Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board
Published
On this page
The acceptance rate for Science Advances is approximately 8.8% to 10%, according to published editorial reports and publisher data from the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS). Of the more than 20,000 manuscripts submitted annually, roughly 84% to 90% are rejected at the initial editorial triage stage without external peer review, while approximately 16% proceed to expert peer review where about 55% are ultimately accepted for publication.
Ask CASRAI · free to tryQuestion about this guide? Ask CASRAI answers with linked sources. 2 free questions a day, no account.
Definition: what is the acceptance rate for Science Advances?
In academic bibliometrics, a journal acceptance rate represents the proportion of submitted manuscripts that survive peer review and editorial screening to achieve formal publication. For Science Advances—the open-access, multidisciplinary flagship founded by the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in 2015—the acceptance rate serves as a key measure of editorial selectivity and manuscript competition.
Understanding this metric requires distinguishing between three related statistical concepts:
- Gross Acceptance Rate: The total number of accepted articles divided by the total number of formal submissions over a defined annual period, expressed as a percentage. At Science Advances, this figure sits between 8.8% and 10%.
- Desk Rejection Rate: The proportion of manuscripts declined by Deputy and Associate Editors during initial triage without being sent to external reviewers. At Science Advances, the desk rejection rate exceeds 84%.
- Post-Review Acceptance Rate: The conditional probability that a manuscript is accepted given that it successfully passed editorial triage and underwent external peer review. At Science Advances, this post-review conversion rate is approximately 55%.
Unlike specialized disciplinary journals that primarily assess technical correctness, Science Advances applies dual criteria: papers must demonstrate flawless experimental and analytical rigor, and they must present an advance of broad conceptual interest across multiple scientific disciplines.
Formula and mathematical breakdown of acceptance metrics
The gross acceptance rate is calculated using a standard ratio of accepted manuscripts to total submissions over a 12-month calendar window. The fundamental formula is expressed as:
R_acc = (N_acc / N_sub) × 100
Where:
- R_acc: The overall journal acceptance rate (expressed as a percentage).
- N_acc: The total count of manuscripts accepted for publication during the measurement window.
- N_sub: The total count of unique, complete manuscripts submitted to the journal during the same window.
Because peer review at high-impact multidisciplinary journals operates in two distinct stages (editorial screening followed by external peer review), the gross acceptance rate can be expanded into a two-stage conditional probability model:
R_acc = P(Triage Pass) × P(Accept | Triage Pass) × 100
In terms of operational journal metrics:
P(Triage Pass) = (1 – R_desk) = (N_rev / N_sub)
P(Accept | Triage Pass) = (N_acc / N_rev)
Where:
- R_desk: The desk rejection rate (proportion of submissions rejected without external review).
- N_rev: The number of manuscripts assigned to external peer reviewers.
- P(Accept | Triage Pass): The acceptance probability for papers that clear initial triage.
This compound formulation demonstrates why increasing external review rigor only marginally alters the overall acceptance rate if the initial triage threshold is set high. For authors, the primary barrier to publication in Science Advances is not reviewer skepticism, but the initial editorial filter.
Worked example with real editorial submission numbers
To see how these formulas function in practice, we can apply audited metrics published by the journal’s editorial leadership. In an official editorial published in Science Advances (DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.add9147), Senior Deputy Editor Warren S. Warren disclosed that the journal receives approximately 20,000 submissions annually and declines roughly 90% of them, predominantly without external review.
Consider an operational annual cohort of 20,000 manuscripts submitted to Science Advances:
- Step 1: Calculate manuscripts sent for external review. Editorial reports indicate that approximately 16% of total submissions clear desk evaluation. Therefore: 20,000 × 0.16 = 3,200 manuscripts sent to peer review (N_rev = 3,200).
- Step 2: Calculate desk rejections. The remaining 84% of submissions are declined during initial triage: 20,000 – 3,200 = 16,800 desk-rejected manuscripts (R_desk = 84.0%).
- Step 3: Calculate post-review acceptances. Of the 3,200 manuscripts evaluated by external peer reviewers, approximately 55% survive revisions and earn an acceptance decision: 3,200 × 0.55 = 1,760 accepted manuscripts (N_acc = 1,760).
- Step 4: Compute the gross acceptance rate. Applying the primary acceptance rate formula: R_acc = (1,760 / 20,000) × 100 = 8.8%.
If editorial selectivity tightens or submission volume spikes while publication capacity remains capped at 2,000 articles, the acceptance rate adjusts accordingly: R_acc = (2,000 / 20,000) × 100 = 10.0%. Thus, verified editorial figures confirm that an author’s baseline mathematical probability of acceptance upon submission sits firmly between 8.8% and 10.0%.
How Science Advances editors evaluate manuscripts
The evaluation architecture at Science Advances differs substantially from both commercial publishing platforms and sibling titles. While journals like Nature Communications employ full-time, in-house professional editors, the Science Advances editorial board model relies entirely on active research scientists working across academic institutions worldwide.
The manuscript evaluation pathway follows a four-step triage and review sequence:
- Administrative Ingestion: Submissions enter through the AAAS Content Tracking System (CTS). Staff verify compliance with disclosure standards, competing interest policies, data availability statements, and author contribution statements.
- Deputy Editor Triage: Manuscripts are routed to one of dozens of Deputy Editors (DEs) organized across broad domain groups, such as Physical and Material Sciences, Life and Biological Sciences, Environmental and Earth Sciences, and Social and Behavioral Sciences. Individual Deputy Editors handle between 50 and 100 manuscripts per month. The Deputy Editor evaluates whether the manuscript offers a conceptual leap of interest to non-specialists. If the work is deemed incremental or overly specialized, the Deputy Editor issues a rapid desk rejection.
- Associate Editor Assignment: If a manuscript shows potential broad impact, the Deputy Editor assigns it to one of more than 70 Associate Editors (AEs) within the relevant disciplinary section. The Associate Editor selects independent, expert peer reviewers, ensuring that candidates have no institutional or collaborative conflicts of interest.
- Peer Review and Final Consensus: Most reviewed manuscripts receive reports from two or three independent referees. Reviewers evaluate technical execution, mathematical correctness, statistical validity, and reproducibility. The handling Associate Editor synthesizes the reports and formulates a recommendation, which is reviewed and confirmed by the Deputy Editor before a formal decision letter is dispatched to the corresponding author.
Submission timelines: time to decision and publication
Understanding editorial turnaround benchmarks helps research groups manage project deadlines, grant reporting schedules, and postdoctoral career milestones. According to publisher disclosures and indexing registries including the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ), submission timelines at Science Advances follow these medians:
- Median Time to First Decision (Desk Triage): 8 days (approximately 1.1 weeks). Manuscripts that do not meet the journal’s cross-disciplinary significance threshold are returned to authors swiftly, allowing rapid resubmission to specialized disciplinary outlets without months of lost momentum.
- Median Time to First Decision Post-Review: 58 days (approximately 8.3 weeks). For manuscripts that pass initial screening and enter external peer review, securing reviewer commitments and synthesizing detailed technical assessments typically requires under two months.
- Median Time to Final Acceptance: 170 days (approximately 5.6 months). This duration encompasses initial review, author revisions, re-evaluation by referees, and final editorial approval.
- Total Time from Submission to Online Publication: 33 weeks (approximately 7.6 months or 231 days). Once formally accepted, production workflows including copyediting, figure standardization, author proofs, and XML/PDF layout require approximately 4 to 6 weeks.
Article processing charges (APC) and open-access funding
Science Advances operates as a pure Gold Open Access journal. All published articles are immediately accessible worldwide upon release. To cover the operational costs of peer review administration, professional copyediting, electronic hosting, and long-term digital preservation, the publisher levies article processing charges (APCs) upon acceptance.
Key financial details governing publication in Science Advances include:
- Standard APC Amount: 5,450 USD. This fee applies across all standard research articles, reviews, and multidisciplinary communications published under Creative Commons licensing.
- Licensing Options: Authors may publish under either a Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license or a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial (CC BY-NC) license. Funder mandates such as Plan S, NIH public access requirements, and Horizon Europe guidelines frequently require the CC BY option.
- Institutional Transformative Agreements: AAAS maintains institutional agreements with hundreds of universities, research councils, and library consortia worldwide. Authors affiliated with qualifying institutions often have their APCs paid in full or discounted automatically upon manuscript acceptance.
- Member Discounts: Individual AAAS members in good standing are eligible for modest author discounts (typically 4% off the standard rate).
- Hardship Waivers: AAAS provides full or partial APC waivers for corresponding authors based in low- and lower-middle-income economies, adhering to Research4Life eligibility criteria. Inability to pay an APC has no bearing on editorial decisions, as editors and reviewers operate independently of billing workflows.
Interpretation: what the acceptance rate means for authors
Evaluating an acceptance rate between 8.8% and 10% requires contextual interpretation. In bibliometric rankings, Science Advances occupies a tier of broad-interest multidisciplinary journals alongside Nature Communications and PNAS. How authors should interpret these selectivity numbers depends on their submission strategy:
The compiled data table below summarizes editorial benchmarks, acceptance rates, turnaround timelines, and publication costs across major multidisciplinary research journals.
| Metric Indicator | Science Advances | Practical Meaning for Authors |
|---|---|---|
| Gross Acceptance Rate | 8.8% – 10.0% | Nine out of ten submitted manuscripts will be declined; competitive positioning requires broad conceptual impact. |
| Desk Rejection Proportion | 84.0% – 90.0% | The vast majority of rejections occur within 10 days without peer review; the abstract and cover letter are critical filters. |
| Review-to-Accept Conversion | ~55.0% | Once a paper enters external peer review, the probability of eventual publication rises above one in two. |
| Journal Impact Factor (JIF) | 13.9 (5-yr: 14.8) | High citation frequency confirms broad disciplinary readership; comparable to peer general-science outlets. |
| Open Access Fee (APC) | 5,450 USD | Authors must secure institutional OA funding or grant allocation prior to final acceptance. |
When choosing where to submit, authors should compare the Science Advances acceptance profile against the Nature acceptance rate (approximately 8%, with an in-house editor model) and the Science Advances journal impact factor (13.9 in the Clarivate JCR June 2026 release). While the flagship journal Science accepts only 6% to 7% of papers, Science Advances offers an outlet for high-impact discoveries that may be slightly more specialized than Science but possess broader general significance than field-specific journals.
Common mistakes that trigger desk rejection
Because more than eight out of ten manuscripts are declined during initial triage, understanding why Deputy Editors reject papers without review is vital for prospective authors. In his published editorial on manuscript triage, Senior Deputy Editor Warren S. Warren highlighted the most frequent strategic errors committed by submitting authors:
- Jargon-Heavy or Exaggerated Framing: Using obscure terminology, dense acronyms, or sensational adjectives in the title and abstract alienates editors. Deputy Editors are research scientists, but they rarely specialize in the exact sub-field of every paper they handle. Titles and abstracts must clearly explain what was discovered and why it matters to an educated non-specialist.
- Cosmetic Resubmission: Resubmitting a rejected paper with only minor phrasing alterations without addressing previous critique guarantees another rejection. The editorial office tracks submission histories across all AAAS journals.
- Failing to Contextualize Prior Literature: Minimizing or failing to cite prominent recent work in the field irritates editors and invited reviewers. Editors expect authors to position their discovery objectively within the existing research landscape.
- Inscrutable Figures and Poor Visual Architecture: Editors often examine figures and captions immediately after the abstract. Illegible font sizes, chaotic multi-panel layouts, poorly labeled axes, or captions separated from graphics make it difficult for editors to grasp the core finding quickly.
- Neglecting Prior Review History During Cascading: When a paper is transferred from Science via cascading peer review or resubmitted after rejection at another publisher, failing to show how reviewer criticisms were systematically resolved is a major red flag. If prior reviews are included, authors should provide a detailed point-by-point rebuttal showing substantive revisions.
- Unrealistic Editor or Reviewer Suggestions: Suggesting Associate Editors whose published expertise does not match the manuscript topic delays handling. Furthermore, nominating reviewers who have recent co-authorships, institutional ties, or clear conflicts of interest compromises editorial neutrality and undermines author credibility.
How to report journal acceptance rates in academic dossiers
Researchers frequently need to document journal selectivity in tenure dossiers, promotion reviews, fellowship applications, and institutional bibliometric reports. When citing acceptance metrics, authors must present verified figures responsibly, adhering to professional standards such as the San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment (DORA).
Best practices for reporting journal selectivity in professional dossiers include:
- Attribute the Source Explicitly: Never cite unverified blog estimates. Cite official publisher reports, audited indexing databases, or published editorial disclosures. For Science Advances, cite the formal editorial disclosure: Warren, W. S. (2022). Beating the odds for journal acceptance. Science Advances, 8(30), eadd9147. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.add9147
- Provide Contextual Denominators: State the estimated submission volume alongside the acceptance percentage (e.g., “Accepted in Science Advances, a multidisciplinary open-access journal published by AAAS with an estimated acceptance rate of 8.8% to 10% across more than 20,000 annual submissions”).
- Balance Acceptance Rates with Article-Level Metrics: Journal-level acceptance percentages reflect competitive selectivity at the point of submission, but they do not measure the scientific merit or citation impact of an individual paper. Complement journal acceptance data with article-level metrics such as normalized citation counts, Altmetric attention scores, and dataset reuse statistics.
How to calculate acceptance rates in Excel, R, and Python
Institutional researchers, bibliometricians, and research office administrators frequently calculate manuscript acceptance metrics from tracking logs. The following code snippets demonstrate how to compute gross acceptance rates, desk rejection rates, and post-review conversion rates across spreadsheet and computational environments.
Calculating acceptance metrics in Excel
Assuming a spreadsheet where Column A lists Manuscript IDs, Column B records Triage Status (Triage_Reject or Triage_Pass), and Column C records Final Decision (Accepted or Rejected):
Total Submissions:
=COUNTA(A2:A20001)
Desk Rejection Rate (%):
=COUNTIF(B2:B20001, "Triage_Reject") / COUNTA(A2:A20001) * 100
Post-Review Acceptance Rate (%):
=COUNTIF(C2:C20001, "Accepted") / COUNTIF(B2:B20001, "Triage_Pass") * 100
Gross Acceptance Rate (%):
=COUNTIF(C2:C20001, "Accepted") / COUNTA(A2:A20001) * 100
Calculating acceptance metrics in R
The following R script defines a reproducible function to compute all three publishing rates from raw submission counts:
calculate_acceptance_metrics = function(submissions, desk_rejects, accepted) {
sent_to_review = submissions - desk_rejects
gross_rate = (accepted / submissions) * 100
desk_rate = (desk_rejects / submissions) * 100
review_accept_rate = (accepted / sent_to_review) * 100
data.frame(
Total_Submissions = submissions,
Desk_Rejection_Rate_Pct = round(desk_rate, 2),
Sent_To_Review_Pct = round((sent_to_review / submissions) * 100, 2),
Post_Review_Accept_Pct = round(review_accept_rate, 2),
Gross_Acceptance_Rate_Pct = round(gross_rate, 2)
)
}
# Example run using Science Advances editorial cohort:
results = calculate_acceptance_metrics(submissions = 20000, desk_rejects = 16800, accepted = 1760)
print(results)
Calculating acceptance metrics in Python
The following Python snippet implements robust rate calculation:
def compute_journal_rates(total_submissions, desk_rejections, final_acceptances):
reviewed_count = total_submissions - desk_rejections
gross_rate = (final_acceptances / total_submissions) * 100.0
desk_rate = (desk_rejections / total_submissions) * 100.0
post_review_rate = (final_acceptances / reviewed_count) * 100.0
return {
"submissions": total_submissions,
"desk_rejection_rate": round(desk_rate, 2),
"external_review_rate": round((reviewed_count / total_submissions) * 100.0, 2),
"post_review_acceptance_rate": round(post_review_rate, 2),
"gross_acceptance_rate": round(gross_rate, 2),
}
# Execution with Science Advances baseline parameters:
metrics = compute_journal_rates(20000, 16800, 1760)
for key, value in metrics.items():
print(f"{key}: {value}")
Frequently asked questions
What is the current acceptance rate for Science Advances?
The overall acceptance rate for Science Advances is between 8.8% and 10%. Out of more than 20,000 papers submitted annually to the journal, roughly 1,760 to 2,000 are ultimately published.
What percentage of papers are desk-rejected at Science Advances?
Approximately 84% to 90% of submitted manuscripts are desk-rejected during initial triage by Deputy and Associate Editors without being sent out for external peer review. Only about 16% of total submissions clear this stage to reach external referees.
How long does Science Advances take to make a first decision?
The median time to a first decision for desk-rejected manuscripts is 8 days. For papers sent out for external peer review, the median time to receive a first decision is 58 days, and the median overall time from submission to final acceptance is 170 days.
How much is the APC for Science Advances?
The article processing charge (APC) for Science Advances is 5,450 USD for standard research articles published under CC BY or CC BY-NC licenses. Discounts apply for institutional transformative agreements and AAAS members, and full waivers are available for eligible authors from developing countries.
Is Science Advances harder to get into than Nature Communications or PNAS?
Science Advances has an acceptance rate of 8.8% to 10%, which is very comparable to Nature Communications (approximately 8%) and more selective than PNAS (approximately 15%). However, because Science Advances uses active academic researchers as editors rather than professional editorial staff, evaluation emphasizes broad scientific impact and community interest over purely algorithmic editorial filters.
Can you transfer a rejected paper from Science to Science Advances?
Yes. Authors whose papers are declined at Science are frequently offered the option to transfer their manuscript and referee reports directly to Science Advances via cascading peer review. However, transferred papers are not guaranteed acceptance; handling Deputy Editors independently evaluate whether the work satisfies the journal’s multidisciplinary advance criteria.
Sources
- Warren, W. S. (2022). Beating the odds for journal acceptance. Science Advances, 8(30), eadd9147. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.add9147 (Accessed: 2026-11-16)
- Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ). (2026). Science Advances journal indexing and publishing metrics. https://doaj.org/toc/2375-2548 (Accessed: 2026-11-16)
- American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS). (2026). Science Advances: Information for Authors, Licensing, and Charges. https://www.science.org/content/page/science-advances-licensing-and-charges (Accessed: 2026-11-16)
- American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS). (2026). Science Journals Editorial Policies and Peer Review Standards. https://www.science.org/content/page/science-information-authors (Accessed: 2026-11-16)
- Nature Portfolio. (2026). Nature Editorial Criteria, Processes, and Turnaround Timelines. https://www.nature.com/nature/for-authors/editorial-criteria-and-processes (Accessed: 2026-11-16)
- National Academy of Sciences. (2026). PNAS Submitting Your Manuscript, Review Workflow, and Fees. https://www.pnas.org/author-center/submitting-your-manuscript (Accessed: 2026-11-16)
- Clarivate. (2026). Journal Citation Reports (JCR): Science Advances Citation Metrics and JIF 13.9. https://clarivate.com/products/scientific-and-academic-research/research-discovery-and-workflow-solutions/journal-citation-reports/ (Accessed: 2026-11-16)
Data: Multidisciplinary Open-Access and High-Impact Journal Acceptance Metrics
Cross-journal comparison of manuscript acceptance rates, desk rejection rates, editorial turnaround times, and article processing charges across premier multidisciplinary research journals, compiled from publisher editorial reports, DOAJ records, and author policy disclosures.
Period covered: 2022-2026. Coverage: Global.
| Journal | Acceptance Rate (%) | Desk Rejection Rate (%) | Median First Decision (days) | Median Time to Acceptance (days) | Article Processing Charge (USD) | Editorial Model |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Science Advances | 8.8 | 84 | 8 | 170 | 5450 | Active Academic Editors (Deputy and Associate Editors) |
| Nature Communications | 8 | 80 | 10 | 185 | 6790 | Full-Time Professional In-House Editors |
| PNAS | 15 | 75 | 14 | 135 | 5400 | Active Academic NAS Members and Guest Editors |
| PLOS ONE | 48 | 20 | 45 | 140 | 2500 | Active Academic Section and Academic Editors |
| Scientific Reports | 55 | 25 | 35 | 125 | 2690 | Active Academic Editorial Board Members |
| Nature (Flagship) | 8 | 82 | 8 | 195 | 11690 | Full-Time Professional In-House Editors |
Sources
- Science Advances Editorial Report & DOAJ Journal Record (accessed 2026-11-16)
- Beating the Odds for Journal Acceptance (Science Advances Editorial) (accessed 2026-11-16)
- AAAS Science Advances Licensing and Charges (accessed 2026-11-16)
- Nature Editorial Metrics & Open Access APC Schedule (accessed 2026-11-16)
- PNAS Submissions and Open Access Publishing Fees (accessed 2026-11-16)
Compiled by CASRAI from the sources above. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution.







