Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board
Published
On this page
The Science Advances editor system is a multi-tiered academic governance framework published by the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS), in which active practicing researchers—rather than in-house professional staff—direct manuscript triage, referee recruitment, and publication decisions. Under this model, overarching scientific direction is guided by Section Editors across five primary disciplinary fields, initial desk evaluations and cross-disciplinary scope screens are executed by Deputy Editors, and the day-to-day management of external peer review is conducted by hundreds of field-specific Associate Editors located at academic institutions worldwide.
Ask CASRAI · free to tryQuestion about this guide? Ask CASRAI answers with linked sources. 2 free questions a day, no account.
What is the Science Advances editorial board model?
The operational philosophy of Science Advances distinguishes it sharply from both commercial subscription journals and sister publications within the AAAS publishing portfolio. Established in 2015 as the premier open-access, multidisciplinary vehicle of the AAAS, the journal operates under the executive oversight of Editor-in-Chief H. Holden Thorp, who leads the entire Science family of journals, and Managing Editor Laura Remis, who directs operational logistics, publishing integrity, and workflow adherence. However, unlike the weekly flagship journal Science—which employs professional, full-time staff editors to handle manuscript triage and peer-review management—Science Advances delegates all scholarly judgment directly to an international academic editorial board composed of working faculty members and active research scientists.
This academic editor structure ensures that every submission is evaluated by researchers who remain active in laboratory investigations, grant writing, and academic teaching. Because active investigators are deeply immersed in current methodological standards and emergent scientific debates, they possess intimate familiarity with experimental complexities that full-time administrative editors might overlook. At the same time, this framework requires stringent protocols to preserve editorial independence and manage potential conflicts of interest. When handling editors receive a submission from a recent collaborator, departmental colleague, or institutional competitor, AAAS recusal rules mandate that the paper be reassigned to an impartial peer across the global editorial network.
The editorial board is structured into three distinct administrative and evaluative tiers:
- Section Editors: Senior scientific leaders who oversee five core disciplinary domains, maintain overarching editorial standards, monitor volume and citation metrics, and adjudicate complex ethical disputes or split editorial appeals.
- Deputy Editors: Experienced full professors and principal investigators who act as the primary operational gatekeepers. Deputy Editors conduct initial scope screenings on incoming manuscripts, decide whether a submission warrants external review or rapid desk rejection, and deliver final publication decisions based on Associate Editor recommendations.
- Associate Editors: Hundreds of specialized researchers organized across sub-disciplines who manage the day-to-day mechanics of peer review. Associate Editors recruit expert referees, evaluate reviewer commentaries, synthesize conflicting technical feedback, and formulate formal recommendations to the Deputy Editor.
Who runs Science Advances and what does it cover?
The governance of Science Advances is anchored by the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS), the world’s largest multidisciplinary scientific society. Founded in 1848, the AAAS launched Science Advances to provide an open-access home for high-impact, sound scientific research that meets the rigorous standards of the Science family but cannot fit within the strict page constraints of the print weekly flagship journal. The journal operates under an open-access model indexed in the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ), publishing under Creative Commons attribution licenses (CC BY or CC BY-NC) with an Article Processing Charge (APC) of approximately $5,450 for published research papers.
To oversee its diverse multidisciplinary intake, the editorial leadership divides the scientific universe into five broad disciplinary sections, each directed by an appointed Section Editor:
- Biomedical and Life Sciences: Overseen by Section Editor Craig Cameron, covering molecular biology, genetics, immunology, pharmacology, virology, physiology, and evolutionary biology.
- Physical and Materials Sciences: Overseen by Section Editor Ilya Kuprov, encompassing physics, inorganic and organic chemistry, materials engineering, nanotechnology, and chemical physics.
- Earth, Environmental, Ecological, and Space Sciences: Overseen by Section Editor Douglas Erwin, covering paleontology, climate science, planetary geology, atmospheric sciences, oceanography, and conservation ecology.
- Neuroscience: Overseen by Section Editor Tali Sharot, spanning cognitive neuroscience, cellular neurobiology, behavioral psychology, neural circuitry, and neurodegenerative disease mechanisms.
- Social and Interdisciplinary Science: Overseen by Section Editor Jennifer Earl, encompassing computational social science, economics, sociology, public policy, anthropology, and cross-cutting interdisciplinary studies.
The journal considers research papers across all five sections, with an emphasis on groundbreaking investigations, paradigm shifts, and cross-cutting interdisciplinary studies. Editorial volume at Science Advances has expanded significantly since its founding, processing thousands of submissions each year while maintaining a highly selective acceptance rate estimated between 8% and 10%. This high selectivity means that the vast majority of submitted manuscripts are declined during the initial Deputy Editor desk screen, before external peer review is initiated.
How to navigate the Science Advances editor-handling workflow
Submitting a manuscript to Science Advances requires navigating the AAAS Central Tracking System (CTS). Understanding how a submission transitions between handling editors allows authors to interpret portal statuses accurately and anticipate editorial requirements. The six distinct stages of the editor-handling workflow proceed as follows:
Step 1: Portal submission and editorial routing selection
Authors begin by accessing the AAAS submission portal through the journal sign-in page. During submission, the corresponding author enters complete metadata, uploads manuscript files and supplementary materials, and selects the primary disciplinary section (such as Physical Sciences or Neuroscience) and specific subcategory. Authors are invited to suggest preferred Deputy Editors or Associate Editors whose expertise aligns with the manuscript, as well as identify non-preferred reviewers or editors due to direct institutional or competitive conflicts.
Step 2: The “Under Evaluation” status and Deputy Editor desk screening
Once initial administrative validation is completed by AAAS editorial staff, the manuscript is assigned to a designated Deputy Editor. In the author tracking portal, this phase is marked with the status Under Evaluation. The Deputy Editor evaluates whether the study possesses sufficient novelty, methodological rigor, and broad multidisciplinary significance to appeal to researchers outside its immediate sub-discipline. Manuscripts that fail to demonstrate cross-disciplinary interest or present incremental findings are promptly desk-rejected at this stage, typically within one to two weeks, preserving external reviewer resources.
Step 3: Associate Editor delegation and specialized evaluation
If the Deputy Editor determines that the manuscript satisfies the journal’s threshold for novelty and scope, the paper is delegated to an Associate Editor possessing specific domain expertise in the research topic. The Associate Editor examines the experimental framework, statistical power calculations, and data availability declarations. If the Associate Editor confirms that the paper is technically ready for formal evaluation, they initiate the referee identification process.
Step 4: External referee recruitment and the “Reviewer Invited” cycle
The Associate Editor selects and invites a minimum of two to four independent peer reviewers. In the author portal, authors may notice the status cycling repeatedly through Reviewer Invited. This reflects the practical difficulty of securing referee acceptances from specialized faculty members and does not signify an adverse judgment on the paper. Once the required number of referees agree to critique the submission, the tracking status advances to In Review or Under Review under a single-anonymized peer review model, where reviewers know the authors’ identities but referee reports remain anonymous.
Step 5: Synthesizing reviewer reports and drafting editorial recommendations
When all requested reviewer evaluations are returned, the status changes to indicate that reviews are complete. The Associate Editor reads each critique, evaluates methodological disputes, and synthesizes the recommendations. Rather than tallying reviewer votes, the Associate Editor weighs the intellectual merit of each critique and prepares a detailed synthesis letter to the Deputy Editor, recommending acceptance, revision (minor or major), or rejection.
Step 6: Deputy Editor final determination and revision compliance
The Deputy Editor reviews the Associate Editor’s synthesis and referee reports to issue the formal editorial decision. If revisions are invited, authors must submit a detailed point-by-point rebuttal alongside tracked changes. AAAS policies enforce strict reproducibility mandates: authors must confirm that all raw data, analysis code, and physical materials are deposited in publicly accessible, compliant repositories before a final unconditional acceptance can be rendered.
Editorial models compared: Science Advances vs. PNAS and Nature Communications
Researchers submitting multidisciplinary findings frequently weigh Science Advances against its primary competitors: the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) and Nature Communications. While all three venues publish high-impact, cross-disciplinary science, their editorial handling mechanisms, decision-making bodies, and author pathways differ significantly.
The most prominent institutional contrast occurs between Science Advances and PNAS. Historically, PNAS operated multiple submission pathways, including communicated papers and prearranged editor options. While many historical pathways have been retired, PNAS still maintains a distinct dual-track structure: Direct Submissions and Member-Contributed submissions. In the Member-Contributed track, an elected member of the U.S. National Academy of Sciences (NAS) can contribute up to two of their own research papers per year, overseeing aspects of the referee selection process. In contrast, Science Advances maintains no member privilege track. Every manuscript—whether authored by a Nobel laureate, an AAAS Fellow, or an early-career postdoctoral fellow—enters the identical centralized workflow and undergoes identical screening by Deputy and Associate Editors.
A second major structural contrast exists between Science Advances and Nature Communications. Published by Springer Nature, Nature Communications relies entirely on full-time, in-house professional editors with doctoral backgrounds. These professional editors do not run academic laboratories; their sole professional role is manuscript triage, reviewer coordination, and editorial adjudication. In contrast, Science Advances utilizes active university faculty members. While academic editors offer unparalleled technical familiarity with active bench practices, full-time professional editors can often provide more rapid administrative turnaround because their time is not divided among university teaching, institutional committee obligations, and active laboratory research.
Furthermore, Science Advances participates actively in cascading peer review across the AAAS family. When a paper is reviewed at Science, Science Translational Medicine, or Science Immunology and found technically exemplary but constrained by print space, the authors can transfer the manuscript and its associated referee reports directly to Science Advances. This transfer mechanism eliminates redundant referee rounds and significantly accelerates publication turnaround. In all cases, authors must satisfy rigorous author contribution disclosure requirements across co-authors, ensuring transparent accountability for all experimental findings.
Strengths and limitations of the academic editor system
The academic handling editor system at Science Advances offers substantive advantages for scholarly communication alongside specific operational trade-offs that authors must manage:
Key strengths
- Deep technical fluency: Because handling editors are active laboratory directors and publishing scholars, they immediately comprehend nuanced experimental designs, control requirements, and cutting-edge analytical tools.
- Protection against superficial desk rejection: Academic editors are well-equipped to appreciate the fundamental technical merit of complex papers that might appear overly specialized to generalist administrative staff.
- High community trust: Peer-driven decision-making reinforces scientific legitimacy, as authors recognize that their research is evaluated by respected colleagues subject to the same professional challenges.
- Constructive editorial guidance: Associate Editors frequently provide nuanced synthesis letters that arbitrate conflicting referee demands, sparing authors from having to satisfy contradictory reviewer requests.
Operational limitations and bottlenecks
- Turnaround variability: Because Deputy and Associate Editors balance editorial duties with academic teaching semesters, grant submission deadlines, and conference schedules, turnaround times can fluctuate widely across different editorial sections.
- The reviewer recruitment plateau: Securing qualified peer reviewers has become increasingly difficult across academic publishing. The repeated cycling of the Reviewer Invited status can prolong the evaluation window by several weeks.
- Sub-disciplinary conservatism: Occasionally, active researchers in highly contentious sub-fields may exhibit theoretical biases toward established paradigms, necessitating formal author appeals or recusal requests.
Alternatives to Science Advances for multidisciplinary research
When selecting a target journal for multidisciplinary or broad-impact research, authors should evaluate alternatives based on editorial staffing, review models, access tiers, and processing charges. The comparative table below outlines the primary alternative venues for broad-interest scientific studies.
The interactive data table below summarizes key governance metrics, fee structures, and handling tiers across these journals.
| Journal | Editorial Decision Maker | Primary Review Format | Scope Focus | Primary Advantage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Science Advances | Active academic faculty (Deputy and Associate Editors) | Single-anonymized peer review | Broad multidisciplinary science, cross-cutting discoveries | AAAS prestige, high community trust, AAAS cascading track |
| PNAS | Academic Editorial Board and NAS Members | Single-anonymized peer review (Direct and Contributed tracks) | Broad biological, physical, and social sciences | National Academy recognition, mandatory non-specialist significance statements |
| Nature Communications | Full-time in-house professional PhD editors | Single-anonymized or optional double-anonymized review | Multidisciplinary natural and applied sciences | Dedicated editorial managers, predictable turnaround, Nature portfolio transfer |
| Cell Reports | Full-time in-house professional PhD editors | Single-anonymized peer review | Broad biological and biomedical sciences | Rapid editorial triage, strong molecular and mechanistic focus |
| eLife | Active academic Senior and Reviewing Editors | Public reviewed preprints with consultative peer review | Life and biomedical sciences | Consultative review, eliminate accept/reject binary via public assessments |
Frequently asked questions
Who makes the final decision on a manuscript at Science Advances?
The final publication decision (accept, revise, or decline) is made by the assigned Deputy Editor in consultation with the Associate Editor. While the Associate Editor manages the peer-review process and provides a detailed synthesis recommendation, the Deputy Editor formally authorizes the decision letter issued to the authors.
Does Science Advances have a member-contributed track like PNAS?
No. Science Advances does not operate any member-contributed, communicated, or privileged submission pathways. All manuscripts submitted to the journal undergo identical editorial triage and evaluation by academic handling editors regardless of author stature, institutional affiliation, or society membership.
How does the cascading transfer from Science to Science Advances work?
When a paper submitted to Science receives positive peer-review evaluations but is declined due to print page limitations, the authors are offered a transfer to Science Advances. If accepted by the authors, the manuscript files, reviewer identities, and referee evaluations are securely cascaded to a Science Advances Deputy Editor, frequently allowing a decision without commissioning a new round of peer reviewers.
What does the “Under Evaluation” status mean in the submission portal?
The Under Evaluation status indicates that the manuscript is actively undergoing desk screening by an assigned Deputy Editor or is being vetted by an Associate Editor prior to external peer review. This stage determines whether the manuscript demonstrates sufficient novelty and broad multidisciplinary appeal to justify external evaluation.
Can authors suggest or exclude specific editors and reviewers?
Yes. Authors may nominate preferred Deputy Editors and Associate Editors within their subject discipline during portal submission, as well as suggest appropriate peer reviewers. Authors may also request the exclusion of specific individuals due to direct competitive conflicts or prior professional disputes, and AAAS editorial staff generally honor reasonable exclusion requests.
What are the primary reasons manuscripts are desk-rejected by Deputy Editors?
The most common reasons for desk rejection at Science Advances include lack of broad multidisciplinary significance, incremental advances over existing literature, specialized findings better suited to field-specific journals, and insufficient experimental or statistical rigor. Deputy Editors filter out approximately 80% to 90% of total submissions before peer review to protect reviewer bandwidth.
Sources
- American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS), Science Advances Editorial Board and Publishing Model, https://www.science.org/journal/sciadv, accessed 2026-11-14.
- National Academy of Sciences, PNAS Author Center: Submitting Your Manuscript and Editorial Tracks, https://www.pnas.org/author-center/submitting-your-manuscript, accessed 2026-11-14.
- Springer Nature, Nature Communications Editorial Policies and Editorial Structure, https://www.nature.com/ncomms/editorial-policies, accessed 2026-11-14.
- Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ), Science Advances Journal Record and Open Access License Details, https://doaj.org/toc/2375-2548, accessed 2026-11-14.
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), Guidelines on Good Practice for Journal Editors and Editorial Board Management, https://publicationethics.org/guidance/Guidelines, accessed 2026-11-14.
Data: Multidisciplinary Journal Editorial Governance and Workflow Metrics
A comparative dataset evaluating editorial leadership models, reviewer handling tiers, cascading policies, and publication parameters across five leading multidisciplinary science journals, compiled from publisher editorial guidelines and indexing records.
| Journal | Governing Publisher | Editorial Leadership Model | Member Privilege Track | Cascading Transfer Supported | Open Access Article Processing Charge (USD) | Estimated Acceptance Rate (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Science Advances | American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) | Active Academic Deputy and Associate Editors | None (Centralized Academic Review) | Yes (from Science family journals) | 5450 | 9 |
| PNAS (Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences) | National Academy of Sciences (NAS) | Academic Editorial Board and NAS Members | Yes (NAS Member Contributed Track) | No (Independent Direct and Contributed Tracks) | 5400 | 14 |
| Nature Communications | Springer Nature | In-House Full-Time Professional Editors | None (Staff Editor Triage) | Yes (from Nature portfolio journals) | 6790 | 8 |
| Cell Reports | Cell Press / Elsevier | In-House Full-Time Professional Editors | None (Staff Editor Triage) | Yes (from Cell Press portfolio) | 5900 | 10 |
| eLife | eLife Sciences Publications | Active Academic Senior and Reviewing Editors | None (Consultative Academic Review) | Yes (Transfer from bioRxiv and medRxiv) | 2500 | 30 |
Sources
- Science Advances Editorial Information and Publishing Model (accessed 2026-11-14)
- PNAS Author Center: Editorial Tracks and Manuscript Submissions (accessed 2026-11-14)
- Nature Communications Editorial Policies and Editorial Staff (accessed 2026-11-14)
- DOAJ Directory of Open Access Journals: Science Advances (accessed 2026-11-14)
Compiled by CASRAI from the sources above. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution.







