely require — often years, not the length of a single grant or funding cycle. Artifact produced: the closed loop back to Phase 1: evidence of whether the whole eight-phase chain, from social diagnosis through delivery, actually reached the outcome the population said it wanted.

A Worked Illustrative Example (Composite)

Illustrative example — the scenario below is a composite constructed to show what each phase’s artifact looks like in practice. It does not describe a real, named programme, institution, or dataset, and no figure in it should be cited as an actual outcome.

A county health department is asked to address rising youth vaping rates. Phase 1 community forums surface that residents’ actual concern is broader — declining adolescent wellbeing and school engagement, of which vaping is one visible symptom. Phase 2 epidemiological review narrows this to two behavioral targets (vaping initiation among 12-14 year-olds, and product availability near schools) and one environmental target (retailer compliance with age-verification requirements). Phase 3 identifies predisposing factors (perceived low harm, peer normalization), reinforcing factors (social-media content that rewards use with attention), and enabling factors (low-cost disposable products sold within walking distance of two middle schools) — ranked so that retailer proximity and perceived-harm messaging score highest on importance × changeability. Phase 4 finds the health department has grant funding for a school-based curriculum but no legal authority over retailer licensing, so the administrative plan pairs a curriculum intervention (within the department’s control) with a referral to the county’s licensing board (outside it, flagged as a dependency). Phases 5 through 8 then deliver the curriculum, check it reached the targeted schools at the planned dose, measure whether perceived-harm attitudes shifted, and — over a longer follow-up window — check whether initiation rates actually declined.

Predisposing, Reinforcing and Enabling Factors Compared

The Community Tool Box defines the three factor types that give PRECEDE its name as follows:

Factor type Definition Examples of what to assess
Predisposing Knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, values and confidence that make people more or less likely to adopt a behavior; educational interventions can often influence them Knowledge of risks, beliefs about harm, confidence in carrying out the behavior
Enabling Internal and external conditions that help people adopt or maintain a behavior, including resource availability, service accessibility, laws and policies, and issue-related skills Access to services, cost, relevant laws, skills
Reinforcing The attitudes of influential people and groups: family, peers, teachers, employers, service providers, media, community leaders and politicians Whether family, peers and providers support or discourage the behavior

Because Phase 3 separates what people believe, what they can actually do and what their surroundings encourage, an intervention team can match each factor to a different kind of action: education for predisposing factors, resources and policy for enabling factors, and work with family, peers and providers for reinforcing factors. Phase 3 sits between the behavioral and environmental targets of Phase 2 and the resource questions of Phase 4, and its ranked factor list is the hand-off between the two.

A Second Worked Example: Smoking Cessation (Community Tool Box)

The Community Tool Box illustrates the first two phases with a smoking example. The outcome chosen in Phase 1 is reducing lung cancer and heart disease and improving the overall quality of life of the community. In Phase 2 the page argues that smoking is a good target behavior because it meets two criteria: it strongly affects the outcome, and an intervention can change it. It lists downstream benefits of fewer smokers: less secondhand smoke, less work time lost to smoking-related illness, fewer low-birth-weight babies, fewer children with asthma and respiratory ailments, and lower health care costs. It lists reasons the behavior is changeable: many people want to quit, public knowledge of the dangers is high, tobacco is expensive, community support exists, and cessation groups can be built into the intervention.

Mapped onto Phase 3 (an editorial reading, not text from the Community Tool Box), knowledge of the dangers is a predisposing factor, cessation groups and the cost of tobacco are enabling factors, and family and peer attitudes are reinforcing factors.

What the 2022 Fifth Edition Changed

According to the description of the 2022 edition on Lawrence Green’s site, the foundations of the model “hold firm” for Phases 1, 2, 4, 6 and 8, and the innovations center on Phases 4 and 5. In the fifth edition, Phase 4 brings forward not only PROCEED intervention strategies but also implementation and evaluation strategies. Phase 5 now focuses on process evaluation of interventions. Phases 6 to 8 cover implementation of PROCEED tasks, including evaluation of short-term, intermediate and long-term outcomes, which were previously named “impact” and “outcomes”. Three new co-authors, Andrea Gielen, Judith Ottoson and Darleen Peterson, joined Green and Kreuter.

The practical consequence is that the same model is numbered two ways in the literature. The classic numbering used in the phase descriptions on this page (diagnoses 1 to 4, implementation 5, then process, impact and outcome evaluation 6 to 8) is what the Community Tool Box and most earlier publications use. A source citing the 2022 edition may describe Phase 5 as process evaluation, so always check which edition a source follows before comparing phase numbers.

Does PRECEDE-PROCEED Work? What the Evidence Review Found

A 2022 systematic review and meta-analysis in Systematic Reviews (“Effect of the PRECEDE-PROCEED model on health programs”, DOI 10.1186/s13643-022-02092-2) examined studies applying the model. It included 26 studies, 11 of which entered the meta-analysis. For knowledge outcomes, the pooled standardized mean difference was 3.64 across seven randomized controlled trials and 1.68 across four quasi-experimental studies. Behavior improved in 11 studies, but behavior outcomes were not pooled. Heterogeneity was very high (I² between 95% and 98%), and the review included only English-language studies and excluded studies that used the PRECEDE half alone.

Reading this for planning purposes: the evidence supports the model as a way to produce programs that improve knowledge, while the pooled evidence for behavior and health-status outcomes is more limited. A large pooled effect with I² this high says that effects vary widely between programs, not that any one program will reach that effect size. A single application should be judged against its own Phase 7 and Phase 8 evaluation.

When to Use PRECEDE-PROCEED, and How to Adapt It

The Community Tool Box recommends the model when you want a structured, participatory, comprehensive plan that includes evaluation. Its listed advantages are that it:

  • gives planning a structure so it is not ad hoc;
  • offers a framework for critical analysis of issues;
  • is participatory, which improves information and builds community ownership;
  • addresses administrative and policy constraints that are often overlooked;
  • includes evaluation at process, impact and outcome levels, allowing adjustment; and
  • says little about content, so methods can be adapted to local needs.

The same source lists limitations: the model applies a diagnosis-then-treatment, medical perspective to community work; it is only as good as its fit, so parts that do not suit a setting should be changed; formal Phase 6 to 8 evaluations require resources many users lack, though simple record-keeping and checking what was done against what was intended still help; and applications may sometimes be top-down, which undermines the participatory intent. It advises adapting the model: the flowchart is meant to help decide which steps to skip, the order and timing can change to match community needs, evaluation can be scaled to resources, and PRECEDE can be revisited at any point during PROCEED if results or implementation reveal gaps.

Where the Model Fits in a Research or Evaluation Office

For a research office or evaluation team, the most useful property of the model is traceability: every Phase 6 to 8 measure traces back to a named Phase 1 to 4 decision. That makes it a natural scaffold for a grant’s evaluation plan or a program’s theory of change, and it pairs with quality-improvement methods such as the PDSA cycle and the Model for Improvement. When a quality-improvement project might also be research, the IRB determination guide covers the review question.

PRECEDE-PROCEED vs. RE-AIM: Planning-and-Evaluation vs. Evaluation-Only

RE-AIM—Reach, Effectiveness, Adoption, Implementation, Maintenance—is a dimension-based framework for evaluating a public-health intervention’s real-world impact. It has no equivalent to PRECEDE-PROCEED’s Phases 1 through 4: RE-AIM does not diagnose a social problem, rank health determinants, sort predisposing/reinforcing/enabling factors, or produce an administrative feasibility assessment. It assumes an intervention already exists and asks how well it reaches its intended population, works under real-world conditions, gets adopted by delivery settings, is implemented with fidelity, and is maintained over time.

That makes the two frameworks complementary rather than competing. PRECEDE-PROCEED’s front half is a program-planning tool: it tells a team what to build and why, grounded in a documented diagnostic chain from community-stated problem to specific behavioral targets. RE-AIM is a reporting tool: it gives an already-built intervention a standardized vocabulary for describing its external validity, most often used when publishing dissemination or translational results. A team can use PRECEDE-PROCEED Phases 1 through 4 to design an intervention, deliver it, and then report on it using RE-AIM’s five dimensions instead of (or alongside) PRECEDE-PROCEED’s own Phases 6 through 8 — the two are not mutually exclusive.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does PRECEDE stand for?

Predisposing, Reinforcing, and Enabling Constructs in Ecological Diagnosis and Evaluation — the label for the model’s four front-end assessment phases.

What does PROCEED stand for?

Policy, Regulatory, and Organizational Constructs in Educational and Environmental Development — the label for the implementation and evaluation phases that follow the PRECEDE assessment.

Who developed the PRECEDE-PROCEED model?

Lawrence W. Green developed the original PRECEDE framework, first published in 1980; Marshall W. Kreuter collaborated on later editions that added the PROCEED implementation-and-evaluation half.

Is PRECEDE-PROCEED a theory or a planning framework?

A planning and evaluation framework, not a behavioral theory in itself. It’s a structure for applying behavioral, epidemiological, and organizational evidence to a specific programme decision — it doesn’t propose a new causal mechanism the way a theory like the Health Belief Model does, and it’s commonly used alongside such theories rather than instead of them.

How is PRECEDE-PROCEED different from a logic model?

A logic model is a general-purpose diagram of inputs, activities, outputs, and outcomes; it documents a programme’s intended causal chain but doesn’t specify a method for deriving which factors that chain should target. PRECEDE-PROCEED’s Phases 1 through 4 produce a logic model’s content with a documented derivation behind it — the ranked predisposing/reinforcing/enabling matrix from Phase 3, specifically, is the part a generic logic model template has no equivalent step for.

When was PROCEED added to the model?

The first edition (1980) was titled Health Education Planning: A Diagnostic Approach. The second edition (1991), by Green and Kreuter, was titled Health Promotion Planning: An Educational and Environmental Approach; the PROCEED implementation-and-evaluation half is associated with this edition.

What is new in the 2022 edition of PRECEDE-PROCEED?

The fifth edition keeps the foundations of Phases 1, 2, 4, 6 and 8 and innovates on Phases 4 and 5: Phase 4 now brings forward implementation and evaluation strategies, and Phase 5 focuses on process evaluation. Phases 6 to 8 cover implementation and the evaluation of short-term, intermediate and long-term outcomes.

What are predisposing, reinforcing and enabling factors?

Predisposing factors are knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, values and confidence; enabling factors are conditions such as resources, service accessibility, laws and skills; reinforcing factors are the attitudes of influential people such as family, peers, providers and community leaders.

Is there evidence that PRECEDE-PROCEED works?

A 2022 systematic review and meta-analysis found large pooled knowledge gains (standardized mean difference 3.64 across seven randomized trials and 1.68 across four quasi-experimental studies) with very high heterogeneity, and improved behavior in 11 of 26 included studies without pooling behavior outcomes.

Can you skip phases of PRECEDE-PROCEED?

The Community Tool Box recommends adapting the model and says its flowchart is meant to help decide which steps to skip; it also notes that evaluation can be scaled to available resources.

Is Phase 3 “educational and ecological” or “educational and organizational”?

Both labels appear. The Community Tool Box says educational and organizational diagnosis; later editions of the textbook use “educational and ecological” in their subtitles. The content of the phase is the same: predisposing, enabling and reinforcing factors.

Sources

Sources (accessed 2026-11-17):

  • Community Tool Box, University of Kansas, “Chapter 2, Section 2. PRECEDE/PROCEED”: ctb.ku.edu
  • Lawrence W. Green, “PRECEDE-PROCEED 2022 Edition” (editions list and fifth-edition changes; Green, Gielen, Ottoson, Peterson and Kreuter, Johns Hopkins University Press, 2022): lgreen.net
  • “Effect of the PRECEDE-PROCEED model on health programs: a systematic review and meta-analysis”, Systematic Reviews, 2022, DOI 10.1186/s13643-022-02092-2: PubMed Central
  • Wikipedia, “PRECEDE–PROCEED model” (phase labels): en.wikipedia.org

Data: PRECEDE-PROCEED eight phases: labels, the question each answers and the half of the model, compiled from the Community Tool Box and Wikipedia phase lists

Eight rows, one per phase. Compares how the Community Tool Box and Wikipedia label each phase, which half of the model it belongs to and what each phase determines. Compiled by reading each source's phase list and aligning them by phase number.

PRECEDE-PROCEED eight phases: labels, the question each answers and the half of the model, compiled from the Community Tool Box and Wikipedia phase lists
PhaseHalf of modelCommunity Tool Box labelWikipedia labelWhat the phase determines
Phase 1PRECEDEDefining the ultimate outcome (social diagnosis)Social diagnosisThe outcome the community wants, from demographic data and community input
Phase 2PRECEDEIdentifying the issue (epidemiological diagnosis)Epidemiological, behavioral, and environmental diagnosisIssues and factors that influence the Phase 1 outcome and that an intervention can change
Phase 3PRECEDEExamining the factors (educational and organizational diagnosis)Educational and ecological diagnosisPredisposing, enabling and reinforcing factors behind the chosen behaviors and conditions
Phase 4PRECEDEIdentifying best practices and policy issues (administrative and policy diagnosis)Administrative and policy diagnosisAdministrative factors and internal and external policies affecting the intervention
Phase 5PROCEEDImplementationImplementationSet up and carry out the intervention
Phase 6PROCEEDProcess evaluationProcess evaluationWhether planned actions are actually being carried out
Phase 7PROCEEDImpact evaluationImpact evaluationWhether the targeted behaviors or environmental factors changed
Phase 8PROCEEDOutcome evaluationOutcome evaluationWhether the Phase 1 community outcome was achieved

Sources

Compiled by CASRAI from the sources above. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution.

Follow CASRAI

Research-administration guidance, standards updates and independent tool reviews.

Ask CASRAI · full access

Ask about The PRECEDE-PROCEED Model: What Each of the 8 Phases Produces, and How It Differs From RE-AIM

Full access: large monthly usage, up to 10 source passages behind each answer, and MCP and API access for Claude Code, Codex and other CLIs. Cancel any time.

An AI assistant for research: funder rules, compliance, methods and publishing. It links the sources behind its answers and labels answers that come from a web search.

Answers draw on CASRAI's guides and dictionary plus the federal and funder documents we index: Federal Register, Grants.gov, Regulations.gov and UKRI.

Works on this site and inside Claude, Cursor and the AI tools you already use.

Everything CASRAI publishes — this page, the dictionary, the guides and the news — stays open to read, with no account and no card.

Referenced across the research world

University of Cambridge logoColumbia University logoCrossref logoUniversity of Edinburgh logoHarvard University logoUniversity of Oxford logoPrinceton University logoStanford School of Medicine logoUniversity College London logoORCID logoUniversity of Cambridge logoColumbia University logoCrossref logoUniversity of Edinburgh logoHarvard University logoUniversity of Oxford logoPrinceton University logoStanford School of Medicine logoUniversity College London logoORCID logo
  • University of Cambridge logo
  • Columbia University logo
  • Crossref logo
  • University of Edinburgh logo
  • Harvard University logo
  • University of Oxford logo
  • Princeton University logo
  • Stanford School of Medicine logo
  • University College London logo
  • ORCID logo

View CASRAI adoption →