On November 9, 2026, artificial intelligence researchers at Amazon introduced HOPE (Higher-Order Pruning of Experts), a training-free model compression technique designed to cut the memory footprint of Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) language models by up to 50 percent without dismantling the cooperative activation clusters that modern neural architectures rely on for multi-step reasoning.
Why MoE Memory Footprints Challenge Academic Research Computing
Over the past two years, Mixture-of-Experts architectures have emerged as the primary design pattern for scaling open-weight foundation models to hundreds of billions of parameters. In typical dense architectures, every parameter in every feed-forward network activates for every input token. In contrast, MoE architectures replace dense feed-forward blocks with an ensemble of specialized sub-networks, known as expert multi-layer perceptrons (MLPs), routing each token to a small subset through a learned gating network.
While this routing mechanism maintains sparse computational requirements per token, it introduces a severe hardware bottleneck: every single expert MLP must remain resident in GPU high-bandwidth memory (VRAM) throughout inference. In models such as Qwen3.5-122B, which houses 256 individual experts across each of its 48 MoE layers, expert MLPs account for approximately 95 percent of the model’s 250-gigabyte parameter footprint, even though only 8 experts are actively engaged during any single forward pass. For university research computing centers and departmental artificial intelligence laboratories, hosting these models demands multi-GPU nodes with 320 to 640 gigabytes of VRAM—such as clustered NVIDIA A100 or H100 accelerators—straining institutional budgets and limiting exploratory academic evaluation.
Dynamic host-to-device offloading strategies mitigate memory pressure but introduce steep PCIe and interconnect latency penalties that render high-throughput generation impractical. Model quantization compresses individual weight matrices but preserves full parameter counts. By contrast, expert pruning removes unneeded sub-networks entirely, permanently reducing memory requirements while maintaining native execution speed.
The Architectural Flaw of First-Order Expert Pruning
Prior expert pruning methodologies—including Router-weighted Expert Activation Pruning (REAP), Mean Activation Norm (MAN), Expert Activation Norm (EAN), and frequency-based pruning—evaluate expert utility as an isolated, scalar metric. Under these first-order approaches, a calibration dataset is passed through the model to record individual expert activation frequencies or average output norms. Experts are then sorted in ascending order of their individual scores, and the lowest-scoring experts in each layer are excised independently.
The central premise of the Amazon study is that first-order scoring fundamentally misrepresents how MoE layers function in practice. In production foundation models, routing decisions do not treat experts as independent computational silos. Instead, gating networks consistently co-activate specific subsets of experts, creating stable, highly specialized functional partnerships that form early during pre-training and endure throughout model fine-tuning.
When pruning decisions rely solely on scalar importance rankings, an expert that appears marginally useful in isolation may be deleted, inadvertently severing a critical co-activation link required by an indispensable partner expert. As pruning rates scale past 20 percent toward aggressive 50 percent parameter reductions, the systematic destruction of these cooperative partnerships leads to catastrophic degradation on complex reasoning benchmarks.
Mathematical Derivation of HOPE’s Second-Order Quadratic Objective
To account for joint activation dynamics, Amazon researchers Alex M. Tseng, Prannay Kaul, Luca Zancato, Wei Xia, and Stefano Soatto derived HOPE to minimize an analytical upper bound on pruning error. When a subset of experts P is removed from a layer containing E experts, tokens that would have been processed by the pruned experts are redirected to replacement experts with the next-highest router gate weights.
Because true pruning error depends nonlinearly on the identity of dynamically chosen replacement experts, direct optimization is computationally intractable. The authors resolved this by constructing a tractable surrogate objective, Z, that bounds the primary component of layer output divergence:
Z = [ sum_{j in P and T(x)} g_j(x) ||f_j(x)||_2 ]^2
Here, g_j(x) represents the gating weight assigned to expert j for token x, f_j(x) is the expert output vector, and T(x) denotes the active top-K routing set. When this squared summation is expanded across all pairs of pruned experts, cross-terms emerge naturally: g_i(x) * g_j(x) * ||f_i(x)||_2 * ||f_j(x)||_2. These cross-terms quantify the joint penalty of simultaneously eliminating both expert i and expert j.
Minimizing the expectation of Z across a calibration dataset transforms expert selection into a binary quadratic programming (QP) problem: minimize p^T F p subject to p in {0, 1}^E and sum(p_k) = |P|, where p is a binary pruning indicator vector. The interaction matrix F captures both individual and cooperative importance. Its diagonal entries F_{k,k} reflect isolated expert magnitude, recovering REAP importance rankings with a Spearman correlation of rho = 0.988. Crucially, the off-diagonal entries F_{i,j} capture the average gate-weighted output product between co-activated pairs, penalizing the simultaneous removal of tightly coupled experts.
The resulting quadratic program is solved via continuous relaxation followed by binary rounding, requiring only one to two seconds of computation per layer using standard optimization solvers. Consequently, HOPE introduces virtually zero computational overhead beyond the initial forward calibration pass common to all pruning techniques.
Empirical Performance Across Coding and Agentic Workflows
The researchers evaluated HOPE across three open-weight architectures: Qwen3.5-122B, Qwen3.5-35B-A3B, and GLM-4.5-Air (featuring 128 experts per layer and 106 billion total parameters). Calibration was performed using two datasets: Evol-CodeAlpaca and trajectory traces from SWE-bench Verified. Pruned checkpoints were tested against four first-order baselines across pruning ratios spanning 10 percent to 50 percent, utilizing both the Tulu3 benchmark suite and SWE-Bench Pro.
Across all tested conditions, HOPE achieved the highest overall performance ranking among evaluated methods, finishing first in 39 percent of benchmarks and in the top two in 67 percent. As pruning aggressiveness increased, HOPE’s margin over first-order methods widened substantially. At a 50 percent pruning rate—halving the expert parameter count—HOPE attained an average rank of 1.58 across benchmarks, compared to 2.42 for REAP.
The performance differential proved most pronounced on SWE-Bench Pro, an agentic software engineering benchmark requiring multi-turn problem solving, tool interaction, and contextual code synthesis. On Qwen3.5-35B-A3B compressed to 50 percent expert capacity, HOPE achieved a score of 42.3, matching the 41.8 benchmark of the full, unpruned base model. In contrast, REAP fell to 36.2, representing a 13 percent performance collapse.
An analysis of disputed experts revealed that HOPE deliberately sacrifices certain individually high-scoring experts if their retention would break larger cooperative clusters. By preserving the structural cohesion of expert partnerships, HOPE maintains the multi-domain reasoning capacity necessary for autonomous software workflows.
Implications for Campus Computing and Open-Source Deployments
For university research offices, research computing administrators, and institutional high-performance computing facilities, HOPE provides a practical bridge between cutting-edge open models and hardware resource constraints. As researchers publish larger AI and machine learning research outputs, deploying frontier MoE checkpoints locally has become an operational hurdle.
By halving expert memory requirements without requiring fine-tuning or specialized hardware backends, HOPE allows 100-billion-parameter MoE architectures to execute on dual-GPU or quad-GPU workstations rather than dedicated multi-node clusters. The authors packaged their implementation as open-source software under the Apache-2.0 license, providing a three-stage command-line interface: calibration, QP solving, and checkpoint pruning.
Pruned models are exported as standard checkpoints fully compatible with Hugging Face Transformers, allowing immediate integration with specialized model serving engines such as vLLM and SGLang. Because the pruned checkpoints require no custom CUDA kernels or modified layer definitions, academic laboratories can preserve computational reproducibility across varied hardware environments. The research artifacts, evaluation scripts, and calibration tools have been released in a public code repository to support community verification.
Methodological Boundaries and Technical Considerations
The authors outlined several methodological constraints that researchers should consider prior to deployment. First, HOPE optimizes expert selection on a layer-by-layer basis; while the authors proposed a theoretical formulation for cross-layer joint pruning, cross-layer coordination remains preliminary and unvalidated at scale.
Second, HOPE models second-order (pairwise) interactions between experts. While third-order triplets or higher-order combinations could theoretically provide additional routing signals, estimating higher-order tensors across hundreds of experts becomes combinatorially prohibitive during calibration.
Finally, at conservative pruning ratios between 10 percent and 20 percent, the performance advantage of second-order optimization over first-order baselines is modest. HOPE demonstrates its primary utility under aggressive 40 to 50 percent pruning budgets, where preserving cooperative expert clusters is essential to preventing capability collapse.
Sources
- Hugging Face Blog: Your Experts Have Partners. There is HOPE for Keeping Them Together. https://huggingface.co/blog/amazon/higher-order-pruning-experts (Checked: 2026-11-14)
- arXiv: Higher-Order Pruning of Experts in Mixture-of-Experts Language Models (arXiv:2609.18916). https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.18916 (Checked: 2026-11-14)
- AWS Labs GitHub Repository: HOPE (Higher-Order Pruning of Experts). https://github.com/awslabs/HOPE (Checked: 2026-11-14)







