Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board
Published · Last updated
On this page
COREQ has 32 items and is written for interview and focus-group studies; SRQR has 21 items and fits any qualitative design. Use COREQ when your data come from interviews or focus groups and the journal asks for it; use SRQR for other designs or when a journal accepts either. Both are reporting checklists: they say what a manuscript must disclose, not how to design or conduct the study. This page sets out the full COREQ 32-item checklist and SRQR 21-item checklist, where each came from, how they overlap, and how to submit either one.
COREQ vs. SRQR: which checklist applies
In summary, the SRQR checklist (Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research) has 21 items and fits any qualitative design, while COREQ (Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research) has 32 items and is written for interview and focus-group studies. Use COREQ when your data come from interviews or focus groups and the journal asks for it; use SRQR for ethnography, case study, document analysis and other designs, or when the journal accepts either.
| Checklist | Full name | Items | Source | Scope | Best fit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| COREQ | Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research | 32 | Tong, Sainsbury & Craig, International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 2007 | Interview and focus-group studies specifically | Health and clinical qualitative research using one-on-one interviews or focus groups |
| SRQR | Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research | 21 | O’Brien, Harris, Beckman, Reed & Cook, Academic Medicine, 2014 | Qualitative research generally, across designs | Grounded theory, ethnography, phenomenology, case study, and any qualitative design that isn’t specifically an interview/focus-group study |
Both are indexed and endorsed by the EQUATOR Network, the umbrella body that maintains the reference library of health-research reporting guidelines. Neither checklist tells you how to design or run a qualitative study — see qualitative research methods for that layer. What they specify is what a completed manuscript must state explicitly, so a reader can judge how the findings were produced without having to infer it.
A closely related third checklist, ENTREQ (Enhancing Transparency in Reporting the Synthesis of Qualitative Research), is easy to confuse with COREQ/SRQR but covers different territory: it applies to qualitative evidence synthesis — meta-syntheses and qualitative systematic reviews that aggregate multiple primary studies — not to a single primary qualitative study. If your paper reports original interviews, focus groups, or fieldwork, you want COREQ or SRQR. If it synthesizes findings across several already-published qualitative studies, ENTREQ is the relevant guideline instead.
Where each checklist came from
COREQ. Allison Tong, Peter Sainsbury and Jonathan Craig published COREQ in International Journal for Quality in Health Care 2007;19(6):349–357 (PMID 17872937). Their abstract reports that they compiled 76 items from 22 existing checklists and reduced them to a 32-item checklist in three domains: research team and reflexivity, study design, and data analysis and reporting. That is why the checklist reads as interview-centred: its design items cover interview guides, repeat interviews, field notes and returning transcripts.
SRQR. Bridget O’Brien and colleagues published SRQR in Academic Medicine 2014;89(9):1245–1251, titled “Standards for reporting qualitative research: a synthesis of recommendations” (DOI 10.1097/ACM.0000000000000388, PMID 24979285). The authors located published recommendations through PubMed, Web of Science and Google through July 2013, plus reference lists and expert suggestions. Two authors drafted items from a sample of the sources, the team revised the items and coded all sources, and five external reviewers gave feedback. The result is 21 items, each defined with examples. Because the items were synthesized across recommendations for qualitative research in general, they are not tied to one data-collection method.
ENTREQ. Tong, Flemming, McInnes, Oliver and Craig published ENTREQ in BMC Medical Research Methodology 2012;12:181 for reporting syntheses of qualitative research, a different document type from a primary study.
Which one does a given journal actually require
There is no universal rule, and checklist requirements vary by journal and by field, so the operational answer is always the same: check the target journal’s Instructions for Authors page before submission, and check it again if submitting to a different journal after a prior rejection. That said, a few patterns hold broadly:
- Health, nursing, and clinical journals disproportionately specify COREQ, largely because it was built directly around interview/focus-group methodology, which dominates clinical and health-services qualitative work.
- Education, social science, and general qualitative-methods journals more often specify or accept SRQR, since it was written to generalize across qualitative designs rather than assume one data-collection method.
- Some journals accept either, or ask only that authors follow a recognized reporting guideline appropriate to the study design without naming one — in which case COREQ is the safer default for interview/focus-group studies specifically, and SRQR for everything else.
- Qualitative evidence syntheses should use ENTREQ, not COREQ or SRQR, regardless of what the underlying primary studies used.
The COREQ 32-item checklist
COREQ organizes its 32 items into three domains. Authors are typically asked to submit a completed checklist alongside the manuscript, with a page/section reference for where each item is addressed.
Domain 1: Research team and reflexivity (8 items)
| # | Item | What it asks for |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Interviewer/facilitator | Who conducted the interview or focus group |
| 2 | Credentials | Researcher’s qualifications, e.g. PhD, MD |
| 3 | Occupation | Researcher’s occupation at the time of the study |
| 4 | Gender | Researcher’s gender |
| 5 | Experience and training | Researcher’s experience or training relevant to qualitative data collection |
| 6 | Relationship established | Was a relationship established with participants before study commencement |
| 7 | Participant knowledge of the interviewer | What participants knew about the researcher (e.g. personal goals, reasons for doing the research) |
| 8 | Interviewer characteristics | Characteristics reported relevant to the research topic, e.g. bias, assumptions, motivations |
Domain 2: Study design (15 items)
| # | Item | What it asks for |
|---|---|---|
| 9 | Methodological orientation and theory | Underlying methodology, e.g. grounded theory, discourse analysis, thematic analysis |
| 10 | Sampling | How participants were selected, e.g. purposive, convenience, consecutive, snowball |
| 11 | Method of approach | How participants were approached — face-to-face, telephone, mail, email |
| 12 | Sample size | Number of participants in the study |
| 13 | Non-participation | Number of people who refused or dropped out, and why |
| 14 | Setting of data collection | Where the data was collected, e.g. home, clinic, workplace |
| 15 | Presence of non-participants | Was anyone else present besides participants and researchers |
| 16 | Description of sample | Relevant demographic characteristics, e.g. age, gender, occupation |
| 17 | Interview guide | Were questions, guides, or activities pilot-tested |
| 18 | Repeat interviews | Were repeat interviews carried out; if so, how many |
| 19 | Audio/visual recording | Did the research use audio or visual recording to collect data |
| 20 | Field notes | Were field notes made during and/or after the interview or focus group |
| 21 | Duration | Duration of the interviews or focus groups |
| 22 | Data saturation | Was data saturation discussed |
| 23 | Transcripts returned | Were transcripts returned to participants for comment/correction |
Domain 3: Analysis and findings (9 items)
| # | Item | What it asks for |
|---|---|---|
| 24 | Number of data coders | How many coders analyzed the data |
| 25 | Description of the coding tree | Was a coding tree developed a priori or derived from the data |
| 26 | Derivation of themes | Were themes identified in advance or derived from the data |
| 27 | Software | What software, if any, was used to manage the data |
| 28 | Participant checking | Did participants provide feedback on the findings (member checking) |
| 29 | Quotations presented | Are participant quotations presented and identified, e.g. participant number |
| 30 | Data and findings consistent | Is there consistency between the data presented and the findings |
| 31 | Clarity of major themes | Are major themes clearly presented |
| 32 | Clarity of minor themes | Is there a description of diverse cases or minor themes |
The SRQR 21-item checklist
SRQR is organized by manuscript section rather than by domain, which is one reason it generalizes more easily across qualitative designs beyond interviews and focus groups.
| # | Item | What it asks for |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Title | Concise description of the nature and topic of the study; identifying the study as qualitative or the specific approach used is recommended |
| 2 | Abstract | Summary of key elements using the abstract format of the target journal |
| 3 | Problem formulation | Description and significance of the problem/phenomenon studied; review of relevant theory and empirical work |
| 4 | Purpose or research question | Purpose of the study and specific objectives or questions |
| 5 | Qualitative approach and research paradigm | Qualitative approach (e.g. ethnography, grounded theory, case study) and guiding theory, if any; rationale |
| 6 | Researcher characteristics and reflexivity | Researchers’ characteristics that may influence the research, including personal attributes, qualifications, experience, relationship with participants |
| 7 | Context | Setting/site and salient contextual factors |
| 8 | Sampling strategy | How and why research participants, documents, or events were selected |
| 9 | Ethical issues pertaining to human subjects | Documentation of approval by an ethics review board, informed consent, and other confidentiality/data-security issues |
| 10 | Data collection methods | Types of data collected, details of data-collection procedures including duration |
| 11 | Data collection instruments and technologies | Description of instruments and devices used for data collection; changes made during the study |
| 12 | Units of study | Number and relevant characteristics of participants, documents, or events included |
| 13 | Data processing | Methods for processing data, e.g. transcription, data entry, verification, anonymization |
| 14 | Data analysis | Process by which inferences, themes were identified and developed, including researchers involved |
| 15 | Techniques to enhance trustworthiness | Techniques used to enhance credibility and trustworthiness, e.g. member checking, triangulation, peer debriefing |
| 16 | Synthesis and interpretation | Main findings, presented with sufficient contextualizing data |
| 17 | Links to empirical data | Evidence documenting how findings connect to the data |
| 18 | Integration with prior work, implications, transferability, and contribution(s) | How findings connect to existing literature, practice, and policy |
| 19 | Limitations | Trustworthiness and limitations of findings |
| 20 | Conflicts of interest | Potential sources of influence or perceived influence |
| 21 | Funding | Sources of funding and other support; role of funders in design and conduct |
What the two checklists overlap on
The data table below the article crosswalks the items by reporting topic. In short, both checklists ask you to describe researcher characteristics and reflexivity (COREQ items 1–8, SRQR item 6), the methodological approach (COREQ 9, SRQR 5), sampling (COREQ 10, SRQR 8), the setting (COREQ 14, SRQR 7), data-collection procedures, the analysis process (COREQ 24–27, SRQR 14) and a technique for strengthening trustworthiness such as member checking (COREQ 28, SRQR 15).
They diverge in two directions. SRQR alone has items for ethics approval and consent (item 9), limitations (item 19) and conflicts of interest and funding (items 20–21), as well as problem formulation and the abstract. COREQ alone drills into interview mechanics: whether the interview guide was pilot-tested, whether interviews were repeated, whether field notes were made, how long sessions lasted, whether saturation was discussed and whether transcripts were returned. A study of interviews can therefore satisfy COREQ and still omit its ethics statement, which is why an ethics statement should be written regardless of which checklist applies.
Worked example: choosing for three study designs
- Semi-structured interviews with clinicians: COREQ fits directly, because items 17–23 describe exactly what such a study produces (guide, recording, field notes, duration, saturation, transcripts). If the journal accepts either, add the ethics, limitations and funding statements that SRQR would require.
- Ethnographic fieldwork with participant observation: COREQ items about interview guides and transcript return have no natural answer; SRQR’s items on sampling of ‘documents or events’, units of study and data processing do. Use SRQR unless the journal names COREQ.
- A meta-synthesis of published qualitative studies: neither; use ENTREQ.
How the checklist submission actually works
- Draft the manuscript first, complete the checklist against it. The checklist is a disclosure audit, not a drafting template — write the paper following normal qualitative reporting practice, then go item-by-item and confirm each one is addressed somewhere in the manuscript, noting the page or section number.
- Submit the completed checklist as a separate file at manuscript submission, typically alongside the cover letter and manuscript file. Most journals that require COREQ or SRQR provide (or link to) the official checklist template as a fillable table; check the journal’s author guidelines for the exact submission mechanism rather than assuming.
- Reference the item location, don’t just check a box. Reviewers and editors use the checklist to locate specific disclosures quickly; a checklist entry that reads ‘item 22, saturation, p. 6, paragraph 2’ is far more useful, and more credible, than one that just marks every item complete with no page reference.
- An item can legitimately be not applicable. Not every study design produces an answer for every item (item 18, repeat interviews, being a common example for single-session designs). State that explicitly rather than leaving it blank, which reads as an oversight rather than a design fact.
What the checklist doesn’t do
Completing COREQ or SRQR demonstrates transparency of reporting — it does not, by itself, establish that the underlying research was well-designed or rigorously conducted. A study can fully satisfy every checklist item while still having a thin sampling rationale or an underdeveloped coding process; conversely, a methodologically strong study can be marked down at review for incomplete reporting even when the underlying work was sound. For the substantive rigor criteria that sit behind several checklist items — credibility, transferability, dependability, and confirmability — see how those are established in practice in the qualitative research methods guide and in triangulation in research.
The EQUATOR Network entries for COREQ, SRQR and ENTREQ state the same usage notes: a reporting guideline says what to include, not in what order to write it; it is neither a study-design tool nor a tool for appraising the quality of a study; and when you use one you should cite the guideline itself. Many journals ask for the completed checklist at submission.
Getting the checklist: Word, PDF and translations
Authors searching for a “SRQR checklist Word” or “COREQ checklist download” usually want a fillable file to attach at submission. The EQUATOR Network SRQR entry cites the original paper (O’Brien BC, Harris IB, Beckman TJ, Reed DA, Cook DA. Academic Medicine 2014;89(9):1245-1251) and points to the detailed item descriptions in the article’s supplementary material; it also lists a French version of the checklist. The EQUATOR Network COREQ entry cites Tong A, Sainsbury P, Craig J. International Journal for Quality in Health Care 2007;19(6):349-357, and lists Spanish and Portuguese (Brazil) translations alongside the English original. The EQUATOR entries for these checklists do not offer a Word download themselves, so a fillable copy usually comes from the journal’s author guidelines or the articles’ supplementary files; use the journal’s version when it provides one, because that is the form its editors expect to receive.
Common mix-ups in searches
- COREQ meaning: the acronym stands for Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research. It is a reporting checklist, not a research method.
- SRQR vs. COREQ: they overlap on researcher reflexivity, sampling, data collection, analysis and trustworthiness, but SRQR also asks for problem formulation, ethics, limitations, conflicts of interest and funding, while COREQ goes deeper on interview mechanics such as interview guides, field notes and transcript return.
- Checklist vs. quality appraisal: a reporting checklist tells readers what you disclosed. How credible the work is depends on the rigor techniques described in trustworthiness in qualitative research.
- Other designs: reporting a survey rather than interviews calls for a different guideline, such as the one in the CHERRIES checklist for internet e-surveys.
Frequently asked questions
Is COREQ or SRQR mandatory for publication?
It depends entirely on the target journal. Many health and social-science journals require one as a condition of peer review, others recommend but don’t require it, and some don’t mention either. Always check the specific journal’s author guidelines rather than assuming; a checklist required by one journal in a field is not necessarily required by every journal in that field.
Can I use COREQ for a grounded theory or ethnography study?
COREQ was built specifically around interview and focus-group methodology, so its items (e.g. interview guide pilot-testing, transcript duration) map less cleanly onto observational fieldwork or document-based case studies. SRQR’s items are written at a level that generalizes better across designs. If a journal doesn’t specify, SRQR is usually the better fit for non-interview qualitative designs.
What’s the difference between COREQ/SRQR and ENTREQ?
COREQ and SRQR report a single primary qualitative study. ENTREQ (Enhancing Transparency in Reporting the Synthesis of Qualitative Research) reports a synthesis across multiple already-published qualitative studies — a qualitative meta-synthesis or qualitative systematic review. Using COREQ or SRQR for a synthesis paper, or ENTREQ for a primary study, is a mismatch reviewers will flag.
Do I need IRB/ethics approval documentation even if the checklist doesn’t ask for it directly?
Yes — SRQR item 9 asks for it explicitly, and COREQ’s domain 2 items on setting and sampling are typically read alongside a separate ethics-approval statement most journals require regardless of which reporting checklist applies. See research ethics in qualitative research for what that documentation needs to cover.
Where do I find the official checklist templates?
The EQUATOR Network keeps the guideline entries and links to the original publications. Its COREQ and SRQR entries do not host a Word file, so use the template your journal links to, or build a table of item numbers with a page reference column from the articles’ item lists.
Is there a Word version of the SRQR or COREQ checklist?
Journals commonly supply their own fillable file; the EQUATOR entries list translations (Spanish and Portuguese for Brazil for COREQ; French for SRQR) rather than a Word template.
Do I have to cite COREQ or SRQR in my paper?
Yes. EQUATOR’s usage note for each guideline is to cite the guideline when you use it, in the methods section or wherever your journal places reporting statements: Tong et al. 2007 for COREQ, O’Brien et al. 2014 for SRQR.
Does a completed checklist prove my study is good quality?
No. EQUATOR describes these guidelines as reporting tools, not quality-appraisal tools. A completed checklist shows what you disclosed; readers still judge credibility from the methods you describe.
Should I use COREQ or ENTREQ for a qualitative systematic review?
ENTREQ, which was published for syntheses of qualitative research. COREQ is for primary interview and focus-group studies.
Sources
Sources (accessed 2026-11-14):
- COREQ, EQUATOR Network
- SRQR, EQUATOR Network
- Tong A, Sainsbury P, Craig J. COREQ. Int J Qual Health Care 2007;19(6):349–357
- O’Brien BC et al. SRQR. Acad Med 2014;89(9):1245–1251
- Tong A, Flemming K, McInnes E, Oliver S, Craig J. Enhancing transparency in reporting the synthesis of qualitative research: ENTREQ. BMC Med Res Methodol 2012;12:181.
Item text is summarized from the COREQ and SRQR publications and the EQUATOR Network entries; confirm journal-specific requirements in the journal’s author guidelines. For more on this, see CASRAI’s guide to empirical research.
Data: COREQ and SRQR item crosswalk by reporting topic
Maps reporting topics to the COREQ (2007, 32 items) and SRQR (2014, 21 items) item numbers that address them, compiled by comparing the item wording of the two published checklists as set out in the original articles and the EQUATOR Network entries.
Period covered: 2007/2014.
| Reporting topic | COREQ item numbers | SRQR item numbers | Covered by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Researcher characteristics and reflexivity | 1-8 | 6 | Both |
| Methodological approach or theory | 9 | 5 | Both |
| Sampling | 10 | 8 | Both |
| Setting or context | 14 | 7 | Both |
| Number and description of participants | 12, 16 | 12 | Both |
| Data collection procedures and instruments | 17-21 | 10-11 | Both |
| Analysis process and software | 24-27 | 14 | Both |
| Trustworthiness techniques (member checking) | 28 | 15 | Both |
| Quotations and links to data | 29 | 17 | Both |
| Ethics approval and consent | none | 9 | SRQR only |
| Limitations | none | 19 | SRQR only |
| Conflicts of interest and funding | none | 20-21 | SRQR only |
Sources
- COREQ, EQUATOR Network (accessed 2026-11-14)
- SRQR, EQUATOR Network (accessed 2026-11-14)
- Tong et al. 2007 COREQ abstract (accessed 2026-11-14)
- O'Brien et al. 2014 SRQR abstract (accessed 2026-11-14)
Compiled by CASRAI from the sources above. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution.







