
On November 21, 2026, European Council President António Costa circulated a revised 2028–2034 Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF) negotiating box compromise in Brussels that retains €158 billion in current prices for the post-2027 Horizon Europe successor programme, establishing the baseline framework for upcoming summit negotiations following earlier debates over FP10 framework programme funding and the European Parliament ITRE committee budget vote.
What Happened: President Costa Circulates Compromise Negotiating Box
In a formal transmission to member state delegations announced via the European Council compromise proposal, President Costa released his revised negotiating text for the European Union’s seven-year budgetary framework. The proposal aims to bridge deep divisions between net-contributor states demanding fiscal restraint and capitals advocating expanded public investment for economic renewal, security, and industrial competitiveness.
To secure a consensus ahead of ministerial debates, President Costa reduced the European Commission’s overall multiannual budget package by roughly 10%, cutting planned expenditure by approximately €204 billion in current prices to establish a €1.78 trillion ceiling (equivalent to €1.58 trillion in 2025 constant prices). However, as reported in Science|Business reporting, the revised framework leaves the research and innovation envelope untouched, holding the line at the €158 billion baseline first tabled by the Irish Council presidency in October 2026.
Under Costa’s blueprint, the post-2027 framework programme (designated FP10) will sit within a newly structured European Competitiveness Fund while preserving its established independent governance, peer-reviewed evaluation systems, and dedicated focus on basic research.
Key Details: Budget Allocations, Competitiveness Fund, and Off-Ceiling Reserves
The €158 billion allocation is calculated in current prices across the 2028–2034 budgetary cycle. In 2025 constant prices—the baseline utilized by Council budget technicians to eliminate projected inflation—the commitment equates to roughly €140 billion. In real terms, this delivers a 57% increase over the €95.5 billion allocated to the 2021–2027 Horizon Europe cycle.
Despite this substantial nominal expansion, the Council proposal sits 9.6% below the European Commission’s €175 billion blueprint from July 2025 and remains far short of the €200 billion baseline adopted by the European Parliament. The table below illustrates the evolving negotiating positions across European institutions:
| Institutional Position or Programme Milestone | Total Envelope (Current Prices) | 2025 Constant Prices | Negotiating Role |
|---|---|---|---|
| Horizon Europe Baseline (2021–2027 Framework) | €95.5 billion | ~€89.0 billion | Current operational programme law |
| European Commission Initial MFF Proposal (July 2025) | €175.0 billion | €155.0 billion | Initial executive proposal |
| European Parliament ITRE Committee Mandate (October 2026) | €200.0 billion | €177.0 billion | Parliament negotiating mandate |
| Irish Council Presidency Negotiating Box (October 2026) | €158.0 billion | €140.0 billion | Preliminary Council compromise |
| European Council President António Costa Proposal (November 2026) | €158.0 billion | €140.0 billion | Active European Council text |
Critically for universities and research institutions, the draft negotiating box safeguards Pillar I programmes, ring-fencing the European Research Council (ERC) and Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions (MSCA) against reallocation into applied commercial ventures. Broader institutional participation will remain aligned with the overarching Horizon Europe funding framework.
In parallel, the proposal keeps the Erasmus+ higher education mobility programme at €39 billion, rejecting attempts to redirect mobility funding into vocational streams. Costa also maintained a dedicated, off-ceiling Ukraine Reserve of up to €100 billion, preventing emergency geopolitical funding requirements from displacing scheduled civilian research lines.
Background and Context: Competing Visions from Commission to Parliament
The negotiations over the 2028–2034 MFF follow intensive economic debates sparked by Mario Draghi’s report on European competitiveness and Enrico Letta’s single market review. Both former prime ministers concluded that the European Union faces severe productivity deficits compared to the United States and East Asia, warning that closing this gap requires doubling public research investment to at least €200 billion.
The European Parliament embraced this analysis, voting overwhelmingly across committee sessions to establish a €200 billion floor for FP10. Parliamentarians insisted that research funding must remain fully insulated from repayment costs associated with NextGenerationEU pandemic recovery debt.
However, net-contributor member states—including Germany, the Netherlands, Austria, and Sweden—pushed in the opposite direction during Council working groups throughout autumn 2026. These capitals argued that rising domestic fiscal pressures necessitate capping the total EU budget near 1.0% of EU Gross National Income. Costa’s text represents an attempt to strike an acceptable midpoint: by paring back regional cohesion envelopes while shielding science, the Council presidency hopes to secure unanimous agreement without sacrificing Europe’s research core.
Stakeholder Reaction: Research Alliances and Parliament Push Back
While research leaders welcomed the Council’s refusal to subject Horizon Europe to horizontal budget cuts, stakeholder reactions remained highly critical of the retreat from the Commission and Parliament targets. In an analysis released following the announcement, engineering university alliance CESAER policy analysis stressed that freezing research allocations at €158 billion threatens Europe’s ambitions in dual-use tech, quantum systems, and sustainable materials.
In the European Parliament, leading political groups signaled intense legislative resistance. An official position paper from the EPP Group in the European Parliament warned that capping research at €158 billion undermines long-term competitiveness, emphasizing that MEPs are prepared to withhold consent on the MFF regulation if the Council does not demonstrate greater financial ambition.
University rectors also registered deep concern over persistent low success rates. In a public statement, the League of European Research Universities pointed out that Horizon Europe currently rejects thousands of high-scoring proposals every year due to budget exhaustion. LERU warned that failing to provide at least €175 billion will exacerbate researcher brain drain to North America and China, leaving universities without adequate support for top-tier scientific infrastructure.
What It Means for Researchers, Universities, and Research Offices
For higher education institutions, principal investigators, and research development officers, Costa’s negotiating box provides programmatic stability while confirming that securing European funding will remain highly competitive.
First, research administration teams must plan for intense proposal competition. With FP10 capped at €158 billion, success rates for collaborative consortia are unlikely to rise significantly above current single-digit thresholds. Research offices will need to emphasize early proposal development, rigorous internal peer review, and compliance with the complex multi-party requirements established under the European grant agreement structure.
Second, the preservation of the ERC and MSCA ensures that individual investigator-led frontier research remains protected. Faculty pursuing fundamental research can structure long-term scientific programmes knowing that ERC excellence criteria will not be displaced by short-term industrial impact metrics.
Third, sponsored programmes offices should prepare for broader administrative simplification. Costa’s negotiating text urges the Commission to accelerate grant onboarding, reduce reporting friction, and broaden lump-sum grant models across multidisciplinary consortia, requiring university research managers to adapt their pre-award costing and milestone-tracking systems accordingly.
What Happens Next: Special European Council Summit and Interinstitutional Talks
The publication of the negotiating box sets the stage for a critical European Council summit in Brussels on November 26–27, 2026. EU heads of state and government will examine Costa’s compromise text, aiming to achieve a unanimous consensus on the seven-year financial parameters before the end of the year.
If the Council reaches agreement, formal interinstitutional negotiations with the European Parliament and Commission will begin in early 2027. Under Article 312 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, the MFF regulation requires the European Parliament’s formal consent, giving lawmakers substantial leverage to push for additional research funding.
In parallel, the European Commission will present the detailed legislative proposal for FP10 in mid-2027, initiating co-decision negotiations on specific research missions, thematic clusters, and participation rules ahead of the scheduled programme launch on January 1, 2028.
Sources
- European Council: Multiannual financial framework: President Costa’s proposal, checked 2026-11-22
- Science|Business: Latest Council budget proposal keeps €158B for next Horizon Europe, checked 2026-11-22
- EPP Group in the European Parliament: New EU budget proposal will hold Europe back, checked 2026-11-22
- CESAER: EU budget talks must protect what makes Europe strong, checked 2026-11-22
- League of European Research Universities: Europe cannot afford to underinvest in its future, checked 2026-11-22







