Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board
Published · Last updated
On this page
General regulatory information, not medical advice. This page covers the product rules for pacifiers sold in the United States; it does not give advice on using a pacifier with any individual child.
Short answer
In the United States a pacifier must meet 16 CFR Part 1511, the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) rule that sets guard or shield, vent hole, structural, attachment and labeling requirements, and it must also meet separate CPSC rules on lead, phthalates, third-party testing and certification. Part 1511 turns each requirement into a numbered test, so a pacifier either passes the stated pull force, heat cycle and small-parts checks or it does not. Sources checked 2026-10-30.
Definition and scope
CPSC’s business guidance on pacifiers defines a pacifier as “an article that consists of a nipple that is intended for a young child to suck upon”, usually with a guard or shield and a handle or ring. Its stated aim is to prevent choking and suffocation: the guard or shield has to keep the whole pacifier from entering the mouth.
Part 1511 is codified in Title 16 of the Code of Federal Regulations under the Federal Hazardous Substances Act regulations, and was published at 42 FR 33279 (June 30, 1977). Section 1511.1 states its purpose: it sets the requirements by which pacifiers, as defined in section 1511.2(a), are not banned articles under 16 CFR 1500.18(a)(8). In other words, a pacifier that does not meet Part 1511 is a banned article.
How 16 CFR 1511 works in practice
Part 1511 has eight sections: scope (1511.1), definitions (1511.2), guard or shield requirements (1511.3), protrusions (1511.4), structural integrity tests (1511.5), ribbons, strings, cords or other attachments (1511.6), labeling (1511.7) and metric references (1511.8). Two figures accompany the tests: a pacifier test fixture (Figure 1) and a small parts gage (Figure 2). The table maps each section to the test value the regulation states.
16 CFR 1511: section-by-section test values
| Section | Subject | What the regulation states |
|---|---|---|
| 1511.3(a) | Guard or shield, pull test | The pacifier sits in the Figure 1 fixture and the nipple is pulled with a force gradually reaching, but not exceeding, 2.0 lb (8.9 N) within 5 seconds, then held for 10 more seconds. The pacifier fails if the whole pacifier is pulled through the fixture opening. |
| 1511.3(b) | Guard or shield, vent holes | At least two symmetrically located holes, each at least 0.20 in (5 mm) in minor dimension, with the edge of each hole no closer than 0.20 in (5 mm) to the perimeter of the guard or shield. |
| 1511.4 | Protrusions | No protrusion from the face of the guard or shield opposite the nipple may exceed 0.63 in (16 mm) when measured by the section 1511.4(b) procedure, using a plane surface applied with a force not exceeding 2.0 lb (8.9 N). |
| 1511.5(a) | Nipple, tensile test | 10.0 lb (44.5 N) applied gradually within 5 seconds and held for 10 more seconds. |
| 1511.5(b) | Handle or ring, pull test | The same 10.0 lb force. |
| 1511.5(c) | Heat cycling | Boiling water for 5 minutes, then cooling for 5 minutes at 60-80 °F (16-27 °C), six cycles in total. The pull tests in 1511.5(a) and (b) and the guard or shield tests in 1511.3 are then repeated. |
| 1511.5(d) | Small parts | Components or fragments released during testing are placed in the truncated cylinder (small parts gage, Figure 2). The pacifier fails if the uppermost edge of a fragment is below the plane of the top of the cylinder. |
| 1511.6 | Attachments | A pacifier may not be sold or distributed with any ribbon, string, cord, chain, twine, leather, yarn or similar attachment. |
| 1511.7 | Labeling | The statement “Warning-Do Not Tie Pacifier Around Child’s Neck as it Presents a Strangulation Danger.” must appear legibly and conspicuously on any retail display carton holding two or more pacifiers and on each individually packaged pacifier. |
The order matters. The heat cycles are not a separate pass: after six boil-and-cool cycles the pull tests and guard or shield tests are run again, so a pacifier has to pass both before and after heat exposure.
Types and related concepts: what sits outside Part 1511
Part 1511 is only one layer of the CPSC requirements. CPSC’s guidance lists further obligations that apply to pacifiers but are not in Part 1511:
- ASTM F963. Pacifiers must also meet applicable requirements of ASTM F963, including heavy elements (section 4.3.5) and nitrosamines in rubber nipples, which reference ASTM F1313 (section 4.20).
- Lead. Paint and surface coatings may contain no more than 0.009 percent lead, and total lead in any accessible component is capped at 100 ppm (0.01 percent).
- Phthalates. Plasticized components may not exceed 0.1 percent of eight specified phthalates.
- Third-party testing and certification. Testing must be done by an accredited, CPSC-accepted third-party laboratory, and a domestic manufacturer or importer issues a Children’s Product Certificate listing each applicable rule and stating that the product complies.
- Tracking label. The pacifier and its packaging need a permanent tracking label or distinguishing mark showing the source, date of manufacture and batch or run information.
Pacifier clips and similar items are not pacifiers. CPSC says they must meet separate requirements: the Small Parts Regulation (16 CFR 1501), use-and-abuse testing and the CPSIA requirements. CPSC staff recommend clips be “preferably no longer than 7-8 inches in total length”. Because Part 1511.6 bars cords and chains from being sold with a pacifier, a clip is evaluated separately rather than as a pacifier component.
Where it matters for labs, clinics and supply decisions
For anyone who writes product specifications or reviews supplier documentation, the useful move is to keep the layers apart. A Part 1511 test report shows performance against the pull, vent hole, heat cycle and small-parts tests; it does not by itself address lead, phthalates or ASTM F963, and the Children’s Product Certificate is the document CPSC says lists each applicable rule. A certificate of analysis is a different kind of supplier document; the certificate of analysis guide is a useful comparison when you review supplier paperwork. For contrast with the device side, see how UDI labeling and GUDID submission handle device labels, how FDA treats FDA-recognized consensus standards and how ISO/IEC 17025 defines what a testing laboratory’s accreditation covers.
Common misunderstandings
- “Meeting Part 1511 means the pacifier is fully compliant.” It does not. Lead, phthalates, ASTM F963, third-party testing, the certificate and tracking label are separate CPSC requirements.
- “A pacifier clip is part of the pacifier rule.” CPSC treats clips as separate articles under other rules, and 1511.6 prohibits attachments sold with the pacifier.
- “The warning label is optional on loose items.” 1511.7 puts the statement on each individually packaged pacifier and on any retail display carton of two or more.
- “The pull test is one test.” The guard or shield test (2.0 lb) and the structural tests (10.0 lb) use different forces, and they are repeated after the six heat cycles.
FAQ
What does 16 CFR 1511 cover?
It covers pacifiers as defined in section 1511.2(a): guard or shield, vent holes, protrusions, structural integrity, attachments and labeling. A pacifier that meets it is not a banned article under 16 CFR 1500.18(a)(8).
Which federal agency regulates pacifier safety?
The Consumer Product Safety Commission. Part 1511 sits in Title 16, Chapter II, which is the CPSC’s chapter of the CFR.
What warning must appear on pacifier packaging?
Section 1511.7 requires “Warning-Do Not Tie Pacifier Around Child’s Neck as it Presents a Strangulation Danger.” on each individually packaged pacifier and on retail display cartons holding two or more.
Does Part 1511 set limits on lead or phthalates?
No. Those limits come from other CPSC requirements: 0.009 percent lead in paint, 100 ppm total lead in accessible components, and 0.1 percent of eight specified phthalates in plasticized components.
Sources
- CPSC, Pacifiers: business guidance, checked 2026-10-30.
- Legal Information Institute (Cornell), 16 CFR Part 1511, Requirements for Pacifiers (section titles), and the section text at the eCFR, 16 CFR Part 1511, covering sections 1511.1 to 1511.7, checked 2026-10-30.







