Skip to main content
v2026.11,986 entries · CC-BY 4.0

Editorial · CASRAI · Research integrity and misconduct

Journal of Further and Higher Education Retracts Its Editors’ Editorial Over Unverifiable References

Taylor & Francis retracted a 2026 editorial by a higher education journal’s editors on 12 November after it could not verify the references.

Published 19 Nov 2026· 7 minute read
Shelves of printed academic journals in a university research library reading room
Photo: African Studies Centre Leiden / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 (cropped). Source · Licence

Taylor and Francis retracted an editorial by the editors of the Journal of Further and Higher Education on 12 November 2026, after the publisher could not confirm that the article’s references and citations were valid, according to Retraction Watch on 19 November. The retraction follows a September report of fabricated citations and matters to any journal office, library or research integrity team that handles reference-list checks.

What happened

The article, “The examined institution: academic freedom, freedom of thought, and the politics of knowledge in Further and Higher Education”, was published online on 3 May 2026 and appeared in volume 50, issue 7 of the journal, pages 1133 to 1141, according to its Crossref record. Crossref lists three authors: Anastasia Christou, Rosalind Latiner Raby and Steve Lambert. Retraction Watch identifies Christou and Lambert as the journal’s coeditors and Raby as its deputy editor, and describes the piece as an editorial on attacks on academic freedom.

Crossref shows a separate “Statement of Retraction” for the article dated 12 November 2026, registered with the DOI 10.1080/0309877x.2026.2761821, and links it to the original through an update relationship of type “retraction”, with the publisher as the source. The original record’s title now begins “RETRACTED ARTICLE”.

Retraction Watch quotes the notice as saying that “the validity of the references and citations is integral to the scientific integrity of an article” and that the publisher is “therefore retracting the article”. The notice also states that “the authors agree with the retraction.” According to Retraction Watch, the publisher asked the authors for more details to verify the references, and their responses did not address the concerns, so the publisher could not determine whether the references were valid. The notice, as reported, does not rest on a finding about how the references were produced.

Key details

Item Detail
Journal and publisher Journal of Further and Higher Education, Taylor and Francis
Article online 3 May 2026 (Crossref)
Concerns reported 8 September 2026 (Retraction Watch)
Retraction statement 12 November 2026 (Crossref)
Interval from report to retraction 65 days
References examined in September At least 9 of 31 nonexistent or wrongly attributed

The September report found that at least nine of the editorial’s 31 references were nonexistent articles or carried incorrect journals or inaccurate author names. Some real scholars were linked to articles they did not write, and some real article titles were credited to the wrong authors. Passages from real articles were attributed to bogus references.

Retraction Watch’s September story gave named examples. John Skrentny of UC San Diego said he had “never published or submitted an article to the Journal of Higher Education”, the venue given for a 2025 paper on self-censorship credited to him. Brendan Cantwell of Michigan State University said a cited Higher Education Policy paper on academic freedom “is not something that I wrote.” Melanie Baak and colleagues told the outlet that a cited 2025 International Journal of Inclusive Education paper was “definitely the article that we wrote, but not the author team”, with different names given in the citation. Retraction Watch also reported that text paraphrased from Baak’s paper was attributed to the fake Cantwell paper.

Background and context

On 8 September, Taylor and Francis told Retraction Watch that its publishing ethics and integrity team was “investigating the concerns that have been raised” and declined further comment. The September story was later updated, on 21 September, to correct the journal’s name and acronym. The company’s author services guidance says it retracts an article where “a major error (e.g., in the methods or analysis) invalidates the conclusions in the article” or where “it appears research or publication misconduct has taken place”. It says retraction decisions are made “in accordance with both Taylor and Francis policies and COPE guidelines”, that the retracted version of record receives a “retracted” watermark, and that a separate statement titled “Retraction: [article title]” is linked to the article and paginated in the online issue.

The case is one of several recent reports of unverifiable references in published work. Retraction Watch’s November 19 story links earlier cases involving a Springer Nature paper (March 2026), a Journal of Academic Ethics paper (December 2025) and a World of Media paper (June 2025). On 16 November, Retraction Watch reported that Biology of Sport will correct papers by its editor-in-chief that include nonexistent references; PubPeer users had flagged at least six articles, and the editor denied using AI and blamed an early-career researcher who managed a shared reference database. Casrai has also covered an audit that estimated how many PubMed papers now cite fake references: see 1 in 277 PubMed papers now cite fake references.

Reaction

A Taylor and Francis spokesperson told Retraction Watch the publisher had nothing to add beyond the notice. Lambert, an associate professor at the University of Chester, had earlier said he was “unable to comment until the journal’s publishers have completed their investigation”. Retraction Watch notes that fake references can be a sign of artificial intelligence use because large language models such as ChatGPT are known to hallucinate references, and it does not state that AI was used in this editorial. Readers commenting on the Retraction Watch pages questioned why the editors had not stepped down; that is commentary, not a finding.

What it means for researchers, universities and research offices

For journal editors and editorial offices, the case shows that an editorial written by the editors is still a published article that can be retracted for reference problems alone. The retraction rests on references the publisher could not verify, not on a stated finding about data or conclusions, which is a different ground from the usual retraction process triggered by data problems. Editorial offices that exempt editor-written pieces from reference checks may want to review that practice in light of this case.

For authors and co-authors, the notice says the authors agreed with the retraction. A fake citation attributes real wording to a work that does not exist, and the harm falls on the real scholars named. Each author is responsible for confirming every entry in a shared reference list before submission, including entries inserted by a co-author or a writing tool.

For university research integrity offices and libraries, the practical step is to treat reference verification as a routine check: resolve each DOI or title against Crossref or a library catalogue, and confirm that author names and journals match. Where drafting tools are used, the publisher policy landscape on generative AI in manuscripts sets out disclosure expectations that journals now apply.

For researchers who cited the retracted editorial, the article remains in the record with its notice attached; the guide on what to do when a paper you cite gets retracted covers how to update a reference list and a manuscript in progress, and the comparison of retractions, errata and expressions of concern explains how each notice type differs.

What happens next

The retraction statement is registered in Crossref as an update to the original article, so reference managers, indexing services and retraction databases that read Crossref’s update data can flag the article as retracted. Taylor and Francis said the publisher had nothing to add beyond the notice. The September report noted that no statement from the wider editorial board had been published; research offices following the case should watch the journal’s page and Retraction Watch for any later announcement from the publisher or the authors’ institutions.

Sources

Ask CASRAI · free to try

Ask about this story

2 free questions a day, no account.

An AI assistant for research: funder rules, compliance, methods and publishing. It links the sources behind its answers and labels answers that come from a web search.

Answers draw on CASRAI's guides and dictionary plus the federal and funder documents we index: Federal Register, Grants.gov, Regulations.gov and UKRI.

Works on this site and inside Claude, Cursor and the AI tools you already use.

Everything CASRAI publishes — this page, the dictionary, the guides and the news — stays open to read, with no account and no card.

Referenced across the research world

University of Cambridge logoColumbia University logoCrossref logoUniversity of Edinburgh logoHarvard University logoUniversity of Oxford logoPrinceton University logoStanford School of Medicine logoUniversity College London logoORCID logoUniversity of Cambridge logoColumbia University logoCrossref logoUniversity of Edinburgh logoHarvard University logoUniversity of Oxford logoPrinceton University logoStanford School of Medicine logoUniversity College London logoORCID logo
  • University of Cambridge logo
  • Columbia University logo
  • Crossref logo
  • University of Edinburgh logo
  • Harvard University logo
  • University of Oxford logo
  • Princeton University logo
  • Stanford School of Medicine logo
  • University College London logo
  • ORCID logo

View CASRAI adoption →