Written and maintained by CASRAI Editorial Board
Published · Last updated
On this page
A reflexivity statement is a short passage in a qualitative manuscript, usually in the Methods section, that names the researcher’s characteristics, relationship to participants and assumptions, and says how they were accounted for. It typically runs one paragraph of three to six sentences. The SRQR and COREQ reporting standards both ask for this information.
A positionality statement and a reflexivity statement are the written artifact: the actual paragraph (or short section) where a researcher names their social location in relation to the study and explains how it was accounted for methodologically. That is a narrower question than the ethical and reporting obligations behind it, covered in CASRAI’s Research Ethics in Qualitative Research guide, or how reflexive commentary gets woven into ethnographic narrative prose, covered in Ethnographic Writing Conventions. This guide is the template-and-example page: what the reporting standards ask for, what to write, where it goes, and what a defensible one looks like. The data table below the guide compares COREQ, SRQR and the AMEE Guide No. 149 on year, venue, size and where each addresses reflexivity.
Positionality vs. reflexivity: quick reference
| Term | What it refers to | What appears in the manuscript |
|---|---|---|
| Positionality | The researcher’s own social location: discipline, institutional role, and personal characteristics (for example professional background, insider/outsider status relative to the population) relevant to the study. | A short statement naming that location and its likely relevance to access, rapport, or interpretation. |
| Reflexivity | The ongoing practice of examining how that position is shaping data collection, analysis, and interpretation, rather than treating the researcher as a neutral instrument. | A statement (often the same paragraph as the positionality statement) describing what that examination found and what was done about it, for example a reflexive journal, peer debriefing, or member checking. |
| Reflexive journal / field diary | A private, ongoing record kept throughout data collection and analysis. | Not published itself. It is the evidence base the reflexivity statement draws on and can be cited as a methodological control. |
In practice, most published qualitative papers combine positionality and reflexivity into one statement rather than two: a sentence or two naming who the researcher is in relation to the study, followed by a sentence or two on how that was managed. The rest of this guide treats them as one combined artifact.
What the reporting standards actually ask
Two EQUATOR Network-listed reporting guidelines are the main reason this has become a near-standard expectation rather than an optional disclosure.
- COREQ (Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research; Tong, Sainsbury and Craig, International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 2007) is a 32-item checklist for interviews and focus groups. The authors gathered 76 items from 22 existing checklists and organised the final list into three domains, the first of which is “research team and reflexivity”. The other two cover study design and data analysis and reporting. The EQUATOR Network describes its scope as qualitative interviews and focus groups, applied to the whole report.
- SRQR (Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research; O’Brien, Harris, Beckman, Reed and Cook, Academic Medicine, 2014) is a 21-item checklist designed to be flexible across paradigms, approaches and methods, developed from a literature search through July 2013 and review by five external reviewers. It carries a dedicated item, “Researcher characteristics and reflexivity” (item S6).
The SRQR item asks authors to describe how researchers’ characteristics may influence the research. The checklist names the elements: personal attributes, qualifications and experience, relationship with participants, and assumptions and presuppositions, together with the potential or actual interaction between those characteristics and the research questions, approach, methods, results and transferability. A complete statement therefore touches each of those elements, or says briefly why one does not apply.
How the statement connects to neighbouring SRQR items
| SRQR item | What it asks for | How the reflexivity statement relates |
|---|---|---|
| S5: Qualitative approach and research paradigm | The approach and the paradigm underlying the study | The way the statement treats the researcher’s influence should match the declared paradigm (see below). |
| S6: Researcher characteristics and reflexivity | Personal attributes, qualifications and experience, relationship with participants, assumptions; their interaction with questions, approach, methods, results, transferability | This is the statement itself. |
| S15: Techniques to enhance trustworthiness | Techniques such as member checking, triangulation and audit trail, and why they were chosen | The “what did I do about it” sentence can point to the techniques reported here. |
| S20: Conflicts of interest | Conflicts of interest | A separate disclosure; it does not replace the reflexivity statement. |
| S21: Funding | Funding | Also separate. |
Journals that ask authors to follow COREQ or SRQR are, in effect, requesting this disclosure as part of reporting completeness rather than as an optional reflective aside.
Four dimensions to consider
AMEE Guide No. 149, “A practical guide to reflexivity in qualitative research” (Olmos-Vega, Stalmeijer, Varpio and Kahlke, Medical Teacher, 2023; online April 2022), describes reflexivity as an ongoing, collaborative practice of examining how subjectivity and context shape research, and discusses personal, interpersonal, methodological and contextual factors. The guide’s abstract also covers the purposes of reflexivity under different paradigms and strategies for reporting it. Used as prompts for a statement (an editorial adaptation, not the guide’s own checklist), the four dimensions become questions:
- Personal: which of my own background, training or beliefs bear on this question?
- Interpersonal: how did my relationship with participants, colleagues or co-researchers shape what was said and heard?
- Methodological: how did my choices of design, sampling, interview guide and analytic approach shape what the data could show?
- Contextual: what institutional, political, cultural or disciplinary setting framed the study and its audience?
The methodological dimension is the main difference between reflexivity and positionality. Positionality describes who the researcher is; reflexivity also examines the choices the researcher made.
Reflexivity depends on the paradigm
What a reflexivity statement is for differs by research tradition, which is why SRQR asks for the paradigm (S5) alongside the researcher characteristics (S6). In reflexive thematic analysis, Braun and Clarke describe researcher subjectivity as a resource for analysis rather than a bias to be removed, so a statement in that tradition explains how the researcher’s perspective informed the analysis and does not claim to have neutralised it. In approaches that use a codebook and several independent coders, the methodological response typically includes coder agreement or consensus procedures, and the statement says so. Whatever the tradition, the wording should be consistent with the paradigm declared elsewhere in Methods: a paper that calls subjectivity a resource in one paragraph and promises bias elimination in the next will read as incoherent.
A drafting workflow
This workflow is an editorial recommendation consistent with the ongoing view of reflexivity in AMEE Guide No. 149.
- At proposal stage: write a first version answering the four template questions below. It records the expectations held before data collection, which cannot be reconstructed honestly afterwards.
- During fieldwork and analysis: keep a dated reflexive journal, with an entry after each interview, observation session or analysis meeting, noting reactions, surprises and moments where assumptions steered a follow-up question.
- At write-up: revise the statement against the journal, keeping only the points that plausibly bear on the findings, and match the length and placement to the target journal.
A reusable template
A defensible statement answers four questions, in roughly this order. Treat each as a prompt to fill in, not a rigid formula:
- Who am I in relation to this study? Relevant professional role, disciplinary training, institutional affiliation, and any personal characteristic (shared or differing from participants) that plausibly affected access, rapport, or interpretation, not an unbounded personal biography.
- What is my relationship to the participants or setting? Insider (member of the population or setting studied), outsider, or somewhere between; any prior relationship (colleague, clinician, prior collaborator) that existed before the study began.
- What assumptions or expectations did I bring in? Named briefly and specifically (a disciplinary lens, a prior hypothesis, a professional stake in the outcome) rather than a generic disclaimer that biases exist.
- What did I do about it, methodologically? The concrete step or steps taken to manage the influence named above: a reflexive journal kept throughout fieldwork, peer debriefing, member checking, an audit trail, bracketing interviews before analysis, or an independent second coder. A statement that names a bias but describes no methodological response reads as disclosure without rigor.
Where it goes in the manuscript
Placement is discipline- and journal-dependent; there is no single universal rule, but three patterns cover most cases:
| Manuscript context | Typical placement |
|---|---|
| Interview/focus-group studies following COREQ (health services, nursing, medical education) | Woven into the Methods section, often under a “Research team” or “Data collection” subheading, alongside interviewer details and any prior relationship with participants; frequently a paragraph rather than a separately labeled statement. |
| Broader qualitative designs following SRQR (grounded theory, phenomenology, case study) | A short paragraph in Methods, sometimes under an explicit “Researcher characteristics and reflexivity” or “Reflexivity” subheading. |
| Ethnography, autoethnography, participatory action research, and much education and critical-qualitative work | Frequently a standalone “Positionality Statement” section, sometimes placed before Methods rather than inside it. Conventions here are journal- and field-specific, so check recent issues of the target journal. |
When a target journal has no explicit house convention, a short paragraph at the start of Methods (or its own labeled subsection immediately after it) is a sensible default, since that is where a reader expects researcher-characteristics information when judging how the data were produced. For the separate disclosure about where the underlying data can be found, see these data availability statement samples.
Worked examples
Illustrative examples only. These are composite, generic statements written to show structure and are not drawn from or attributed to any real study, author, or institution.
Example: insider-researcher, health-services interview study
The first author is a registered nurse with eight years of clinical experience in the inpatient unit where recruitment took place, and had a prior collegial relationship with several potential participants before the study began. This insider position likely supported rapport and candor in interviews, but also risked participants moderating their responses out of concern for how disclosures might be perceived by a colleague. To manage this, the first author did not interview any current direct reports, disclosed her clinical role explicitly at the start of each interview, and kept a reflexive journal noting moments where her clinical assumptions appeared to shape a follow-up question; entries were reviewed with a co-author with no clinical role at the site during weekly debriefs throughout data collection.
Example: outsider-researcher, ethnographic/education study
The researcher entered the field site as an outsider: a doctoral student with no prior affiliation to the school district, no shared racial or linguistic background with most participating families, and an institutional position (university-based researcher) that carried different social capital than that of the teachers and parents in the study. This distance likely limited access to informal, backstage talk available to a known community member, but also reduced the risk that participants would shape responses around an existing relationship. The researcher addressed this by extending fieldwork to fourteen months to build trust incrementally, using a local research assistant for initial introductions, and returning transcribed field notes to three key participants for member checking before analysis.
Example: a statement that fails, and its repair
Also an illustrative composite. A weak version reads: “The author is a White, middle-class woman and acknowledges that this may have influenced the study.” It names identity but not effect, relationship, assumption or response. A repaired version supplies the four elements: “The author, a physiotherapist by training, interviewed other physiotherapists about workload. Shared professional language aided rapport but may have led participants to skip explanations they assumed were obvious; the interview guide was therefore piloted with a non-clinical colleague, and the author asked for explanations of routine terms even when she knew them.”
Reviewer checklist
This is an editorial self-check mapped to the SRQR item S6 elements, not part of any standard. A statement is ready when each answer is yes:
- Does it name the researcher’s relevant attributes, qualifications and experience (not a full biography)?
- Does it describe the relationship to participants or setting, including any pre-existing one?
- Does it state the specific assumptions or presuppositions held at the outset?
- Does it say how those characteristics may have affected the questions, approach, methods, results or transferability?
- Does it name a concrete methodological response that is also reported in the trustworthiness part of Methods?
- Is it consistent with the paradigm declared in the same paper, and placed where a reviewer will find it?
Common mistakes
- Naming identity without naming effect. “I am a White, middle-class researcher” states positionality but not reflexivity: it does not say how that position plausibly shaped the study or what was done in response.
- No methodological response. A statement that identifies a potential bias but describes no concrete step (journaling, debriefing, member checking, bracketing) reads as performative disclosure.
- Autobiography. Life history with no link to the research questions, access or interpretation adds length without information.
- Using reflexivity to excuse weak methods. Acknowledging a limitation is not a substitute for a design that addresses it, and a reflexivity statement is not the Limitations section.
- Confusing this with a conflict-of-interest or funding disclosure. Reflexivity concerns interpretive influence on the research itself; COI disclosures concern financial or professional interests (SRQR items S20 and S21). Most journals require both, separately.
- Treating it as one-and-done. AMEE Guide No. 149 frames reflexivity as ongoing. A reflexive journal kept during fieldwork produces a more specific statement than one written from memory afterward. For how the analysis itself is done, see coding qualitative interview data.
- Placing it somewhere a reviewer won’t find it. Researcher-characteristics information belongs in Methods, where the reporting standards place it.
Frequently asked questions
What is a positionality statement in qualitative research?
A short section or paragraph, usually in the Methods section, where a researcher names their own social location (discipline, institutional role, and any personal characteristics relevant to the study population) and its likely relevance to access, rapport, or interpretation of the data.
Is a reflexivity statement required by COREQ or SRQR?
Both checklists ask for it. COREQ has a “research team and reflexivity” domain for interview and focus-group studies, and SRQR has a dedicated item, “Researcher characteristics and reflexivity”, for qualitative designs generally. Neither mandates a section label, but a journal that requires COREQ or SRQR compliance is in effect requiring this content somewhere in the manuscript.
How long should a positionality or reflexivity statement be?
Most journal-article versions run one short paragraph, roughly three to six sentences: who the researcher is in relation to the study, the relationship to participants, the assumption or assumptions that mattered most, and the concrete step taken to manage them. Standalone “Positionality Statement” sections in ethnography, participatory research or a dissertation can run longer; some guides suggest several hundred words for a dissertation. Padding with generic biography is a common and avoidable weakness.
Where does a reflexivity statement go?
Usually in Methods, under a researcher-characteristics or reflexivity subheading, or as a standalone section in ethnographic and critical traditions. Check the target journal’s recent issues.
What’s the difference between a positionality statement and a reflexivity statement?
Positionality is about who the researcher is in relation to the study; reflexivity is the ongoing practice of examining how that position, and the researcher’s methodological choices, shape the research and documenting what was done about it. Most manuscripts combine both into a single statement.
Do quantitative papers need a positionality statement?
Not conventionally. Positionality and reflexivity statements are a qualitative-methods convention tied to interpretive and constructivist paradigms, where the researcher is understood as an active instrument of interpretation. Mixed-methods papers typically include one for the qualitative strand.
Is a reflexivity statement the same as the limitations section?
No. Reflexivity explains how the researcher’s characteristics and choices may have shaped the study and what was done about it, in Methods. Limitations discuss what the findings cannot support. They can cross-refer but should not be merged.
Can I write it in the first person?
Yes. First person is a standard, accepted context for these statements; see Using First Person (“I”) in a Research Paper.
Should I disclose protected characteristics such as race, religion or disability?
Disclose characteristics that plausibly bear on access, rapport or interpretation in this particular study, and say how. The characteristics are the researcher’s choice to share; the reporting standards ask how characteristics may influence the research, not for a full demographic profile.
Related CASRAI guides
- Research Ethics in Qualitative Research: Consent, Confidentiality, and Positionality: the ethical and reporting obligations behind positionality and reflexivity, including power dynamics and consent.
- Ethnographic Writing Conventions: how reflexive commentary is woven into narrative prose rather than confined to a single statement.
- Writing the Qualitative Methods Section: where the positionality/reflexivity statement fits within the broader Methods section.
- How Qualitative Research Papers Deviate from IMRaD Structure: for standalone-statement placement questions.
- Using First Person (“I”) in a Research Paper: positionality and reflexivity statements are one of the accepted contexts for first-person voice.
- Thematic Analysis: A Step-by-Step Guide: where reflexivity re-enters as a rigor criterion during coding and analysis.
- IMRaD Example: a full illustrative IMRaD outline with representative section content and a checklist.
Sources
- Tong A, Sainsbury P, Craig J. Consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative research (COREQ): a 32-item checklist for interviews and focus groups. International Journal for Quality in Health Care 19(6):349-357, 2007 (PMID 17872937), via Europe PMC: https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/search?query=EXT_ID:17872937%20AND%20SRC:MED&format=json&resultType=core
- O’Brien BC, Harris IB, Beckman TJ, Reed DA, Cook DA. Standards for reporting qualitative research: a synthesis of recommendations. Academic Medicine 89(9):1245-1251, 2014 (PMID 24979285), via Europe PMC: https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/search?query=EXT_ID:24979285%20AND%20SRC:MED&format=json&resultType=core
- EQUATOR Network, SRQR checklist: https://resources.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/srqr/srqr-checklist.html
- EQUATOR Network, COREQ: https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/coreq/
- Olmos-Vega FM, Stalmeijer RE, Varpio L, Kahlke R. A practical guide to reflexivity in qualitative research: AMEE Guide No. 149. Medical Teacher 45(3):241-251, 2023, doi:10.1080/0142159X.2022.2057287.
Data: Qualitative reporting guidance that addresses researcher reflexivity: scope and reflexivity element
Compares COREQ, SRQR and the AMEE Guide 149 on year, venue, size and where each addresses researcher reflexivity. Compiled from bibliographic records (Europe PMC) and the EQUATOR Network checklist pages.
Period covered: 2007/2023.
| Guidance | Year published (year) | Journal | Items in checklist (items) | Stated scope | Where reflexivity appears |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| COREQ (Tong, Sainsbury, Craig) | 2007 | International Journal for Quality in Health Care | 32 | Interviews and focus groups | Domain 1: research team and reflexivity (of 3 domains) |
| SRQR (O'Brien et al.) | 2014 | Academic Medicine | 21 | Qualitative research across approaches and paradigms | Item: researcher characteristics and reflexivity (Methods; with approach/paradigm and trustworthiness items) |
| AMEE Guide No. 149 (Olmos-Vega et al.) | 2022 | Medical Teacher | n/a | Reflexivity practice in qualitative research, health professions education | Whole guide: personal, interpersonal, methodological and contextual reflexivity; reporting strategies |
Sources
- Europe PMC record: COREQ (PMID 17872937) (accessed 2026-11-14)
- Europe PMC record: SRQR (PMID 24979285) (accessed 2026-11-14)
- EQUATOR Network: SRQR checklist (accessed 2026-11-14)
- EQUATOR Network: COREQ (accessed 2026-11-14)
Compiled by CASRAI from the sources above. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution.







